Luminous/pearly finishes — it can be hard to find, particularly at sub-$30 price points. I love shine, creaminess, and a little shimmer in my lip color.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Pat McGrath. Tom Ford.
To a lesser extent, Charlotte Tilbury.
Long wearing, yet not over-drying (like matte liquid lipsticks). I’ve gotten rid of most of my matte liquid lipsticks because my lips have become very sensitive over the past year or so and I just can’t handle drying formulas anymore.
As for colors, I’m a huge sucker for “dead” shades, like greys, taupes, cool-toned browns. I also love cool/dark purples and unique shades like dark blue or green.
Matte or cream formulas
Nudes, light rosy pinks or peachy nudes and peachy corals
Sheers, semi sheer, opaque. All are good to me
A really good dark lipstick in a cream or semi-matte finish. Any shade as long as it’s deep and vampy, doesn’t settle into lip lines nor bleeds.
Even coverage and, of course, fun colors. I don’t have a single favorite finish/level of pigmentation (depends on the shade), but I do also enjoy lipsticks with fine shimmer!
I prefer a creamy or satiny finish over matte, both for feel and look. No nude lipsticks for this lady and the same for odd colours like blue, green, brown, etc. Cool shades in reds or berry tones (MAC Craving, Smashbox Red Rage and UD F-Bomb sort of illustrate my favourite colours) and sometimes, a slightly warmer or browned red – Guerlain Habit Rouge or UD Mrs. Mia Wallace – works well for autumn/cooler weather.
Matte & satin finishes that don’t look cakey/crumbly or shrivel my lips.
Opaque, full coverage, not patchy/streaky super dark colors like navy, burgundy, and eggplant.
Non-trad colors like blue, green, gray.
Creamy color with good coverage. Shimmery or creamy finish. Fuchsia and other bright colors, unconventional colors, unique finishes such as sparkles, duochromes, metallics. I also have a weakness for rosy-brown nudes.
Non-drying, creamy but with very smooth, even coverage is my favorite type of formula, ie; PMG Luxetrance or most UD Vice Comfort Matte and Cream Lipsticks. A weakness for great reds, coral-nudes, and purples/plums is also a very real thing for me! A bit of shimmer or luminosity never hurts when it comes to reeling me in, either!
Lipsticks that have that “juicy” look to them (without having to use gloss over) – vivid pigmentation, satin creme finish and a little bit of sheen. Something that lasts well and doesn’t have a horrible scent is a bonus too.
Oh my, lipsticks are my weakness ! I don’t know why I am such a sucker for lipsticks ,especially Chanel . My issue is finding ones that don’t seep in to my lip lines right away . I’m with you on the shine and touch of shimmer , Christina. Thus I usually always combine two lipsticks .
Thin, medium coverage, hydrating formulas that smooth the lips and have a nice shine. Like Chanel rouges or Guerlain Kiss Kiss. Expensive weakness!
My favorites at this moment are the velvet finish liquid lipsticks the ones that aren’t completely transfer proof but don’t suck the life out of your lips. Like the Huda Beauty Liquid Mattes or the Kylie Cosmetics Velvet Liquid Lipsticks. I really love the Jeffree Star formula for a full on transfer proof finish. I had purchased his Summer Collection 16 and he mixed watermelon flavor into the liquid lipstick and it messed up the formula. I was disappointed and hadn’t bought any other of his lipsticks since then. I decided to take a chance and try the Mini Velour Liquid Lipstick set of nudes he recently released with 8 shades and I love them all. For a traditional lipstick I really love the Tarte Color Splash Lipsticks. For Gloss I’m into the Huda Beauty Lip Strobes and the Kylie Cosmetics and Anastasia Beverly Hills glosses. Toppers I love Lime Crime Diamond Crushers they are so iridescent,metallic, and sparkly. Every time I wear one I get tons of compliments they are just really different and eye catching. Obviously I’m have a serious lipstick obsession??♀️
Mlbb shades. Especially pinky nudes, brown nudes, dusty roses, warm mauves. I have the same colors in like 50 versions.
I like luminous finishes too, but I rarely venture over the $30 line for lipstick – what would you recommend for a splurge?
Pat McGrath’s lip line has been amazing. The last matt lip glosses that I purchased came with little pots of glitter that you pat on before the lip gloss dries down, the effect is amazing, you can put as much or as little glitter on as you want. I just put a little hint on and it stays on for hours and the colors of the lip glosses are so nice I just can’t get over how nice they are, I’m obsessed.
Where do I start? I just love creamy, glossy lipsticks – not mattes at all. My particular weakness is in bronzy brown russet shades and reds. I also like ginger shades too.
My favourite brands are Milani (Colour Statement), Elizabeth Arden Ceramide, some Maybelline’s and Clarins Joli Rouge.
Shimmer, metallic and a bit sheer. Emolliant. My colors are most ranges of cherry and rose. Not too bright.
Christine, I totally agree with you on the luminous pearly finishes, shine, creaminess, and shimmer preferences. Revlon and Cover Girl used to have great options in those areas, but not so much in recent years. NYX Round lipsticks still cover all of those bases, not long lasting, but I can reapply, and the price is very reasonable.
I’ve been enjoying Bobbi Brown Luxe lipsticks in the last year.
Brands: MAC, Tom Ford, NARS Audacious, Pat McGrath (LuxeTrance)
I like a creamy feel, satin finish and a very subtle shimmer.
Like you I am looking for a creamy comfortable feel on the lips, and luminosity but doesn’t have to be high shine. Sometimes I want opaque and other times a sheer color is good, depending on time of day and occasion. I like a range of colors but not the off the beaten path ones like white/black/blue/green/grey. Absolutely non-drying or it doesn’t have a chance. I’d prefer a formula that doesn’t last a lot of hours and needs to be re-applied to one that lasts but looks cakey and or dries my lips.
Gray-purples and muted berry shades, I’m a sucker for those regardless of price point! Still looking for the perfect dupe of ELF’s “Dusty Rose” aka my favorite lipstick ever.
I prefer mattes I don’t find they dry my lips at all wearing Chapstick under everytime. I collected most of WetnWild colors and really love them they stay put and even after eating or drinking a nice stain remains on lips so I like them for that very same reason they don’t disappear easily and I can always choose to put a little gloss on top or not. But I’ll take lipsticks in any shape or form they are my main weakness followed by blush and eyeshadows. Some of my favorites are Cherry Picking, Cherry Bomb, Mauve Outta Here. Bare it all is a beautiful light natural shade and a light Peachy one they have are gorgeous but nudes don’t look too good on me being pale I like it bright. Really love them! Their pencil lip stains are great too beautiful shades! Liquid lipsticks are good also but for my next purchases I’ll be sticking to lipsticks. I find liquid ones a bit more of a challenge to apply on corners of lips. On WetnWild just wish the cap would stay better put but being careful I don’t mind when the quality is awesome for the price. ?
I look for paraben-free, as ‘clean’ as possible list of ingredients, since basically we end up eating it.
Beyond that I want everything, and haven’t found it yet: precise definition, a plump smooth look, long lasting, uber flattering color, and I like me some pearl/shimmer, too. PML, Tilbury and Guerlain are on my list to try.
I love a good matte that is realtively easy to use and won’t dry out my lips. Something that doesn’t settle in the creases and is truly all day wear.
I love nourishing lipsticks that have a creamy, satiny finish, and the colours that make me swoon are the subdued raspberry shades that make me lips look extra full and kissable.
Pale cool pinks, true purples in a light to medium shade, pure netural beige and brown.
I LOVE frosted/Pearl lipsticks ! My go to (I’ve bought probably 100) since its been out is Revlon #420 Blushed. Also love Revlon Wine With Everything (Pearl) !!