Your Mission: Tell us what you love, hate, or are otherwise indifferent to about colored mascaras. Do you use them all the time? What are your favorites (or least favorites)?
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
They dry up waaaaaaay too quick. At least the Urban Decay ones do. I’ve taken to just mixing eyeshadow with clear mascara/brow lacquer whenever I want colored lashes.
I don`t have colored mascara, only brown and black MAC Sudio Fix Lash Mascara
I love colored mascara. Because I already have black lashes, colored mascara adds some fun to my looks.
I dont like it i dont think it shows up too great nor am i that adventurous…. But hey by all means enjoy it if you like it!!
I LOVE the idea of colored mascaras, and when they’re done right, I think they wear beautifully. My gripe with them is that most times they aren’t pigmented enough so you end up wearing them, but not really being able to tell much of a difference save some splattered, random color on your eyelashes that is sparse in some places but lovely in others.
No matter the color, my lashes will look black. On vary rare occasions when I can get some color to show up, I feel my lashes look diseased. lol I’m completely a black mascara girl!
I love colored mascaras!!! the best for me are the ones from YSL, I have on in blue and one in purple and trust me they are very very pigmented!!!the colors are amazing!! I’m waiting the wonder woman collection so I can buy the green one!! =)
I usually wear them if I use matching eyeshadows but they are gorgeous with a pale-neutral eyeshadow , so the color of the lashes is the first thing you note about the eyes …
I use black on everyday, but sometimes blue if i want something different.
And i have blue eyes, so it looks cool, i like a maxfactor one! 🙂
I like purple/violet mascaras. Lancome Fatale was my favourite, now I have YSL Faux Cils waiting in line.
i love electric blue and deep purple colored mascaras. but the wands they usually come with really suck! They’re also not so obvious on black lashes so I have to use a few layers and, even then, the color’s noticeable only from up close.
I love everything about colored mascaras except that they’re too expensive for how fast they dry up.
i don’t necessarily wear mascara in really bold colors ( i had a guerlain one in purple which i loved but it dried up way too quickly to justify the hefty price tag), but i loooooove wearing dark blue mascara. it’s lovely. makes my blue eyes pop and the whites of my eyes appear brighter while still not looking over the top. it’s softer than black, but bolder and with a more eye-defining effect than brown. lancôme hypnose precious cells has the prettiest dark blue. in normal lighting, it looks almost black on my lashes , but when the sunlight hits it, you can tell it’s blue. i get a ton of compliments on it.
i do wish i had a nice purple though…
Colored mascaras are wonderful! You just have to wear them on top of MAC Prep & Prime lash (a white base). On top of being good for and elongating your lashes, it provides that white base and helps the color come through true to color!
I always have 5 or 6 colored mascaras in my stash. I agree with you MoLo, the UD ones dry out way too fast!… However, I have some MAC ones from years ago that I still use (even today I am wearing the Blue Mythic, a zoom lash, can’t remember what collection it came with…) and they are in fine shape. I am excited for the Wonder Woman colored mascaras, especially the green one as, green is not a color done a lot. Although Givenchy released a khaki one last year or so and I purchased it but that’s not really a green one!
By dar, Christian Dior’s Azure blue mascara is the best HANDS DOWN! I love how bright it is and it goes on silky smooth… i’ll do a natural look and add this color just to spice it up.. A DEF MUST HAVE!
I like them – they amuse me. I do wonder if other people think it is a bit wierd if they notice I have green eyelashes.
I only have two colored mascaras, the blue Phenomen’Eyes from Givenchy and the BADgal lash in plum from Benefit. I love my blue one for nighttime looks, especially layered on top of black mascara. My lashes are really light so it doesn’t show up well on its own. And the plum mascara is great for a more natural look. It just darkens my lashes slightly so it looks like I’m not wearing mascara at all and my lashes are just naturally that gorgeous 🙂
I LOOOOVE colored mascara! It’s my fav way to amp up a look! The best one I have ever had i got for $3 from wet and wild. It’s a crazy amazing electric blue. Unfortunately it was LE, but i hope they bring it back.
I love the IDEA of them, but have yet to wear a colored mascara. I owned one in my teens.
The only time I could see myself wearing it is when creating a EOTD, photoshoots or when I want to look festive..
I really like them for a subtle bit of color in an otherwise-neutral eye. Sam from Pixiwoo has a great tutorial where she uses a blue mascara with an otherwise very bare eye. As an added twist, she uses a glitter liner on the lashes themselves, so they sparkle just a tiny bit when the light hits them the right way. It’s very pretty!
I find using lash primers helps the color show up quite a bit.
Here’s that Pixiwoo tutorial I mentioned, just in case anyone wants to see it!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVyP2rcOT90
I tried the Barry M ones, and my eyes have never been in that much pain before… Horrible, but at least they look cool! =D
For some reason, I associate colored mascara with being in high school or younger and playing with makeup. I haven’t used any since that time in my life. I don’t really have any desire to either.
My very first mascara was a blue one – paired with blue and pink eyeshadow… uh, I was young (13) and that is 20 years ago ^^
But since that time I don’t like coloured mascara any more. It is nice to see when used in a special MakeUp (like you did with the eyeshadow palettes and mascaras from the MAC Wonderwoman LE), but I wouldn’t use them any more 🙂
I love wearing black on my top lashes and a color mascara on the bottom lashes. Blue and purple mascara are my favorite. When I wear it like that the colored mascara really makes my eye color POP! I have blueish/green eyes. Everyone should try this!!!
I will never understand colored mascara. I have yet to meet some one who finds it sexy. Its like the blue lipstick that was hot for like minute. Did anyone other than lady gaga ever buy into that? Its cool for halloween not much else.
I hate colored mascara ,
I do not understand the point of making my lashes look blue , violet or green !
I dunno , when it comes to mascaras I go for the blackest black ones ,
My favs are Diorshow Blackout and YSL faux cils volume effect in Noir Radical
I ordered the purple mascara from the Wonder Woman collection. I hope it looks as nice as it did in the look Christine did with it :).
There is also a recent video by MakeupbyTiffanyD where she uses a turquoise-ish mascara from Benefit and it looked really good.
I’d love to try it out… but my lashes are so dark I’m afraid the color won’t show up.
I think I’m the only person that loves them! I love to experiment with colourful eyeshadow and having colourful mascara is a bonus! UD just recently discontinued their line and they were my favs!! I think everyone has this ‘They are only for little kids’ stigma when it comes to using them but actually I think deep blue tones look gorgeous for a night out and don’t look tacky!
Love J.
Hate it.
This is a great topic as I’m hesitating to get colored mascara.I think it can make yr eyes look wider w blue or warmer w brown or plum or funky w very outrageous colours 🙂
I loooove coloured mascara! I prefer using them as a final touch. After applying black or bown maskara, I go for a coloured one only at the final lenght os the lashes. It gives a sparkle of the colour I chose, it is so much fun!
They look silly on me with my dark lashes. It just looks like I put on mascara and got eyeshadow fallout all over my lashes. I prefer to wear my color on my lids.
Went through a phase of wearing blue mascara when I was about 14/15. Boots 17 mascara in Electric Blue, it was brilliant!!
I love the concept of them, but quite often the colors are too subtle to notice.
I like colored mascaras because I get bored easily and I like to change things up and try different makeup colors. I also think they can be very pretty and flattering. I’m eager to try the MAC Wonder Woman ones. I have Benefit Bad Gal mascaras in blue and plum, and they’re just okay. A good green mascara is hard to find.
I was a teenager in New Jersey in the 80s and I can’t even look at colored mascara without remembering my giant permed hair and turquoise and magenta eyeshadow with turquoise mascara! I thought I was SOOOO cool… But now it gives me makeup PTSD.
I like them when I see other people do looks with colored mascara, but I just don’t think I could pull it off. I’d feel like a clown.
I don’t like clear mascaras, it’s not that noticeable and it doesn’t make a huge difference to your make up
I used to hate them and think they are tacky but I got a great dark red MAC one. It’s really fun and makes my eyes look BLUE
Never really show up…..
LOVE colored mascaras. <3
I have a UD Blue Indigo, I bought for $2.00 from Hautelook and when I received it was really, really dry…since it was only $2 and I tried to put 2 drops of lenses solution into the mascara and it worked really well! Now I can use and I really love!
I don’t really like colored mascara…I think that nothing is as great as black mascara.
Colored mascaras don’t look all that great on me unfortunately but my mom is downright OBSESSED with them. It’s the only makeup item she wears. Flirt used to have a pretty neat color selection but they were discontinued.
they never show up on my dark lashes 🙁 i have yet to find any that i love…..I want some though!
I love colored mascaras. Myfavorite blue right now is Kat Von D’s in Techno. It’s a bright blue and I love it! Sometimes I will do it all blue and others I will do black on top and the blue on the bottom. I would love a bright purple instead of the darker ones usually available. Any suggestions? I’m interested in seeing the green Wonder Woman as well.
I wish they’d work (mainly purple/blue) but so far not much success.
I don’t like colored mascaras for the same reason I don’t like pink and purple hair. They don’t lookm natural. I prefer hair and lashes that look like they could be your natural color or are at least a color that real hair can be.
Colored mascara was my high school trademark back in the 90’s. Blue, purple, silver, green, I had a different color for every day of the week. I have blond eyelashes, so they really show up. I bought a cheap pink one last year, but it’s just not me anymore. That doesn’t mean I wasn’t eyeing the Wonder Woman ones, though.
I like them when they show up, but all too often they aren’t pigmented or thick enough to show up.
When I was in high school, I used to wear bright orange-red mascara from a brand called Sweet Georgia Brown. I used to love that stuff so much.
I like it when it’s purple mascara or even better burgundy mascara! This is why I’m so sorry I missed out on the recent burgundy Zoom Lash from MAC Stylishly Yours collection. I’ve heard that the Benefit Bad Gal Plum mascara isn’t really a good formula at all in general, but I did try on the YSL burgundy mascara once and it did look good on me. I guess I gotta really fork over the cash for the YSL one then eventually! Hmmm….
Not a huge fan, but I do own Smashbox Bionic Mascara in Indigo Ink that I got in a Smashbox set that is actually quite nice. Not overly noticeable but does add a nice touch when doing a dark blue look, or even a very natural look to make the white of your eyes look a bit whiter. Wouldn’t purchase on my own, but nice to have.
Use to wear mascara. Only like the dark blue mascara. Royal blue was ok, but the dark blue colors were nice. I loved Stendahl. But that brand I think no longer exists.
Tell us what you love, hate, or are otherwise indifferent to about colored mascaras. Do you use them all the time? What are your favorites (or least favorites)?
I’ve always loved color, especially with eyeliner and mascara although I haven’t tried many colors for mascara.
I’ve only used black, brown and blue mascara and I definitely enjoyed the brightness of the blue. The only downside I find is color coordinating colored mascara with other make up, unless you’re going for a colorful/rainbow look. Otherwise I’d just have colored mascara alone.
It’d be nice if you reviewed some colored mascaras, I’ve seen turqoise and purple and would love to try em.
I love colored mascaras. My first experience was with Sephora’s outdated Pink/Sephora Girl collection. They had colors like yellow, kelly green, blue, etc. in little tubes. The pigmentation was great. Bloody Mary (a special effects brand) has the best white mascara I have tried. Hard Candy’s Lash Call is probably the best overall brand for it. I have it in the hot pink (Punk) and also the teal color (Mermaid?). They’re AMAZING. The fiberized mascaras from Hard Candy aren’t as great, as far as color goes. (Buxom’s blue is pretty great, but it bleeds.)
The BEST primer I’ve found for colored mascara is actually lotion. I wet my lashes down and shape them into little spikes with a bit of body lotion, then brush the color over them. A lot of colored mascaras don’t apply well to bare lashes, and apply all clumpy and just to the tips. The lotion solves this for me.
AWESOME! Thanks for so many suggestions 😀
Have you tried any of Anna Sui’s colored mascaras? I looovvee the packaging and they seem to be excellent, but I’m not about to drop so much cash for mascara that doesn’t show up on my dark lashes :/
i honestly think colored mascara looks kinda tacky- kiddish more for young teens. black mascara looks the best. but if you like it that’s all that matters!
I love colored mascaras! I own two tubes of bright blue & the new purple Victorious from MAC. I touch them to the tips of my lashes so I don’t have screamingly colored lashes, but just a hint of “something” there that always makes people stop and look longer. It really does wonders for my green eyes!
No way… Black only, and the blacker the better !
I love it. I especially love estee’s colored mascaras. They really pick up the colors in your eyes
I love benefit bad gal in plum. I have green eyes and it really brings out the color. I wear it more often than black mascara.
I really odn’t see the point to using a colored mascara, never have and I never will.
I like them, especially purple. As I mentioned in an earlier post, they seem to be getting harder to find.
Colored mascara are for adventurous people and I am not. I stick to traditional black.
I never/ dont have colour mascara.
Only Dior black.
I find colour dont suit me. Only black.
Omg… remember the colored mascara wands for your HAIR? Haha, wow. Flashback!
Anyway, I’m not into colored mascara. I’m actually pretty conservative when it comes to makeup… I mean I’ll wear a darker look that’s somewhat bold (for me, at least) but it usually consists of neutral shades. I think if I were more skilled at applying makeup, I would be more adventurous. I’ve noticed the better I’ve gotten, the more comfortable I am trying new colors. Still.. they’re limited to eye shadow only! And liner, kinda. I keep the crazy colors for my nails.
OMG I remember those! (the hair ones)
Holy flashback…
I am a big fan of colored mascaras especially dior number 258 and of course ysl mascaras the best choice for colored lashes.I think the worst shiseido
lovelovelove! especially the ones from Pupa and the vibrant blue ysl 🙂
Would LOVE to find one that showed up – I’m a sucker for color, and I’d like to try matching my dyed hair, haha.
So far only one from LA Splash has done any good for me. I used to use Bourjouis Oui au Volume when it came in purple, which was ridiculously colored AND volumnizing, but alas it has gone the way of the dinosaurs :(.
i wear a royal blue mascara all the time and have for years. i always get people commenting and complimenting me on it. Most of the time i wear the dior non waterproof as thats the best i can find but years ago you could even get a maybelline in a royal blue but they discontinued it probably 10 years ago. 🙁