Archived Post
Survey Says... April 28th, 2010
- What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
- What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
- What’s your favorite water line liner?
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
106 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Black Track Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Smolder
What’s your favorite water line liner? Stila Eye Kajal
I use Revlon CS liners for upper and lower lash line,but do not line the water line.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Givenchy Parad’eyes liner in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
MAC Pearglids…all shades 🙂
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Guerlain Terracotta powder Khol…all shades 🙂
I was literally JUST thinking that the next time you had a Q&A I would ask this! Specifically about water line liner…what IS your favorite??
My fav for Upper Lash is MAC Liquidlast Liner in any and all colors…that stuff does not move!
Lower Lash: Chanel’s Long Lasting Liner in Jade- Gorgeous!
Water Line: I’ve been using MACs Technakohl, but I’d love to hear other suggestions!
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? L’Oreal Lineur Intense in Black Mica
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Milani Liquif’eyes in Gold and Silver or UD 24/7 liners
What’s your favorite water line liner? UD 24/7 liners, in Stash, Bourbon, and Gunmetal. L’Oreal HIP Chrome liner in Violet Volt
Meeeh maybe sounds quite dumb but what is the difference between lower
and water lash liner I thought was the same thing.
Waterline is the “rim” part, the lower lash line is on and under the lashes 🙂
Ooh didn’t know that you can wear it under the lashes is that
for a kind of Smokey look of for people that don’t like
eyeliner in the water line? but u need too use different kinds
then?
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Urban Decay 24/7 haven’t tried one I don’t like or Stila smudge pot (esp little black dress)
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Urban Decay 24/7 in Underground
What’s your favorite water line liner?
don’t do
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? NYC Black liquid liner (cheap and works like a charm)
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? UD 24/7 liner in El Dorado
What’s your favorite water line liner? Don’t really line my water line that much anymore so…N/A 🙂
oh my gosh i have to agree with you on the NYC black liquid liner ..why spend more than two dollars on a liquid liner when this one works so well .
you’re the first !
i’m shocked by how many people don’t know about this liner ..
🙂
Upper: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline.
Lower: Don’t use regulary (I use eyeshadow most of the time) but if I did use I would do it with Blacktrack too!
Waterline: MAC Smolder & Feline.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Teddy Kohl is most versatile
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? –
What’s your favorite water line liner? I hope it will be the Chromagraphic Pencil in NC15/NW20 but I have not got it yet.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
– Stila Smudge Pot in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
– Urban Decay Zero & plain matte black eyeshadow smudged in
What’s your favorite water line liner?
– Urban Decay Zero
Upper lashline: Black Track Fluidline as well! I never use anything on my lower lashline.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
MAC FLuidline…any shade depending on the rest of my namekup theme.
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
I usually just use the same shadow I’m using ontop…the darkest shade.
What’s your favorite water line liner?
MAC Kohl. But I also love Avon liners.
Upper lash line – mac blacktrack fluidline.
Lower lash line – Dior crayon liner.
Waterline – ud 24/7 liner!
Upper lashline: loreal linear intense or mac black track fluidline
lower: I usually use an eyeshadow or mac pearlglides!
Waterline: makeupforever aqua eyes or urban decay zero
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Kat Von D felt tip eyeliner In black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Tokidoki eye Khol in the monkey one 🙂
What’s your favorite water line liner? Mac Feline
Great survey! I haven’t had the opportunity to try higher end ones but here are mine:
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? I like to use NYX eyeshadow in “Black”, wet with an angle brush. A good cheap gel liner on is by Wet n’ Wild too!
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? I usually use eyeshadow for this too! Or MAC Feline
What’s your favorite water line liner? Milani Color Brillance pencil in Black
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Definitely Guerlain Terracotta powder Khol. My favorite is a limited edition, oriental bronze. But I also love the other shades.
Woops! Sorry for the typos- RUSHING! ♥ ;]
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Loreal Lineur Intense
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7 in Zero
What’s your favorite water line liner? Mac Smolder
* What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
I really love Pupa’s Multiplay liner, it’s pigmented and long-lasting and it makes a great base for eyeshadow if necessary. I also adore Bobbi Brown’s gel liner.
* What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Urban Decay’s 24/7 liners!
* What’s your favorite water line liner?
TiGi’s pencil liner, can’t remember what it’s called.
upper lash line: maybelline ultra liner
lower lash line: any eyeshadow (typically NYX black) or pearlglides
water line: MAC feline kohl power
Buxom Lashliner
Eyeshadow, applied with an eyeliner brush
Urban Decay 24/7 liners
Upper: UD or MAC pencils or MAC fluidline
Lover: UD or MAC pencils
Waterline: UD
Upper lash: bourjois kohl & contour or mac pearlglides
Lower lash: i use mac e/s in espresso
Waterline: benefit eyebright
upper – MAYBELLINE ASHBLAST
LOWER- MAYBELLINE GREAT LASH
WATERLINE- UD zero eyeliner
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? I use urban decay
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? 24/7 glide liner
What’s your favorite water line liner? for all these purposes
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Fluidlines as my lashline touch my crease and fluidlines won’t transfer, (even 24/7 liners and pearlglides will end up transfering during they day, i still love them though as i love colour) plus they dry quickly and give me a nice crisp defined line which i love on my upper lashline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Eyeshadows, as these give a softer look which i prefer on my lower lashline.
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Fluidlines as they tend to have a long wear time so no need to reapply every 10mins, plus you rarely get that big glob of transfered liner in your inner corners that i hate.
Guerlain powder Khol is slowly creeping into the lead tho as it also lines my top waterline which makes my lash line look amazing plus it has great staying power, just need to practice my application a bit more before it becomes my HG.
Hi Linda,
I’m not sure if it’s safe to apply fluidline to your waterline area…Can anyone confirm?
Better safe than sorry 😉
My favourite upper lash liner is Urban Decay’s liquid liner in Perversion. I just bought the L’Oreal Lineur Intense felt tip liner…not sure about it yet! It’ll take some getting used to but I’ve been hearing great things about it.
For my lower lashes, I usually just use Urban Decay’s Primer Potion and apply eyeshadow with a small angled brush.
For my waterline, I am currently using CoverGirl’s Perfect Point Plus eyeliner and am very impressed! I normally use UD’s 24/7 eyeliners though.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? L’oreal Lineur Intense Carbon Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7 Pencil in Bourbon
What’s your favorite water line liner? Lise Watier Waterproof Eye pencil in Blanc
🙂
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
MAC Blacktrack Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Any waterproof coloured pencil liner 🙂
What’s your favorite water line liner?
MADminerals gel liner because it lasts all freaking day!
Coastal Scents Gel Liner, Milani Liquif’eye or UD 24/7!
I actually prefer Milani, but if I need a color they don’t have I use UD 24/7 with Sephora’s Eyeliner Last/Sealer.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC blacktrack fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? I usually smudge in the fluidline and Urban Decay shadow in Perversion for a slight smokey look
What’s your favorite water line liner? again, MAC blacktrack fluidline (this is the only thing so far that stays on almost all day on my waterline)
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? – MAc Point Black Liquidlast Liner
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? – MAC Feline and MAC pearlglide liners
What’s your favorite water line liner? – MAC Feline
Upper Lash liner: Smashbox cream liner palette (10 shades!) or Shiseido liquid liner pen in black
Lower lash: MAC waternymph e/s with a pencil or angle liner brush
Water line: MAC technakhol liner in auto-de-blu or graphblack
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Usually leave my upper lash line alone, but MAC eye kohls or Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Pearlglide liners or Stila Eye Kajal
What’s your favorite water line liner? Fluidline
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Wet ‘n’ Wild Creme Eyeliner in black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
MAC Pearlglide Eyeliner Pencils
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Loreal HIP Cream Eyeliner
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Fluidline in Rich Ground
I almost never put liner on my bottom lids tho’ I’ll smudge some eyeshadow. And I never line my waterline, makes my eyes look too small and squinty.
blacktrack fluidline, raven kohl power or any eyeshadow, and i mac greasepaint stick in black, YES AS A WATERLINER
* What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
A MAC MUA put Blactrack Fluidline on and I liked it, but I’m afraid I couldn’t make it look as good. Other wise I don’t line this area, it never looks good.
* What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
I don’t line this area.
* What’s your favorite water line liner?
MAC Feline
upper – Smolder (MAC) for a pencil or Bobbi Brown gel liners
lower – Smolder
water line – Stila Kajal in Onyx!
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Urban Decay Bourbon
I don’t line mine lower lash and my waterline,cause my eyes can’t take it:(
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Indelible gel liner in Black Cherry and Black Out.
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Lately I haven’t been using liner on my lower lash line. But when I do It’s Urban Decay 24/7.
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Urban Decay 24/7 in Yeyo and Deviant.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?- Lash Stiletto Liquid Liner or UD 24/7 Pencils, OR Bobbi Brown gel liner
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Pearlglides or UD 24/7 pencils
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Feline and Stila Onyx Kajal on top of Feline!
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Fluidline/ Feline/ Smolder
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Fluidline
Upper lashline: Kat Von D liquid eyeliner in black.
Lower lashline: Urban Decay 24/7 pencils, though I usually just use eyeshadow on my lower lashline.
Waterline: MAC Eye Kohl.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Black TrackFluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Powerpoint
What’s your favorite water line liner? MUFE Aqua Eyes OR BlackTrack Fluidline
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? HIP Black Cream liner
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7 any color
What’s your favorite water line liner? Urban Decay 24/7 zero
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Chanel Crayon des Yeux in Coffee Bean or Lancome’s Artliner in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MUFE Light Taupe
What’s your favorite water line liner? Laura Mercier for lop waterline, HIP kohl’s for all over, MUFE for lower without Kohl’s
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Blacktrack FluidLine
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Smolder
What’s your favorite water line liner? UD 24/7 Liner Zero
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Fluidline Blacktrack
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? I don’t use a liner for my lower lash line, I always use an eyeshadow to match my look
What’s your favorite water line liner? UD 24/7 Glide on Pencil
Favorite upper lash liner: UD 24/7 in zero
Favorite lower lash liner: MAC teddy
Favorite water line liner: Stila Kajal in topaz and pear-glide
undercurrent, kohl power eye pencil in raven
Engraved Powerpoint Eye Pencil by MAC for all three! 🙂
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Mac – Fluidline in Blacktrack
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Engraved
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Mac – Fluidline in Blacktrack
1.lineur intense by L’Oreal
2.Urban Decay in anycolor or Makeupforever 23L
3.either makeupforever or urban decay
upper lash liner? …MAC Blacktrack FluidLine
lower lash liner?….MAC Smolder or Feline
water line liner? ….UD 24/7 Liner in Zero/ MUFE Aqua Eyes
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Maybelline EyeStudio Gel Liner in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
MAC Pearlglides
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Zero
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? urban decay liquid eyeliner
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? mac smolder khol
What’s your favorite water line liner? mac smolder khol
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Penultimate Liner
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes
What’s your favorite water line liner? Make Up For Ever Aqua Creamliner
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? BE Buxom Inside Eyeliner in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7 in El Dorado
What’s your favorite water line liner? Stila Smudge Pot in Black
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? UD 24/7 liners
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Technakohl Liner in Graphblack (only liner that stays on really well w/out smudging)
Upper: Jane Mineral Gel Eyeliner
Lower: I use shadow on my lower lashline, anything else smears
Waterline: Blacktrack fluidline
1. l’oreal lineur intense
2. engraved powerpoint by mac
3. engraved here as well 🙂
upper – either lancome artliner or nyx felt tip liner
lower- mac pearlglide
waterline – loreal hip kohl liner
upper lash line= wet n wild cream liner in 886 black
lower lash line-UD liners with a matching shadow
water line-nyx liners in white or light brown
I like Blacktrack Fluidline for everything. i will try some others soon
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Blacktrack Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Stubborn Brown or UD Oil Slick
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Blacktrack Fluidline or UD Zero
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Estee Lauder ES Onyx
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Pearleglide Undercurrent
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Feline
Upper Lash Liner: for color–> MAC Pearlglides
for black–> MAC Black Chromaline
Lower Lash Liner: MAC Fluidlines (for color) or MAC Black Chromaline
Favorite Waterline liner? Mac Black Chromaline! It’s the only thing that stays put <3
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Urban Decay Liquid Eyeliner in Revolver
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Zero
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC’s Technokhol Liner in Graphblack
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Make up Forever Aqua Eyes Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
Urban Decay Zero
What’s your favorite water line liner?
Make up Forever Aqua Eyes Champagne
Upper: MAC Blacktrack fluidline
Lower: UD 24/7 liners especially zero, bourbon, 1999, flipside
Waterline: MAC fascinating kohl or MAC engraved powerpoint…I want to try the MUFE pencils
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? MAC Black Track Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? MAC Pearlglide Eyeliners or Annabelle Eyeliner in Black (drugstore brand, very stiff – anything creamy makes a huge mess)
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Feline Kohl Power or MAC Chromagraphic Pencil in NC15/NW20
Upper: MAC fluidline
Lower: MAC Pearlglide Intense eyeliner
Waterline: MAC Kohl eyeliners
Upperlash: I actually don’t line my upper lashline.
Lowerlash: Usually a colored eyeshadow with a pencil brush, sometimes layered ontop of an nyx jumbo pencil or a Urban Decay liner.
Waterline: Urban Decay 24/7.
Upper: Stila Onyx kahjal
Lower: whatever’s complimenting to my make-up
Waterline: Blacktrack
Upper: MAC fluidline (i only have blk track and dip down, but am looking to trying different colors) Or an UD 24/7 liner.
Lower: Usually I will use an eyeshadow color corresponding to my look or an UD 24/7 liner.
Waterline: UD 24/7 and Fluidline here and it stays decent, but not all day… 🙁 any suggestions?
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Almay Black Eyeliner.
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? I got a new MAC one today. It’s a Powerpoint I think, in the colour Jade?
What’s your favorite water line liner? I don’t line my waterline.
Upper lashline eyeliner: MAC pearlglide eyeliner Black Russian and Blackline
Lower lashline: MAC technakohl in Graphblack
Waterline: Indian kajal and MAC Smolder
I am still on the hunt for a really good eyeliner that will not break the bank. So far, I am liking Styli-Style Line & Seal. I’ve tried the flat pencil one and I didn’t like it. It tugged on my skin. I still haven’t tried Prestige, which I’ve heard is a good one.
Upper Lash Liner: None
Lower Lash Liner: Lavshuca Pencil Liner in BK-1
Water-Liner: Naris Up Liquid Liner
Upper: Blacktrack
Lower: shadows…not a fan of pencil or creme on the lower…always smudge on me
Waterline: blacktrack
* What’s your favorite upper lash liner? -buxomlash gel liner, or coastal scents black
* What’s your favorite lower lash liner? – don’t usually use one…probably UD 24/7
* What’s your favorite water line liner? – UD 24/7 in zero or MUFE aqualiner in black 🙂
What’s your favorite upper lash liner?
Bobbi Brown Long-wearing Gel Liner in Black
What’s your favorite lower lash liner?
I just use a bit of brown eyeshadow. (BB’s e/s in Sable)
What’s your favorite water line liner?
MUFE’s Aqua Eyes, and the colors vary pretty often. 🙂
Upper Lash Line: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline OR Loreal Lineur Intense
Lower Lash Line: Always use shadows to match my eye look.
Water Line: MAC Blacktrack (even though its not technically approved, it works brilliantly!)
Loreal HIP cream liner brown or black for the waterline and upper lash line. MAC brownborder powerpoint pencil for lower lash
Upper: UD 24/7 liner in Bourbon
Lower: UD 24/7 Underground
Waterline: UD 24/7 Underground
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Black Track Fluidline
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Urban Decay 24/7
What’s your favorite water line liner? Stila Kajal
Favorite upper lash liner: MAC Fluidline in any color
Favorite lower lash line: MAC Graphblack liner
Favorite water line: MAC Feline eye kohl
I love Le Crayon Khol of Lancome
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? stila smudge pot
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? ud 24/7 liners
What’s your favorite water line liner? mac feline eye kohl
tightline- feline eye kohl
Hey Girls!
What is the difference between a upper and lower lash liner? Why not use the same??
Upper: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline or bourjois liner feutre.
Lower: mostly shadows or smole\feline smudge
Waterline: MAC Smolder & Feline.
Upper: Blacktrack fluidline
Lower: Mac Powersurge or Dig It (gone but not forgotten)
Waterline: I can’t get on with lining the waterline – I think it looks evil
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof eye definer in Noir
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? I generally use an eye shadow, my current favorite is from the MAC black collection, Cinderfella.
What’s your favorite water line liner? Either Skoah’s Smokin’ Smudgie in Coal or Glo Minerals gloPrecision Eye Pencil in Black
Um i was really interested in investing(for me its alot of money for an liner) and i was curios on how to apply it??
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? L’Oreal Lineur Intense Carbon
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? UD 24/7 liners (various color, to match shadow)
What’s your favorite water line liner? MAC Feline Kohl Power or Stila Kajal in Topaz
I like to use MAC Fluidline for my upper lash line. When I do my lower lash line I usually put on Make Up Forever Aqua Eyes in 14L (the white one) and then use eyeshadow on top of that. I use MAC Fluidline for my water line and I’ll set it with some MAC Carbon.
i love the mac powerpoint it’s the best since i’ve tried allot! i also love erre due eyepencils cause they are less expencive and super soft.
What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Urban Decay’s liquid liner in Perversion
What’s your favorite lower lash liner? Don’t do lower lash line but by reading others responses I might try out this out with my colorful eyeliners.
What’s your favorite water line liner? Revlon’s Colorstay eyeliner
* What’s your favorite upper lash liner? Blacktrack fluidline
* What’s your favorite lower lash liner? usually some of whatever eyeshadow i have on top but sometimes I’ll do a neutral eye and pop Sephora brand nano liner in Lagoon underneath
* What’s your favorite water line liner? Sephora brand liners and UD 24/7
* What’s your favorite upper lash liner: MAC blitz&glitz fluidline
* What’s your favorite lower lash liner: Urban Decay 24/7 underground
* What’s your favorite water line liner: U.M.A.