Archived Post

Show Offs: Eyeshadow Palettes

I have a large amount of MAC products. I fully admit to my addiction, and I enjoy it to the fullest. Makeup is not just a hobby, but it is actually a job (you know, the blog, is now a semi-career that I’m carving out for myself) that I love and enjoy. Needless to say, to function as an addict, I no doubt need to have an insane-crazy-OMG! kind of amount of makeup. I’ve loved MAC since February 2005, just before Madame B launched. I bought every single shadow from that launch, which was twice as many shadows as I had originally (Amber Lights, Bronze, Goldmine).

The beginning of my love affair with MAC began with the multitude of beautiful, pigmented products; both eyeshadows and pigments had stolen my heart. I had never been into makeup prior to MAC; I didn’t even know what blending was when I started crushing on the brand! I was eighteen, and makeup appealed to me on an entirely new level. MAC does something no other brand had done to me: it caught me, and it caught me good.

There is something about the folks over at marketing that just know how to draw you into the store and give you something that keeps you coming back. I find so many are quick to fall for the brand once they’ve stopped in or bought a few products. I personally feel that a lot of it is their price point, which falls above drugstore, but still below the majority of high end brands (like NARS and Urban Decay). You can get the wonderful experience of talking to artists and playing with products before you purchase them, which you can’t get at most drugstores, but the prices aren’t outrageous (obviously, in comparison). But anyway, they had me hook, line, and sinker from the get-go.

This post is ultimately photographs of my eyeshadow collection, which I keep in 15-pan palettes. I do have a few pre-made quads as well as my staple smoky eye quad (containing Carbon, Casablanca, Ricepaper, and Vex) that are not photographed. I recently depotted 34 eyeshadows (and I need to do some blushes, too), so I had to rearrange my palettes and thought now would be a great time to take photos!

Here are a few answers to questions I’m sure plenty of you have:

  • How long? I’ve been buying since February 2005–that’s over three years of “collecting” so-to-speak. I didn’t get this much overnight!
  • Do you buy everything? No, no, no. If I did, I would have four or five times as much, not to mention I would be homeless! Over the years, I have swapped away shadows and products, so this has been very much an evolving collection. I never buy for the sake of buying; I buy what I like, and at this point, I do try to avoid getting 10,000 dupes of the same color (aka Deep Truth and its many, many variations).
  • Is this the biggest collection? NO! There are dozens of people who have posted photos of what they own, and what I own pales in comparison. I have a decent amount, but many have much, much more.
  • Why palettes? When I do a look, I like to open up a palette with a color family in mind, e.g. green, and then I can look at all the greens and pick what I think will work the best. I find this makes what I own much more accessible, in comparison to keeping shadows in their pots. I also find that this presents a much easier storage solution that takes up less room than individual shadows.
  • How can you travel then? I have about four or five empty quads that I have available to take with me. I usually go on short trips, so one or two quads is plenty. In the event of a longer one, I might take all of my quads, or I might take a full 15-pan palette or two (picking and choosing select colors, of course).
  • Don’t you feel this is a waste of money/overboard? No, not in the least. This is my take on it: makeup is my hobby of choice. Most people have at least one hobby, if not several, and they pour their money into it. Some like stamps, others are into crafts. Not all hobbies cost the same, and some even are more like investments. Makeup makes me happy, and I don’t buy more than I can afford. It’s only a problem when it interferes with you living a normal, healthy, and happy life–like when you get into disastrous debt as a result.

You can see close-ups of the seven palettes (updated with names!)…

Row 1: Limo, Cranberry, Antiqued;
Row 2: Til Daybreak, Expensive Pink, Coppering;
Row 3: Living Pink, Passionate, Post-Haste;
Row 4: Rule, Up-do, Pink Papillon;
Row 5: Evening Aura, Fab & Flashy, Firespot

Row 1: Going Bananas, Goldmine, Juiced;
Row 2: Rye, Gorgeous Gold, Rose Blanc;
Row 3: Summer Neutral, Tendermetal, Rye;
Row 4: Sable Wrap, Patina, Warming Trend;
Row 5: Flourishing, Femme Noir, Fiction

Row 1: Humid, Velvet Moss, Sumptuous Olive;
Row 2: Overgrown, Lucky Green, Wondergrass;
Row 3: Aquavert, Metamorph, Juxt;
Row 4: Shimmermoss, Gulf Stream, Newly Minted;
Row 5: Cool Heat, A Bluer Blue, Melody

Row 1: Deep Truth, Parrot, Stormwatch;
Row 2: Freshwater, Blue Flame, Blue Storm;
Row 3: Thunder, Climate Blue, Electric Eel;
Row 4: Fig. 1, Gallant, Cinders;
Row 5: Pearl of the Earth, Romping, Stars ‘n Rockets

Row 1: Sketch, Neutral Pink, Thunder;
Row 2: Satin Taupe, Magnetic Fields, Smut;
Row 3: Romp, Bronze, Embark;
Row 4: Taupe Note, Cork, Woodwinked;
Row 5: A Little Folie, Ochre Style, Elite

Row 1: Texture, Valet, Beautyburst;
Row 2: Motif, Say Yeah, Arena;
Row 3: Daisychain, Nanogold, Jasmine;
Row 4: Phloof!, White Tie, Rite of Spring;
Row 5: Grain, Hush, Pen ‘n Pink

Row 1: Performance, Bisque, Malt;
Row 2: Shroom, Femme-fi, Modest Tone;
Row 3: Clue, Vellum, Blanc Type;
Row 4: Silver Ring, Charred, Copperplate;
Row 5: Cloudburst, (empty), Cumulus

94 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Shayla Avatar

Whoa, Christine, that’s quite the collection! I myself have four 15-pan palettes (two spots left!) and one quad palette. I haven’t depotted my LEs like you have though…I’m too afraid to break them!

Christine Avatar

Hi Shayla,

With Starflash coming out, I wouldn’t be surprised if I ended up with all of them! (Hello, six sets of empties? Score!)

My take on the depotting process and breaking them:

1) I have so many eyeshadows, even if I chip or loose a little chunk, I will survive. I have too many colors to use, and most of them are barely dented.

2) I can always press them back together with a little alcohol and parchment/wax paper.

I usually start the depotting process with my least favorites, that way any oops should occur then. I depot like, once every year or less, LOL. I’m pretty lazy about it, so I always gotta be patient so I don’t ruin them.

Ada Avatar

Thanks for a peek into your e/s collection. I really liked your comment about it being a hobby, and only getting what you can afford. My collection is teeny, but if I think of it as a hobby, there’s no reason I need to justify it to anyone.

Sandy Avatar

Hi Christine, I love your collection. Mine is not quite as big, but it’s getting there. I really really need to depot though. I have so many pots that I really don’t know where to keep them anymore. I’m just scared to ruin my eyeshadows while depotting 🙁

Christine Avatar

Hi Sandy,

Like I told Shayla, I worry about it, too, but then I realize I have way too many shadows I won’t miss a chip or two in say, 2 of the 34 I depot, you know? You can always put it back together with some alcohol, too 🙂 I’ve done this before, and it worked out well!

I know a lot of people have GREAT success using a flat iron (which I don’t own), though. This past time, I used the oven (first time), which went pretty well as long as you are patient! I’ve previously only done the vicious flame method, LOL.

Christine Avatar

Hi Sandy,

If you have a flat iron, I’d totally go that route. I used the oven, which is not nearly as stinky or messy as the candle/flame method. I baked them at 250F for 5-8 minutes, and I put five in at a time. You have to work pretty quick to get all five out before they harden up again, so you may want to start off slower if you go the oven route. A lot of times, the shadow will start to lift out of the pan when the glue melts a lot.

Oh! And get a glue remover before you start. This way, you can remove the glue beneath the pans (so they won’t stick in your palettes). Don’t forget to melt off the label at the bottom of the pot, too, so you can stick that under the pan. I got a roll of magnetic tape for $2 at the Container Store 😉 I have plenty of depots without magnets that work and have no problems hanging out in my palettes, though.

claudine Avatar

nice pictures Christine
i have to go to MAC tomorrow and get Stars n Rockets thats a perm i never bought before lol
oh and Make up is my Hobby too….the only hobby i have and its the only hobby i need because it makes me sooooo happy 🙂
and MAC is a great brand im very happy with their quality and the prize (cheap compared to NARS or Chanel here)

Christine Avatar

Hi Claudine,

OMG, I’m so glad you’re getting it. It is one of my favorite colors, it just has the best duochrome. Very like Pink Pearl, but more purple, and easier to use (love Pink Pearl, but eyeshadows are easier to use generally speaking!).

Anna Avatar

I always laugh about stars and rockets : ) because thats the color that started this whole obsession with mac..how crazy! its probably my favorite color ever..okay well maybe not ever because i do like shroom but still stars and rockets is a top fav of mine : )

Nana Avatar

Your philosophy about makeup as your hobby and only getting those what you like shows that you are not only beautiful but also an intelligent gal. Thank you for allowing us to peek. I love your collection!

Amanda23 Avatar

Wow! You have a pretty well rounded collection. I too feel that makeup is my hobby. I love collecting it and using it of course, but sometimes I feel like I can be a lil extreme. I have over 150 different shades of MAC e/s, mostly in pots…. I am the opposite and although it takes a ton of room (you have no idea) I just like to open my drawer and look at all my shadows at once. Its crazy! But I love it! I wish I could get one of the e/s displays like they have at MAC, that would complete me!! ;o)

Christine Avatar

Hi Amanda,

Oh, the pots look lovely all together, I know it! Although, I do like the way my palettes look, but maybe I’m biased 😉

Hunt ebay, sometimes the MAC units show up (how that happens, I don’t know, and I don’t *want* to know), but yes… there are a few floating in space.

Ariele Avatar

All the colors look so beautiful lined up like that 🙂 Thanks for sharing! And ITA – you shouldn’t have to justify it. I’ve started considering makeup (MAC in particular) a hobby as well. I love it, I enjoy spending money on it and owning it and using it. Sure, it can get expensive but as long as you don’t go overboard, I think its worth it! I, too, only buy the things I think I will use… otherwise, what’s the point? I’m also another gal that’s scared to depot… I have two 15-pan palettes filled with just Pro Pans or depots I’ve bought off of sales online. But the rest are in pots – close to 100 by now I’m sure. Just think of all the B2Ms!! Ohhh.. maybe I should try this weekend, I could get ALL the Starflash shadows free 🙂

Christine Avatar

Hi Ariele,

I know, right? I always love looking at palettes arranged by color. Something about it soothes me!

Yeah, I’m pretty excited – I should be able to get at least 6 of the Starflash shadows for free. More if I manage to depot my blushes (I probably have at least 6 that need depotting!), lol.

Christine Avatar

Hi Lu!

Oh gosh, the list would go on endlessly! Some of the shadows I reach for often are: Cranberry, Goldmine, Gorgeous Gold, Rye (LE), Humid, Sumptuous Olive, Lucky Green (LE), Juxt, Shimmermoss, Freshwater, Stars ‘n Rockets, Brnoze, Ricepaper, Say Yeah (LE), Grain, Carbon

Nell Avatar

Thanks for this great post, I loved reading about your addiction-history.
I just wish the e/s colors were labeled in the pics, that would be so helpful!

Chloe Avatar

Christine, have you ever done any freelancing? Your palettes look just like mine! I agree with you when you say that it isn’t a waste. This is a hobby and my collection, like yours, wasn’t collected overnight. However, my husband has become supportive of my love affair since he knows it’s an investment. I do freelance work in my area and that’s how I get more money to buy more things to add to my collection! Genious! =D

Christine Avatar

Hi Chloe,

Not really. I’ve done a few things for friends/family, but I really don’t LOVE applying makeup to others. I LOVE helping and teaching and basically love everything I do on the blog.

Freelancing is definitely a great way to enjoy, use, and keep up your collection!

Chloe Avatar

Well, you do an AMAZING job at helping and teaching others. You’re the best at that! It’s difficult to find people that can coach you in this field, most people want to keep their techniques to themselves but you are so helpful and generous. I just wanted you to know that you are helping ALL of us out here and we appreciate you tremendously for that!! Thank you, Christine. =D

cloudburst Avatar

I love looking at my pallettes too – they are so pretty when you organize them by shades!

I have one question – how do you depot the LE pallettes? I assume the square shadows come from the holiday type pallettes.

And I have a suggestion to those who are afraid to depot (a MAC MA actually told me how to do it years ago) after you pop the shadow top off of the base of the container (I use a large x-acto knife), take a pair of tweezers or plyers & hold the shadow above a candle flame, once the black plastic starts to melt, take a push pin & push up from the bottom. I have had great success with this method and very rarely chip or crack my shadows.

My only other suggestion is do your depotting somewhere ventilated, because the melting plastic is a little stinky.

Rubi Avatar

I love your pallettes. I have tons of make-up mostly DIOR, Chanel, Nars. I also have a lot of Lancome quads. MAC is recent to me because I used to think it was “cheap”. I would go to the Pro store at Ceasar’s Palace just to get a special one time use color for an outfit and that was it. BUT, after reading your blog and really giving the brand a chance I have changed my mind. I actually color print the looks you do that I love and as dorky as it sounds, I have a little sheet protector binder with them in there (lame, I know) and I just take the printout to the counter and have the MUA grab all the stuff I am going to need. Since Feb I have gotten about 30 e/s, 8 pigments and a bunch of lippies.

Elle Avatar

Love this post, Christine. I haven’t done the depotting thing yet, but the more I buy the more I think it’s a good idea…

And you’ll never have to justify your hobby to the fans of your blog. I love reading your posts/doing your tutorials and hey, whatever makes you happy, girl 😉 If it’s makeup, it’s makeup. And you’re right, MAC really does have a way of turning people into rabid fans. I was talking to an MA last week while buying more of the ElectroFlash duos, and she’s like “Yeah we come out with a lot of stuff so you don’t get bored with us”. Like THAT could ever happen 😉

Christine Avatar

Hi Elle,

I got into pans pretty early on, which is why I need to depot. I don’t like having both, lol! I think you might get a chip or two here and there, but on the whole, I think it’s totally worth it. My pots always sit ignored, but I constantly use the colors in my palettes (which also explains why I use 50 colors in a look!).

Nartian Avatar

Your Bronze is well-loved/used!

What I find equally fascinating is noticing the colors you *don’t* have in your collection (unless they’re in the quads/sets not photographed), specifically Bamboo (or the more intense Tete-a-Tint) and the redder colors like Trax, Sable, Swiss Chocolate, and even Parfait Amour. Sometimes I forget that your coloring isn’t exactly the same as mine.

Thanks for sharing!

Christine Avatar

Hi Nartian,

It was one of my first three shadows from MAC! It was also my first depot. It’s actually broken, LOL, and I really should replace it.

You know, I’ve owned Bamboo, Trax, and Parfait Amour in the past. I swapped Bamboo and Parfait Amour away because they were similar (Parfait Amour is *very* much like Gallant – Gallant has a bit more pay off, so I figured if I ran out of Gallant, Parfait Amour is perm!). Trax I hated. Pay off stunk for me, LOL.

Nicky Avatar

Christine,

This is such a great post. I love how you’ve organized all your colors–it’s inspiring me to organize my makeup collection better! Seriously, I’m just gazing at your photos with envy!

I love MAC for the same reasons as you–nice price point and so much to offer. I think the powers-that-be at MAC know how to lure us into the store with their Limited Edition collections, which always makes me spend money!

Stephanie Avatar

Hi,

I love your collection and I think you are right. There are people who spend their money on stamps and we spend on ours on make-up so no reason to justify it! I see here that you are saying you can get e/s as back to mac items? Is that a store to store basis? Pro stores only? Because the counters/stores I go to here (in Florida) say I can only get lipsticks and only perms so if I have to go to the Pro store to get e/s I will!

Thanks

Eva Avatar

Christine,
you have me droooooling over these palettes..
They look great and I am so jealous of all the LE eyeshadows!
Great e/s collection..I can´t imagine what your whole m/u collection looks like (and yes, I do remember the post from last year. :o))..

Pquanda Avatar

Christine! Love the post, and really appreciate that you put the names. Would you be able to do a look with Fig. 1? That’s my biggest lemming ever right now!

Zsofi Avatar

Wow Christine this is MAC porn :-DDDDDDDDDDD
love Your collection and thanks for sharing with us.
the story of You falling in love with makeup and MAC really touched me. now i read i for the second time,and this is not the last :-))))))
i feel the same,love love love MAC!!!!!!

Zsofi Avatar

The fact that Your hobby is now kind of a job for You is so inspiring!!!!
You always have been a role model for me,now even more. i want to work for MAC 🙂
someone famous once said,that the most happy life a person can have is,when he or she has a job,that is also their hobby .
i am sure You learned about the Maslow pyramid,so i tell You You are on top of it now,You reached slf-actualisation,which is the greatest thing in life 🙂
i try to reach it myself 😀

Carrie Avatar

This is such a great reference, not just for the product photos, but also palette layout suggestions. I just expanded to 3 palettes and it took me a while to figure out how to organize everything. I like this layout.

LOL, my Embark is exactly like yours, crumbled and re-put-together all funky and cracked.

Monica Avatar

Hi Christine! Thanks for sharing with us part of your collection.. Its great! I’m jealous..he,he..;D
One question.. do you have plumage? if not is one color that I recommend you.. I don’t know as much of make up as you do, however a MA suggested it to me and I got it. Its a great color to mix with Teal, greens, purples, it goes with almost anything, and I really like the texture.. maybe you can give it a try (maybe you already have it).
Thanks again.. I already wrote down my list of must haves based on your palletes!
Have a great weekend!!

Ashley Avatar

Great collection! I love the variation in your colours- not too many dupes to be seen there! And lucky you having a MAC that will take back depots!

Stacey Avatar

Awesome collection… I just depotted about 80% of my shadows this week to put into palettes… can’t believe I didn’t do it sooner! I did take a huge chunk out of my Clarity though… but not the end of the world. Lol.

Chantale Avatar

Yeah! Let’s share the love! Love the palettes you created! Vewry pleasing to the eye when placed by family colours. To quote/paraphrase a different saying: Once you use MAC, you never go back! LOL
Can’t bring myself to depot them. To me, it would be like desecrating a sacred artifact…
I realise that it would make it easier for me to use more of my products because, when you have as much makeup as I have, it’s easy to forget a few and to just keep using the same ones because they are visible and not hidden in containers. So, in order to prevent that from happening, I do reorganize my makeup for my upcoming week looks (I usually play with my makeup on the weekends, clean my brushes at the same time as reorganize). I will set up on the bathroom counter, the paints/pigments/e/s/etc that I will be using for that week… I am sort of organized. I love to try looks while at home so no one else can see me if I mess up. It’s safe and I can remove it if I don’t like it. I also am an artist at heart and create my own makeup colors by mixing different colours/brands together. I have gotten the idea from some of my favs MAs. Like buying clear mascaras, nail polishes, and lip glosses and pigmenting them myself. Or mixing different blushes, e/s, finishing powders that I don’t really like anymore and that just sit there, collecting dust. I will mix them together until I reach a colour that I like and that I will use…

Nicole Avatar

Amazing collection. Could you please post some pictures, when you include your depotted e/s and rearranged your collection.

I started my collection in Summer 1999 with Mulch and I own just about 30 eye shadows (including 2 premade quads).

Saira Avatar

Wow! Your collection is so cool! It’s inspired me to go and buy more make-up :o), hee hee. Been meaning to organise my eyeshadows for a while, so good to see how much organising them can help with thinking up new looks and colour combinations. I think the first Mac eyeshadow I bought was Beautiful Iris and then I got Goldmine after that – been hooked ever since!

Patricia Avatar

How do you depot your square pans? I have two pallets like that I wouldn’t even know where to start on depotting those. By the way, your collection is out of this world. I’m jeaslous. hehe!

enna Avatar

hi, is there a great difference between post-haste and passionate? which one do you use more often? i was torn between them and eventually got post-haste

Lis Avatar

Thank you make-up is my hobby too, and in fact it has caused me to stop drinking and too take better care of myself. It really fustrates me when people wonder why I spend so much on make-up when it is my hard earned money. XOXO

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!