Archived Post
Survey Says... February 10th, 2010
- What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
- What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
- What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
93 Comments
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Favourite Lipgloss: Mac Lipglass in Nice Kitty from Hello Kitty — gorgeous blue-pink
Favourite Eyeliner: Urban Decay in Electric — gorgeous vibrant teal!
Favourite Mascara: Covergirl LashBlast — Major lashes for cheap!
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
MAC pink manish out the manisch aurora colection.
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
MAC fluidline blitz glitz.
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Max faxtor false lash effect.
xxx Eveline.
favorite lipgloss of all time- probably mac love nectar lustreglass. very smooth with an apricot nude tint when it hits the light.
favorite eyeliner of all time- urban decay 24/7 eyeliner! smooth and creamy, great for upper & lower lashline, and waterline.
favorite mascara of all time- mac studio fix lash. mac gets tons of terrible comments about their mascara, but this one doesn’t clump and appears on my lashes as if they were false!
Fav lipgloss = MAC Lusterglass in Wonderstruck
Fav eyeliner = MAC Technakohl in Graphblack
Fav mascara = Imju Fiberwig
🙂
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
mac dazzleglass in smile
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
urban decay 24/7 glide-on eye pencil in zero
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
givency phenomen eyes mascara in black
MAC Lipglass in Lust
Givenchy Parad’eyes liner in Dream in Black
Givenchy Captiv’eyes mascara in Extreme Black
Wet N Wild Megaplump. Great smell, colors, taste, texture.
For natural looks, I like Urban Decay Ink for Eyes in Demolition-its a cool brown that looks very subtle on me.
For dramatic looks, I like Buxom Lashliner in Leatherette-their brown is warmer than the Ink for Eyes, or else I’d have that as well. I love the texture and color.
I use Diorshow mascara, but I don’t know that i’m so thrilled with it that other products wouldn’t thrill me.
These questions are so tough!
Lipgloss: Naked Frost, Morning Glory
Eyeliner: Feline Eye kohl, Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Bourbon
Mascara: Makeup Forever Smokey Lash, Benefit Bad Gal Lash, or Imju Fiberwig Mascara
I couldn’t just pick one for each category! lol
lip gloss: nars chihuahua
eyeliner: stila smudge pot
mascara: dior show? I actually haven’t found the perfect one for me yet. still searching
MAC’s Tinted Lipglass is Underage for lipglass, MAC’s Blacktrack Fluidline for eyeliner, & Lashblast for mascara 🙂
fav l/g oyster girl
fav eyeliner powerpoint in engraved
fav mascara chanel inimitable waterproof 🙂
Favorite lip gloss of all time: Only 1!?!?!? ok i’ll try 😉
so far, it’s Chanel Aqualumiere gloss in Candy Glow – pink-peach-gold perfection!
Favorite eyeliner of all time – Lancome Le Grande Kohl waterproof in Chaitagne! Absolute fave! smudges smoothly, never skips or catches, tip never breaks and it lasts forever!
Favorite mascara of all time – so far, Giorgio Armani Eyes to Kill because the Bronze shade is perfect for my skin tone/eye and hair color! Excellent quality and a really cool tube! Expensive, but woth evey cent!
Favourite lipgloss: MAC’s Dazzleglass Creme in Soft Dazzle
Favourite Eyeliner: I don’t/can’t wear it 😛
Favourite Mascara: L’Oreal Telescopic in Carbon Black
🙂
lipgloss = MAC lipglass in Sun Set
eyeliner = MAC fluidline in Graphic Brown
mascara = MAC studio fix lash in Black Fix
Fav. Lipgloss – MAC lipglass in Viva Glam V or Nymphette
Fav. Eyeliner – Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliner in Stash (gorgeous gold/olive green)
Fav. Mascara – Dior Diorshow in Black
gloss- mac lychee luxe
liner- mac feline
mascara- no preference
Lip gloss Chanel glossimer in Myriade
Eyeliner Makeup FOrever Aqua Black Shadow/Liner
Mascara Chanel Inimitable
Favorite Lipgloss – Paul & Joe’s Lip Lacquer #10
Favorite Eyeliner – MAC’s Feline
Favorite Mascara – a tie btw MAC’s Zoom and Plush lash
Favorite lipgloss-Mac tinted lipglass in “Lychee Luxe” <333 love it!
Favorite eyeliner-Makeup forever aqua eyes eyeliner in "shimmering plum 4L" its a gorgeous soft plum color.
Favorite mascara-Covergirl Lash blast.
Fav lipgloss is stila 24k gold in coral right now. Fav eyeliner is a tie between MUFE and UD 24/7 (MUFE is wayyyy better waterline but UD is soooo smooth!), and fav mascara is DiorShow hands down. Unfortunately I love trying new products so my all time favs change often 🙂
lip gloss: Dior Ultra-Gloss Reflect in Clutch Pink
eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 (different color every day)
mascara: Chanel Inimitable in black
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Laura Mercier Lip Plumper in Persimmon
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Ooh, toss up between Prestige WP Granite (pretty but practical) and HIP Violet Volt (gorgeous and fun)
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Kiss Me Heroine Long & Curl. It’s a Japanese drugstore mascara and I’m on my 3rd tube! It lengthens (fiber mascara), separates and defines, lifts noticeably, holds curl, doesn’t flake or smudge and lasts allllll day until I take it off. It’s a little difficult to get off but the green L’Oreal makeup remover works really well for it (hold saturated cotton pad to lashes for 20 seconds each).
Lipgloss: Mac Plushglass in Ample Pink
Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 in Zero
Mascara: Cover Girl Lash Blast in Black
Favourite Lipgloss: Mac Lipglass in Nymphette
Favourite Eyeliner: Mac Blacktrack Fluidline
Favourite Mascara: Fresh Supernova (makes my lashes super long!)
Fav lipgloss-Smashbox lip enhancing gloss in the color Hype. Perfect nude pink for me.
Fav eyeliner- MAC Feline Kohlpower
Fav Mascara- (for now) Rimmel sexy curves. I had to revisit and i absolutely love it
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
I don’t have one…does chapstick count? If so, Blistex Herbal Answer! haha
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Toss up btwn MAC Graphblack or Urban Decay Zero
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Shiseido’s Lasting Lift
I take that back.
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Urban Decay UNDERGROUND!
* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Fashion Pack Barbie Collection
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Teddy Eye Kohl
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Clinique’s Naturally Glossy
Lipgloss – BE Buxom Amber
Eyeliner – MAC Kohl Smolder
Mascara – MAC Zoom Lash Black is pretty awesome!
* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
I’ll never be able to pick one so Chanel Glossimer in Praline for a more subdued natural look and Chanel Glossimer in Sideral for glittery pink goodness.
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
I can’t not mention Bobbi Brown gel liner in Black Ink, but for fun stuff I like the Urban Decay 24/7 pencils in nearly any color but especially Ransom.
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Diorshow, for sure!
DDD/GGG, NC4-50, Bobbi Brown Golden
Fave gloss: MAC Lustreglass in Palatial
Fave eyeliner: MAC Boot Black liquid liner
Fave mascara: Benefit Bad Gal/ MAC Dazzlelash or Plushlash
Favorite lipgloss: MAC’s love nectar lustreglass. it makes everything look good.
Favorite Eyeliner: Urban Decay’s zero
Favorite Mascara: MAC’s Plush Lash
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Estée Lauder High Gloss
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? MAC Fluidline Blacktrack
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Sephora’s clear mascara
1. beauty rush strawberry fizz
2. Urban Decay Oil Slick or Blitz n Glitz fluidline
3. Anstasia Lash Lifting
Favourite Lipgloss: Dior Addict ultra reflect gloss in 257 or mac dazzleglass in baby sparks! Too hard to choose.
Favourite eyeliner: ELF waterproof eyeliner pen in black
Favorite mascara: Eyeko ‘Big Eyes’ Mascara
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Stila lip pot in Baie, sadly I think it got discontinued.
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Stila smudge pot. For a specific color I think I’d go with starry night, it’s such a pretty blue.
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Max Factor False lash effect. I think it’s very similar to the Covergirl lashblast but I can’t get it in my country so I go with the Max Faxtor one.
Lipgloss:MAc Lust
Eyeliner:Stila smudge pot
Mascara:Mac pro lash
favorite lipgloss: MAC Creamsheen in Boy Bait-makes my lips look plump and tones the natural color down.
Favorite Eyeliner: Prestige Total Intensity in Blackest Black- Its exactly like MAC Feline, but doesnt smudge.
Favorite Mascara: Maybelline Volume Express Turbo Boost Waterproof- I always go back to this mascara after trying others and its cheap! 🙂
Favorite lipgloss: Either Spring Bean Lustreglass or Viva Glam VI SE Lipglass. It’s so hard to choose just one.
Favorite Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 pencil in Bourbon.
Favorite Mascara: Haven’t found a favorite yet. They all seem to flake and clump after a couple of uses.
Lipgloss: MAC viva glam v
eyeliner: MAC fluidline blacktrack
Mascara: Fiberwig
Favourite lipgloss of all-time: YSL No.3 Golden Pink Golden Gloss
Favourite eyeliner of all-time: MAC Feline Kohl Power Eye Pencil
Favourite mascara of all-time: Clinique High Impact (black)
My favorite lip gloss- bobbi brown almost bare (any bobbi brown lip gloss is awesome and love mac too)
My favorite eye liner- bobbi brown gel liner in bronze
My favorite mascara- benefit
Favorite Lipgloss: MAC Lustreglass in Love Nectar
Favorite Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliner in Gunmetal
Favorit Mascara: Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Waterproof in Very Black.
🙂
Favorite lipgloss – Mac Plushglass in Power Supply. My absolute favorite. It’s the perfect pinky-rose color on me.
Favorite Eyeliner – CoverGirl Exact Eyelight Eye-Brightening Liner in Radient Sapphire. Although it’s inexpensive, it complements my blue eyes well.
Favorite Mascara – wet N wild MEGA LENGTH Mascara. I was expecting this to be such a crappy mascara, but when I tried it, I was plesantly surprised!! No clumps, just super long lashes – and its cheap!!!!
^^at the rate i’m going with make-up lately, this will change by next week haha. (:
lipgloss: MAC Viva Glam VI SE
eyeliner: L’Oreal lineur intense
mascara: Diorshow black
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
Chanel Glossimer in Imaginaire
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Pencil: All UD 24/7s, I love all colors!
Liquid: Lancome Artliner
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Day: Diorshow Iconic, Covergirl Lashblast
Night: Diorshow Blackout <3 <3 <3
MAC Beaute Lipglass from the Holiday collection
MAC Feline Eye Kohl from Love Lace
LashBlast Luxe in Black Platinum
i don’t wear lipgloss so I would say my fav lipstick is MYTH by mac.
my fav eyeliner is HEMA black
and my favourite mascara must be the COVER GIRL, lashblast
Favourite Lipgloss: I actually don’t have a favourite.. if I had to choose probably Nymphette
Favourite Eyeliner: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline or Revlon ColorStay
Favourite Mascara: CoverGirl Lashblast waterproof or length
MAC lip gelee in Saplicious
Shiseido fine eye liner liquid liner pen in black
Dior Diorshow Iconic mascara in black
lustreglass, smolder khol, mac mascara x. yes, all mac!
favorite lipgloss: this coppery shimmery one my grandma has..ive never been able to find one like it and the name has worn off 🙁
favorite eyeliner: lm kohl in brown copper
favorite mascara: ga eyes to kill
* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? nymphette mac
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? still haven’t found one
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? nyx doll eyes
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC’s Springbean lustreglass
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? MAC’s fluidline in blacktrack
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? MAC’s Plushlash 🙂
favorite lipgloss – Urban Decay Pocket Rocket Timothy
(I don’t like MAC Lipglasses b/c you get such little product and it smells like poo. lol.)
favorite eyeliner – Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes
(I tried Urban Decay 24/7 but it was too smudgy)
MAC Fluidline for gel.
favorite mascara – Covergirl Lashblast. Does what the high end brands do but better for less money. Winner to me!
Lipgloss: MAC Cremesheen Glass in Boy Bait.
Eyeliner: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline.
Mascara: YSL Faux Cils (I don’t know if I wrote it right :p haha)
I don’t have one particular piece of makeup that’s my favorite I change my looks and hair so frequently that I don’t get attached to one particular Item. but if I had to choose viva glam V lip glass.
I only have a fave lipgloss of all time: MAC’s “Light My Fire” from the Tantress collection.
For daytime/everyday, the other for nightime/special occasions
Favourite Lipgloss: Mac Lipglass in Nymphette (Over Prive or Hot Gossip) / Lancome Juicy Tube in Ginger Palace
Favourite Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 (any color)
Favourite Mascara: Covergirl LashBlast (very cheap but very long full lashes!)
Lipgloss- Mac viva glam v
Eyeliner- mac blacktrack fluidline
Mascara- cover girl lashblast
i dont have a favorite lip gloss
favorite eye liner is feline …i love how black it is ..it does smudge
bad gal is my favorite mascara
Favorite Lipgloss- not really a lip gloss but it gives my lips shine! ROSEBUD Lip Balm in Minted Rose.
Favorite eyeliner- Stila Kajal in Onyx. it never fails!
Favorite Mascara- Covergirl Lash Blast
Lipgloss: NARS Turkish Delight
Eyeliner: MUFE Aqua Eyes Liner in 6L deep purple
Mascara: Covergirl LashBlast or Benefit’s BadGal
Lipgloss: Viva Glam V Lipglass
Eyeliner: Fly-By-Blue Pearlglide Eyeliner
Mascara: Clinique High Impact, Plush Lash, or Covergirl Lashblast
MAC Partial to Pink
Stila Kajal in Topaz
Maybelline Colossal Volum Express in Blackest Black
Lipgloss: haha. I don’t like gloss
eyeliner: loreal 24hr gel liner
mascara: maybelline volum express
NARS l/g in Chihuahua
MAC Blacktrack fluidline
Rimmel Sexy Curves
Fav lipgloss is Mac Baby Sparks dazzleglass
Fav eyeliner is UD 24/7 in Rockstar…it’s perfect for green eyes
Fav mascara is Dior Iconic
Lipgloss: Boy Bait Cremesheen Glass
Eye Liner: Carbon Eye Shadow
Mascara: Dior Show
Favourite lipgloss of all-time: MAC Oh Baby lipglass (the perfect colour that just warms up my face!)
Favourite eyeliner of all-time: MAC Graphic Brown fluidline (perfect EVERY time!)
Favourite mascara of all-time: Maybelline Full ‘N Soft mascara (never clumps or goops)
Lipgloss: (I don’t wear lipgloss)
Eyeliner: Almay and Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliners
Mascara: Urban Decay Big Fatty Mascara
Favourite Lipgloss – MAC She Loves Candy lipglass (Hello Kitty collection)
Favourite Eyeliner – MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack
Favourite Mascara – MAC Dazzlelash in Black Dazzle. I love the tiny brush, and have never found another mascara that has one like it.
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
From the 2009 Mischeif Makers – Poetic Lisence Lipglass. My PERFECT NUDE. Second to that is Boy Bait Cremesheen Lipgloss
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Feline 😀
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Pro Lash
lipgloss- MAC Viva Glam VI Special Edition
eyeline- U/D 24/7 Zero
mascara- Diorshow
favorite lipgloss- i dont rlly have one yet 🙁
favorite eyeliner- Urban Decay 24/7 in rockstar
favorite mascara- Loreal voluminious
Lipgloss: I really love the formula, color selection and flavor of the Urban Decay Pocket Rockets! My favorite shade is definitely Doug.
Eyeliner: MAC Smolder is the smoothest and blackest black I’ve ever tried, it’s phenomenal. For liquid eyeliner I love Dior Liner and for everyday pencils I like Urban Decay’s 24/7 liners.
Mascara: MaxFactor’s 2000 Calorie, Fresh Supernova, or MAC Plushlash.
Lipgloss: MAC Dazzleglass in “Steppin’ Out”. It is the prettiest pink to layer over any lipstick, but it’s also beautiful by itself!
Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 in “Flipside”. It’s definately not an everyday eyeliner, but it is so vibrant & gorgeous!
Mascara: I haven’t really found my dream mascara yet, but so far the best has been Lancome’s “Hypnose”.
LIPGLOSS: MAC Miss Marble
EYELINER: MAC Blacktrack Fluidline
MASCARA: MAC Mascara X Black
Favorite Lipgloss: Fashion Scoop Cremesheen by Mac
Favorite Eyeliner: Black Stila Smudge Pot
Favorite Mascara: Anything that doesn’t clump together really (lol)
favorite lipgloss: mac 2N lipglass (pretty nude!)
favorite eyeliner: mac blacktrack fluidline (great texture, doesn’t budge!)
favorite mascara: stila major major lash (gives my lashes natural curl, mega-volume!)
Fav Lipgloss: MAC “Underage”
Fav Eyeliner: Loreal Extra Intense Liquid Pencil “Black”..Best liner ever..its definitely more intense than mac and doesn’t budge or smear.
Fav Mascara: Loreal Voluminous Mascara “Carbon Black”
Lipgloss: Revlon Super Lustrous Lipgloss in “Pink Afterglow”
Eyeliner: Revlon Eyeliner Pencil
Mascara: Sexy Curves by Rimmel
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all time? Mac Lipglass Viva Glam VI
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all time? Loreal Extra Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner ( I used to swear by UD 24/7, but after trying this? OMG love.)
What’s your favorite mascara of all time? Covergirl LashBlast ( I loved the rubber wand 2000 cal from Max Factor, but it’s gone… I think LashBlast is it’s US sister. same tube, same brush)
Lipgloss: Clinique Longwear lipgloss in “Air Kiss”. It has a wonderful texture, and it stays on for 2 hours! The color is a wonderful peachy pink gloss with gold shimmer.
Eyeliner: Lancome Artliner in Black. It has a smooth texture and doubles great as an eyeshadow base for vibrant payoff. It works really well with a Bobbi Brown eyeliner brush.
Mascara: Buxom Lash by Bare Essentuals
Gloss: MAC Fluterrose & MAC Prrr
Eyeliner: Urban Decay 24/7 in ROCKSTAR
Mascara: Covergirl LashBlast & L’oreal HIP
Fav lipgloss – MAC Love nectar
Fav eyeliner – UD rockstar (purple)
Fav Mascara – Lancome Hypnose
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
MAC Viva Glam VI special edition
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Oil Slick
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
L’Oreal Full n Soft Waterproof
Cheers for Beauty <3
XOXO
Chau M. Dang
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
A tie between NYX French Kiss & MAC Prr
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
UD 24/7 – I love ’em all!
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Rimmel Ultra Glam
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC Starlet Kiss Heatherette Collection
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Urban decay 24/7 eyeliner in zero or MAC fluidline in blacktrack
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Diorshow in black
What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? YSL Golden Gloss in #7
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Revlon’s Colorstay 16Hr. pencil eyeliner
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? So far its YSL’s Faux Cils
mac lipglass in poetic license
mac fluidline in blacktrack
maybelline’s colossal lash… probably
Favorite lipgloss of all-time: Spring Bean Lustreglass by MAC
Favorite eyeliner of all-time: Fluidline in Blacktrack by MAC
Favorite mascara of all-time: Rimmel London’s Sexy Curves 😀
* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time: Chanel bikini peach
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time: Make up forever aqua eyes
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time: Lancôme Hypnôse