Explore Temptalia

We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!

Here are some useful resources for you:

Foundation Matrix™

Find your next foundation or concealer match!

The Dupe List™

Find a product dupe or compare two palettes.

Swatch Gallery™

Find swatches by color, product, formula, etc.

Compare Any Two

Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!

86 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
lunatwinkle Avatar
lunatwinkle

Fav mascara: L’Oreal Waterproof Voluminous! I always come back and reach for this in my stash! 😀

Fav eyeliner: Revlon Colorstay for liquid and pencil eyeliner. Although yes, I also love Urban Decay 24/7 too. I just purchased the Super Stash for myself and I love every color. But oftentimes when I’m broke, I always reach for my trusty Revlon. Can’t beat them!

Kimmie T Avatar
Kimmie T

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?

Nivea a Kiss of Shine. Simple, little shine, no muss no fuss.

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?

Bare Escentuals Buxom Lash. It’s just that freaking amazing!

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?

Urban Decay Liquid Liner in Perversion.

allison Avatar
allison

fave lipgloss: it’s always changing! right now i really like mac lipglass is strawberry blonde.
Fave mascara: loreal voluminous in carbon black with loreal extra volume collagen!
Fave eyeliner: urban decay pencil in zero.

Zoffe Avatar
Zoffe

Lipgloss: MAC Palatial lustreglass because it’s such a gorgeous pink. I like how it’s wearable but still very unique. It’s so sad that it’s discontinued though! 🙁 Funtabulous dazzleglass is another favourite that I use all the time ;D
Mascara: I love DiorShow, but it’s way too expensive for a mascara IMO. Maybelline Colossal gives a very similar effect on my lashes, but is way cheaper. I also really like MAC Dazzlelash for a very quick and easy to use mascara that still makes my lashes really defined.
Eyeliner: MAC Blacktrack fluidline for the classic black liner, MAC Aqualine liquidlast liner for something fun, and Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Honey for something super pretty but simple 😀

Alexis B. Avatar
Alexis B.

lipgloss: for color I LOVE MAC Truth & Light – I would die if I could get my hands on another one of those 🙁

mascara: Bare Escentuals, Buxom Lash and MAC Zoom Lash

liner: Urban Decay 24/7 in Bourbon

kelliegonzo Avatar
kelliegonzo

* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? – co bigelow
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? – diorshow iconic
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? – style styli line & seal 24 hr twist

<3

Kelsie Avatar
Kelsie

Favorite lip gloss: Bare Escentuals Lip Buxom in Destiny or Urban Decay pocket rocket in Doug
Favorite mascara: Too-faced lash injection pinpoint
Favorite eyeliner: Urban decay 24/7 glide on eye pencil in electric

AA Avatar
AA

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?

MAC Ripe & Rich

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?

MAC Plushlash

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?

MAC Stubborn Brown

Amber Avatar
Amber

Fave lipgloss – always changing! right now, it’s BE Buxon in Ginger.
Fave mascara – Giorgio Armani Eyes To Kill
Fave eyeliner – Lancome Le Stylo Waterproof in Chataigne.

Catherine Avatar
Catherine

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Laura Mercier Lip Plumper in Persimmon. Laura Mercier really knows how to do her lip products! My all-time favorite are her stickglosses, but her actual glosses are amazingly nice too! (And this is coming from someone who wears lipstick 24/7!

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Kiss Me Heroine Long and Curl Mascara. The only mascara that gives me lift, length and doesn’t smudge all day!

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? The UD 24/7s, even though they still smudge on my lower lashline a little bit. I want to try the MUFE Aqua Eyes soon though. They’ve been on my list for quite a while.

Ceriene Avatar
Ceriene

Never tried the UD 24/7s though I purchased MUFE’s Aqua Eyes very recently. I ended up getting too, because they stay on the waterline like nobody’s business. I definitely suggest trying them out!

Fari Avatar
Fari

Favorite Lipgloss: It always changes, but usually i reach for Viva Glam VI. its just so pretty on my lips haha. and sparkly.

Favorite Mascara: Lashblast. I try to find another HG mascara in high-end and low-end, but I always come back to this one.

Favorite Eyeliner : Liquid- Loreal Lineur Intense in Carbon Black. Pencil – UD 24/7 in zero.

Ann Avatar
Ann

extase contains fiber, so it lengthens your lashes like crazy. It also provides more volume than iconic and separates just as well. highly recommended!

UltraLuxe Avatar
UltraLuxe

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
CO Bigelow, actually. Right amount of stickiness, and I put it on thick before bed and in the morning, ALL lip flakies are gone!

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Haven’t found it yet.

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
WnW black liquid, cheap and works great.

Ashley K Avatar
Ashley K

Lipgloss: In general, MAC lustreglass. As far as color, I love nectar and little VI, but I change it up for different looks.
Mascara: My new love is supernova by fresh, plus the bottle gorgeous.
Eyeliner: UD 24/7

Sally Avatar
Sally

My Faves:

1) Lipgloss- MAC Lustreglass in Love Nectar or Chanel Glossimer in Pin-Up.

2) Mascara- Maybelline Define-A-Lash

3) Eyeliner- MAC Feline Kohl Power

Wilcoa Avatar
Wilcoa

Lipgloss: MAC Viva Glam IV (I think lol, the label has worn off, but it is one of the more recent VG)
Mascara: Maybelline FNS
Eyeliner: MUFE aqua eyes 0L, a bit “harder” than the 24/7 ones which I feel I break or go through quicker.

Darrien Avatar
Darrien

Mascara: By far DiorShow, one the best I have ever tried.
Lipgloss: NARS Turkish Delight, I love baby pinks.
Eyeliner: MUFE Aqua Eyes, 0L of course the everyday black but I also love 6L which is like a black/purple and 23L which is champagney color. Lets just put it this way I love all the colours!

Bridgette Avatar
Bridgette

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? YSL Golden Gloss
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? YSL Volume Effet Faux Cils
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Revlon Colorstay pencil eyeliner

KC Avatar
KC

Fav. Lipgloss: Revlon Shiny Sheers in 845 Sheer Plumdrop. Sadly they stop making these 🙁

Fav. Mascara: L’Oreal Voluminous in Carbon Black

Fav. Eyeliner: MAC Technakohl in Graphblack.

CeeBee Avatar
CeeBee

* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
DiorKiss – especially love the old 18mL tubes, the colour range and formula was great.

* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
DiorShow – Goes on well, excellent pigment, doesn’t smudge or flake and smells like roses. Yum. Iconic isn’t bad either!

* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Revlon Luxurious Eyeliner in Sueded Brown. Warm metallic chocolate, goes on without dragging, lasts all day without smudging.

Trish Avatar
Trish

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Mac Viva Glam VI
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Lash Stiletto
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Urban Decay 24/7 (any color)

Mariana Avatar
Mariana

lipgloss: MAC lipglass in Vibrational (LE)
mascara: MAC Plushlash (with a primer b/c it smudges under my eyes) 🙂
eyeliner: MAC Technakohl in Earthline

Megan Avatar
Megan

Favorite lipglass: MAC Pop Mode
Favorite mascara: Max Factor 2000 Calorie
Favorite eyeliner: A tie between MAC Blacktrack fluidline and UD 24/7 in Covet

Cindy Avatar
Cindy

* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC Springbean lustreglass
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? MAC Plushlash
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? MAC Blacktrack fluidline
🙂

Marissa B Avatar
Marissa B

Fave lipgloss….MAC creamsheen glass in boy bait! One of my good friends turned me onto this and its now my absolute fave. The perfect bude pink! Need to buy a back up 😉
Fave mascara…Bare Essentuals Buxom Lash. LOVE.
Fave eyeliner….loreal lineur intense carbon black!

Dusty Avatar
Dusty

Lipgloss: Not a gloss really, but I make my own lip-plumper that I use ALL THE TIME! It has a very matte finish. So yeah, it’s not really a gloss 😉

Mascara: MAC’s Plushlash

Eyeliner: Covergirl’s Perfect Point Plus in Black Onyx – I never use it but it was my weapon of choice back in high school so I have very fond memories of it 🙂 I still keep some with me for good luck – LOL!

amy Avatar
amy

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC Lustreglass Wonderstruck
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Maybelline Colossal Volume Express Mascara
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? U/D 24/7 Glide on liners

Christy Avatar
Christy

Lipgloss: MAC Lipglass in Sweet Strawberry.
Mascara: Diorshow Blackout. My lashes look fake when I wear it, it’s just expensive to wear everyday.
Eyeliner: MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack. With a MAC 212 brush, it is the easiest way to do my upper lashline. Second favorite is MAC Feline because it’s so utterly black.

penelope Avatar
penelope

lipgloss= lancome color fever and dior addict (non-sticky)
mascara= max factor volume couture wp (lengthening and curl)
eyeliner= urban decay zero (smooth, silky and long lasting)

Bythia Avatar
Bythia

My favorite lipgloss: Stila lip glaze in pink (for the taste and wearability)or MUFE liquid lip color in 7
My favorite mascara: Covergirl Lashblast
My favorite eyeliner: MAC fuidline blacktrack

minek Avatar
minek

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Does Rouge Allure Lacque count as a gloss?
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? YSL Faux Cils
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Lancome Art Liner…I don’t have the fine motor skills for anything other than a felt tip! :p

sandra Avatar
sandra

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
MAC’s Love Nectar

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
MAX Factor’s Masterpiece

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
MAC’s Fluidline

Alyx Avatar
Alyx

* What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
I looove She Loves Candy from the Hello Kitty collection
* What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
At the moment LashFusion XL from Fushion Beauty, but BadGal Lash is amazing too
* What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Hmmm Im sorta new to different eyeliners but UD Zero seems to be fantastic.

itie Avatar
itie

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
NARS, Lancome Juicy Tubes, MAC Dazzlecreme

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Lancome Osc.

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Urban Decay and Lancome Eye Kohl

Steffi Avatar
Steffi

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time?
Lancome Color Fever Gloss “Dangerously Pink”

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time?
Chanel Exceptionnel Black

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time?
Isadora Perfect Contour Kajal “Silver”

Sarah M Avatar
Sarah M

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? – MAC Plushglass in Cushy White.
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? – Clinique High Impact Mascara in Black.
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? – MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil in Feline.

Sans Avatar
Sans

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? Vaseline (always handy)
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Mac Plushlash
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? UD Perversion/Smolder

Jess Avatar
Jess

Lipgloss: Chanel Glossimers…love the color/texture and no icky scent
Mascara: Lancome Defincils…no clumping and long, long lashes
Eyeliner: I rarely use pencil eyeliners, so I’m going with Bare Escentuals powder liners….love them! I use a thin slanted brush to apply and they can be applied dry or wet

Jenni Avatar
Jenni

Fav mascara: Imju Fiberwig
Fav eyeliner: MAC technakohl in graphblack

Don’t have a fav lipgloss, but I’m reading comments here to get some products I can try!

Reza Avatar
Reza

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? BE Buxom Lips in Destiny
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? Rimmel The MAX Volume Flash (in the hot pink tube, their new one; WOW!) is tied for first place with BE Buxom Mascara, where you get almost the same effect but without parabens or nasty additives–it’s much pricier, though.
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Still looking!

MissDeeCanada Avatar
MissDeeCanada

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC LYCHEE LUXE

What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? L’OREAL VOLUMNOUS

What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? Canadian Brand, ANABELLE, tons of colours and like under 5$ each. GOSH cosmetics also makes some really nice soft ones for about 10$

nina Avatar
nina

favorite lipgloss: usually i dont wear lg very often, but if i had to choose it would be manhattan tasty lipgloss

favorite mascara: diorshow :)best one i ever had

favorite eyeliner: blacktrack fluidline, because it stays so long and looks good

Vanessa Avatar
Vanessa

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC Prrr..
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? CoverGirl LashExact
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? MAC Engraved Powerpoint

Eve Avatar
Eve

L/g: MAC Plushglass in Ample Pink/MAC Lipglass in Lust. They both have actually same mauvey-pink color which is perfect for my poor-pigmented lips, and lasts forever. And the smell… yummm!

Mascara: classical Bourjois Volume Glamour. Old love does not rust.

Eyeliner: Dior Waterproof Crayon Eyeliner, Shiseido The Makeup Eyeliner Pencil (prefer black, dark brown and plum/burgundy ones).

Desiree Avatar
Desiree

Nothing of is a favorite of ‘all time’ but at the moment…(I’m around nw40-43, for reference):

fave lipgloss: NYX megashine lipgloss in Desert (a cool plummy brown)

fave lipstick: MAC lipstick in Craving and Velvet Teddy (I don’t wear Craving much these days but man, it’s a great pink shade for darker complexions)

fave eyeliner: I don’t really wear eyeliner too much because lately it just seems like such a harsh addition to eye makeup. But if I had to say, I love Coastal Scents gel liner in True Black (it’s super dark, a true jet black) and I like L’Oreal Extra Intense Liquid Liner Pencil Eyeliner in Noir (its a cheaper version of the UD pencil in Zero but way better!)

Shirley Avatar
Shirley

What’s your favorite lipgloss of all-time? MAC Lipglass – she loves candy (LE *CRY*)
What’s your favorite mascara of all-time? covergirl lashblast, better than ALL the department store brands i’ve tried
What’s your favorite eyeliner of all-time? mac fluidline

K Avatar
K

Favorite lipgloss of all-time? Yet TBD.
Favorite mascara of all-time? L’Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara in Black
Favorite eyeliner of all-time? Urban Decay 24/7 Liner in Bourbon

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!