Are you getting anything from MAC’s Magic, Mirth, & Mischief Collection? Or are you skipping?
.
I’ll be there front and center to review!
.
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
Haha, I usually wait until your reviews to see if I want anything, but so far…nothing’s really striking me.
Yep – me too – waiting to see tempting swatches and reviews…I may want the purple e/s duo but that’s it.
I have been waiting for you!!! But I know I am getting Put a Spell on you, the Chocolate Eye bag, Surprise me Lipstick ( awesome peach colour) and the teal mineral eye shadow.
I am too waiting for the reviews. So far there is nothing that catchs my attention.
I don’t know…
I want things from other brands like I want nailpolishes from Zoya so I might skip to keep money for those
The “Sorceress” and “Smoke & Mirrors” palettes, and the two face color palettes! 🙂
nothing so far. i have been taking an interest on other brands as well like from nars, ysl and dior.
Smoke & Mirrors!
I already got Jingle Jangle and She-Zam!
No.
Although the glitter liner and jingle jangle dazzleglass calls to me, I’ve got no money.
I’m saving it all for Baroque Bourdoir!
Heck yes! Got a $100 gift card carefully saved for this.
i liked teh palettes, but i will wait for reviews and later buy frm CCO…the sephora sale is nearby, so all the fund has been diverted….:)
Hope I’ll manage to get Do the Trick! brush set.
I need to see swatches on a blog first as I always have to order online because I don’t have mac counter close to me.
Hahaha, I usually wait for your reviews first. I’m kind of interested in Super Duper Natural blush… but not sure if it’s too close to Nuance quite yet.
I’m so thrilled when I can actually reply ‘NO’ to this question.
I definitely want to see your reviews first–so far, I am eyeing She-Zam dazzleglass, the mineralize blushes, and maybe $$$$ yes (I missed it on the first go-round).
maybe sourcress eye set and boy bait cremeglass. mostly waiting for your swatches and reviews first though.
YES! Picked up my stuff on Sunday!
Waiting on you as well christine. The stuff looks okay but I didn’t see any major deals or anything I’m dying for. Also, did you do away with letter grades for products? Cause they really helped!
I already picked up the Alakazam eye set (which looks so gorgeous together it’s crazy) but I may go back and get the House of Mirth lip set. The lip stick and pencil alone are AMAZING even though it’s a lustre. that set is exactly what I’ve been looking for and now I may just have to go get it! I’m so glad I have access to 2 counters and a store incase this sells out quick!
Yes, I’m planning on buying one or two of the mini lipglasses and maybe an e/s quad. I can’t really decide on the rest yet, I have to see everything at the counter first.
I’m not planning on much. Waiting for reviews and then I’ll order. 🙂
Yes of course! I already did some damage at a preview party last week….and I know I will be getting more!
Not as much as I thought I would be getting. I’m picking up the Sorceress palette, the Smokey palette, both mineral kits, and both mineralize blushes. I might get the peachy lipstick, She-Zam and an eyeshadow. The silver and gold crescents on the MES’s are apparently glitter bombs, so I find it hard to justify $19.50 for an eyeshadow and about 1/3 of it I won’t use. If they still have them available during the sale in January, I might get them.
Definitely all the mineralize stuff, plus dazzleglasses (in fact I’ve already managed to get 2 of them from eBay), and possibly one or two palettes. Not the bags though.
I bought the 6 Mystic Cool eyeshadow palette and the Put a spell on you pink lipbag and the Naughty Noir eye bag.
I’m only getting the exclusive kit that has Nuance mineralize blush in it. And that’s only because I adore that blush and have been patiently waiting for its re-release! Nothing else moves me, though. I’ll have to see in person.
Waiting for reviews, but so far I’m only thinking of the warm palette and maybe some mini piggie when they come out, just to round out some basics to my collection.
I am probably getting the two glitter pencils and at least one mineralize eyeshadow or the sorceress palette but I booked an appointment for a MAC event for next Thursday so I probably won’t get anything until then.
I’ll probably skip most of the colour collection, but i think i’m gonna go all out on the eye palettes and mini sets.
Most likely Blue Sorcery 🙂
Put a spell on you Pink lip bag!!
So excited 🙂
I’ going to skip as I do every year. I love MAC but for some reason every Holiday collection disappoints.
I definately won’t buy a single product, because of the packaging and the reason that I bought too many products last month so I have to cut down my MAC-money.
We already had an early launch and I got 2 eyeshadow palates, a brush set, one of the pigment/fluid line sets and a lip set. Love them all! I think I have a makeup problem…. Sigh!
Oh-I just left MAC on my lunch break! I got the two mineralized blushes, two palettes (warm eyes and mystic eyes) and I got one (the pinker one) of the beauty powder/blush set. I will be back tomorrow to get a brush set and another eye palette. I will be getting ALL the pigments and lipglosses on Nov. 5th! I love MAC!!!!!!
Went to Nordies and swatched the eye shadow sets. Nothing really different from MAC’s permanaent collection. So skipping those. Skipping the mineralize duos because the glitter side is chunky and difficult to work with. I might get a lipstick and the dazzleglasses, but the sets are blah. Trust me, nothing exciting.
I’m thinking about the mineralize set with Shimpagne, but not for sure yet.
Not likely. Nothing from this collection jumps out at me as a must-have. I’m looking forward to Mischief Makers!
Yesterday I went to one of my MAC counters to buy m/u remover wipes and they had received the collection and the MA asked me if I wanted a peek. I could not swatch the products but still. I also reserved what I wanted. ISince I don’t like palettes, I didn’t put any on hold but damn, I have to admit that the face trio palettes are way cool and tempting!…
I am going to pick up my stash tomorrow. I am getting:
– both blushes
– both eyeliners (I just ran out of Nightsky 2 days ago!) which I owned before and really liked
– 2 lipsticks (the pink ones)
– 3 e/s duos (the blue one, the burgundy one, the brown one)
– $$$ nail polish (I passed on it the last time)
– all the Dazzle glasses
– 2 of the Dazzleglass Cremes (I already have the lilac one)
And to think that I was so sure that I was done coveting MAC stuff until after Christmas!!!
Ooops! Wasn’t finished..
Since I own so much MAC m/u, one of the problems I run into with sets and palettes is that I usually have at least 2-3-4 of the colors/products already so it’s totally not worth it for me to buy again of what I already have for 1 or 2 colors. I also find that the quality and pigmentation of the palettes is substandard. Same for the short handle brushes; they are cute and the bags as well but I own almost all the regular size brushes and prefer to carry them around with me in a special MAC bag. Besides, their quality is lower than the regular ones too.
I think I’ll pass — wait, did I really say that??
I’m kind of waiting for some money to come in and when it does, I’ll probably spend it on NARS blushes, I’ve been SO eager to try them out! I’ve also just found out there is a store in my city that sells OPI and one that sells Shu Umeurheureua (can’t remember that name!). Hmmm, should use the search box to see if you’ve ever done a review on their curlers…
Probably.
But i’m waiting for your swatches of the palettes 🙂
I went to check out the collection today, and I have to say I was NOT impressed at all. I’ll be skipping this collection.
i was going to get shmpagne till i read it’s exactly like soft and gentle.wtff
It’s similar for sure!
I picked up my stuff today. I got the smoke and mirrors and the pallette with the purples I cant remember the name. I got all four lipsticks Conjure up, all the dazzleglasses, house of mirth lip bag and the naughty noir eye bag and hocus focus.
how did you like the smoke and mirrors palette? i really want it but i want to carefully spend my money!
i really want the fun in the sun set since i own nothing from that set and it looks absolutely gorgeous (: can anyone tell me if they sell the set at nordstroms?
ive decided to skip out in this one, i dont like mineralized eyeshadows very much,
but i am looking forward to the other holiday items, such as the holiday eye palettes, which are all limited edition shades!!! finally, no sneaking in of permanent colors in the palettes. cant wait!
I was on their website last night and nothing was appealing to me and now seeing the swatches it still isn’t something I fancy.
I’ll skip and wait for the holiday collection.
Wasn’t planning on it Trying to save 🙂 Maybe a dazzleglass or blush if I’m tempted. reviews look pretty good.
I picked up the Devil May Dare warm eyes palette. I was looking at the smoke and mirrors however both the MUA and I felt i’d have dupes for all the colours in what i already own and the warm would suit my green eyes better. The green shadow in it was still really close to Sumptuous Olive, a bit brighter with more yellow, but all in all a good palette. That’s about all I will be getting. I also picked up Graphology as its now discontinued.
I’m going to get both face kits I think they both look beautiful other than that probably nothing else
after style black i thaught none of the follwowing collections intrested me that much and i thaught id pass on this one and maybe just get she zam dazzleglass.
but those MES are so tempting!! i especially love midnight madness, its a miracle and blue sorcery.
I was thinking to get a couple palettes, waiting for your review though Christine !!!!!!
I may look at one of the eyeshadow kits. The two or three things I thought I might get are definite no’s now!
I will check them out but nothing appeals to me. Gonna pass.
I plan on getting lipsticks Total Wow & Surprise Me, I also might get Pervette too(idky). In dazzleglass I am getting Jingle Jangle & Phiff! However I don’t think I plan on wearing and layering surprise me & phiff until spring because the color reminds me of Miami lol.
Does anyone know if these colors are going to become apart of Mac’s permanent collection???, so then I can save my $$ and buy surprise me & phiff! later.
I really though I was going to skip this collection but now I’ve seen the artst looks on the US website (I’m in UK 🙁 so have to wait til November) I’m going to get midnight madness or it’s a miracle MES, probably blue sorcery because i love turquoise and was reallly disappointed by Strike a pose eyeshadow, which I thought would be more like this one looks, but will wait to see more swatches of it.
Superdupernatural blush, i just love the name
maybe one of the creamsheen glosses as I’m a pale lip fanatic at the moment
I got the ever so rich, since it was sold out with the creme sheen release..or whatever that release was, i also bought pervette and night sky! yay!
I got sorceress and smoke and mirrors pallets. I also got midnight madness and its a miracle duos. I wished the pallets were a little more pigmented though.
interested in the face palette, but that’s pretty much it. i’m trying to destash at the moment!!
I’m honestly not too excited about this collection.
I do like the teal mineralized eyeshadow (but not the silver part in it!) and the silver dazzleglass (I forget the names), but other than those, I don’t think I’ll get anything.
I like the cream sheen glasses :D, I think they would rock over some of limecrime’s new lippies which I am eargerly awaiting to recieve.
Same goes with the dazzleglasses :D!!
I love the pink nailpolish, and I would love to purchase the lighter face-kit.
I also wanted to get one of the lip sets, it’s such a pretty bag ~!!