63 Comments

Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!

Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).

We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!

Comments on this post are closed.
Elle Jaye Avatar

â– Your skin tone/coloring: MAC NC50
â– Favorite fall lip color? NARS Volga or MAC Diva with MAC Nightmoth liner
â– Favorite fall blush color? NARS Dolce Vita/MAC Fever
â– Favorite fall eye palette?
I like the Coastal Scents Fall Festival Palette or my Wet N Wild Comfort Zone palette.

Mindy Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:
Favorite fall lip color? Last season Chanel had limited edition lipstick called Caracrere and I loved it! Clinique Black Honey is another good choice.
Favorite fall blush color? I love plums. Tartes Blushing Bride and Dazzeled will probably see a lot of love from me.
Favorite fall eye palette? I still love Tarte’s True Blood pallet for fall. Although Lorac Pro Palette will be used frequently as well.

Kate Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: maybe NW15, I use Laura Mercier Silk Creme in Soft Ivory, sometimes adding some Illamasqua Skin Base 02 to lighten it further.
Favorite fall lip color? – Sleek True Color Lipstick in Cherry, Korres lipgloss in Ruby Red
Favorite fall blush color? – Sleek Flushed
Favorite fall eye palette? – I rarely use palettes, mostly individual colors.

Audrey Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Pale, MAC NW13, Chanel BR-12 in Vitalumiere aqua
Favorite fall lip color? Tarte Dazzled Lipsurgence (rosy with shimmer)
Favorite fall blush color? Tarte Blushing Bride (powder)
Favorite fall eye palette? Lorac PRO palette or my MAC palette, although I still have 6 spaces to fill.

Joanne Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Tan w/yellow undertones (NARS Tahoe, MAC NC43)
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Talk that Talk & Bright Plum
Favorite fall blush color? Nars Mata Hari & Dolce Vita
Favorite fall eye palette? Urban Decay Naked Palette — all year around 🙂

A Name Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Maybe NC30, although it didn’t really match
Favorite fall lip color?: Mac Brick O La (though Chanel Imperial might challenge it once I get a chance to wear it)
Favorite fall blush color?: Nars Taos? My other blushes are summery, I’m still looking for a more toned down brown/orange colour. Maybe Nars Silvana.
Favorite fall eye palette? Don’t own much eyeshadow, but Urban Decay Smog seems like a great fall colour.

Mariella Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Brick-o-la or New York Apple
Favorite fall blush color? Tarte Natural Beauty
Favorite fall eye palette? Hmmm – it’s a toss up between Dior Bonne Etoile (hey, I waited for it forever!) and the original Naked palette because the colours in that are still among the best “autumn leaves” type shades.

becca Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: nc/nw10, very pale neutral
Favorite fall lip color? chanel rouge coco in cambon, ysl rouge volupte #2
Favorite fall blush color? tom ford wicked, chanel rose ecrin
Favorite fall eye palette? tom ford she wolf

courtney Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:fair/light
Favorite fall lip color? Revlon black cherry
Favorite fall blush color? Elf tickled pink
Favorite fall eye palette? Urban decay vice 2, too faced pretty rebel and lorac pro

ElKay Avatar

â– Your skin tone/coloring: NW-25
â– Favorite fall lip color? Givenchy Rose Dentelle
â– Favorite fall blush color? Nars Gina
â– Favorite fall eye palette? I’ve been really loving my Marc Jacobs lolita

Alicja Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: light/medium, warm

Favorite fall lip color? purple (Mac Heroine), dark berry (Sleek Cranberry), dark fuchsia (Mac Embrace me), fuchsia-plum (Mac Flat out fabulous)

Favorite fall blush color? red-brown/bronze-rose (Sleek Antique), wine berry (Sleek Fenberry), light peach.

Favorite fall eye palette? my own Inglot fall-palette including: AMC shine 108, 407P, 605P, 607P, 450P, 405P, 409P, 457DS, AMC72 and 446P.

Dominique Avatar

â—¾Your skin tone/coloring: NW 20

â—¾Favorite fall lip color? : Dior 999

â—¾Favorite fall blush color? : Guerlain Madame Rougit

◾Favorite fall eye palette? : Chanel Mystère

Let Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: probably around NC25 right now
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Mehr or Strictly Plutonic
Favorite fall blush color? MAC Hidden Treasure
Favorite fall eye palette? BareMinerals The Happy Place quad

Jill Avatar

– very light, about nc15/20
– plum/berry. my favorite is inglot lip paint 58
– either dark rose (nars amour) or orange (sephora apricot brandy)
– wet n wild comfort zone

Amber Avatar

Skintone/coloring: Bobbi Brown Alabaster/00
Favorite fall lip color: I have a few! Guerlain Orgueile, Guerlain Gigolo, YSL RVS Prune in Fire and UD Venom.
Favorite fall blush color – NARS Douceur
Favorite fall eye palette – UD Naked

xamyx Avatar

Skintone/Coloring: Fairly light, very neutral; dark-featured.

Lip: I tend to gravitate towards nudes & other soft shades because I tend to go deeper/heavier on the eyes. However, on “lazier” days, I’ll go for something vampy.

Blush: I haven’t figured it out yet, but I’m thinking NARS Douceur will be one I reach for often. It’s still pretty hot where I am, so I haven’t been wearing full-face looks…

Eyeshadow palette: UD Black Palette, although I have to pull some lighter shades, and a highlighter, but the jewel-tones are just so pretty. UD Smoked is also pretty good, and has everything but the highlighter.

Nikki Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC50
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Rebel Lipglass
Favorite fall blush color? It’s a tie between La Femme Grape & La Femme Bordeaux.
Favorite fall eye palette? I use the same palettes year round: a self-made neutral palette and Wet n Wild’s Comfort Zone.

Maddie Avatar

â– Your skin tone/coloring: C3/NC20.
â– Favorite fall lip color? Sephora Collection Rouge Cream Lipstick in Courtisane, OCC Lip Tar in Anita and Maybelline Midnight Plum (1005).
â– Favorite fall blush color? Hmmm, at the moment Sephora Collection Orange Punchy Blush, but I’m really trying to find a perfect neutral, MATTE blush that doesn’t make me look muddy (MAC Harmony, I’m looking at you!) Any suggestions, Christine? 😀
â– Favorite fall eye palette? My own Inglot Palette containing 102R, 421, 423 and 452. Inglot 452 over MAC Constructivist… LOVE!

Clio Avatar

Skin tone: warm olive tone
Fall lip: MAC Viva Glam I, Rimmel Bordeaux, Revlon Catwalk
Fall blush: theBalm Cabana Boy, MAC Tease Your Tastes.

Veronica Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10/15
Favorite fall lip color? Hmm, that’s a tough one…we’ll go with NARS Valparaiso
Favorite fall blush color? Bobbi Brown Nude Pink
Favorite fall eye palette? I don’t have a specific palette, but I generally go a tad smokier on the eyes, like plummy taupes and browns.

Erica Avatar

Skin Tone: MUFE 177/Mac NC 50/55
Favorite fall lip color: Tom Ford Black Orchid
Favorite fall blush color: Mac Raizin/Nars Dolce Vita
Favorite fall eye palette: UD Naked I palette (started playing with my UD Vice 2 palette though….).

Karen Avatar

-skin tone light with warm undertones.
-favourite fall lip colour Mac Rebel. Also really been loving Kat Von D lipstick Maus from the holiday set, sure hope it becomes permanent!
-favourite fall blush Benefit Bella Bomba.
-favourite fall eye palette Kat Von D Spellbinding book of shadows, Kat Von D Ladybird palette, as well as the new Urban Decay Vice 2 palette.

Andi Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Neutral fair
Favorite fall lip color? Red
Favorite fall blush color? Peach
Favorite fall eye palette? I don’t use pallettes – usually go for yellow-orange-red fade.

Deb Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: A little lighter than NW15
Favorite fall lip color? Nude browns and pinks
Favorite fall blush color? MAC Pink Tea, taupey pinks in general
Favorite fall eye palette? Always Urban Decay Naked

Nortme Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC30/35
Favorite fall lip color: Mac Hug Me (MLBB), Mac Brave (neutral pink), Mac Plumful (rose/plum)
Favorite fall blush color: Mac Warm Soul, Nars Deep Throat, Nars Sin
Favorite fall eye palette: Dior Bonne Etoile, UD Naked, Shiseido Voyage, Nars And God Created the Woman

Mariela Benitez Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium/Yellow undertones
Favorite fall lip color? Mac Ruby Woo
Favorite fall blush color? Tarte Blushing bride
Favorite fall eye palette? Lorac Pro palette

kelly Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Mac NC 35
Favorite fall lip color? Last year Mac Rebel, this year I’m in love with new Mac Fix on drama
Favorite fall blush color? Mac Prisma and Nars Deep Throat.
Favorite fall eye palette? almost never use eyeshadows, but Naked 1 is good for all seasons.

Azreen Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Warm/Bobbi Brown’s 4.5 Warm Natural
Favorite fall lip color: NARS Mysterious Red for a fall red, or NARS Montego Bay for my perfect nude (I love a matte lip… can you tell?)
Favorite fall blush color: Chanel’s cream blush in Destiny, or NARS Dolce Vita
Favorite fall eye palette: not a huge eye shadow girl, but I have been using Smashbox Softbox 2 – (a lot of fallout)

Chris25 Avatar

Skintone: Tanned with yellow undertones (NC40-42).

Fave fall lip color?: Revlon Super Lustrous l/s in Raisin Rage and Wet n Wild MegaLast l/s in Cherry Bomb.

Fave fall blush?: NYX Raisin, NARS Crazed.

Fave fall eye palette?: NARS Cordura and Kat Von D Ludwig.

Precious Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NC20

Favorite fall lip color? Burberry Lip Cover Soft Satin Lipstick in Bright Plum, Chanel Luminous Intense Lipstick in Rouge Noir and Rouge Coco in Culte, Guerlain Rouge G in Gigolo and Rouge G L’Extrait in Orgueil, MAC Lipstick in Rebel and Pro Longwear Lipcreme in Endless Drama

Favorite fall blush color? MAC Powder Blush in Trace Gold, NARS Powder Blush in Madly and Seduction,Tom Ford Cheek Color in Wicked

Favorite fall eye palette? Chanel Eyeshadow Quads in Harmonie du Soir and Raffinement, Guerlain Ecrin 4 Couleurs Les Ombres Turandot

Jan Avatar

In Fall:

Skin tends toward NC42
Lipstick: Love MAC Odyssey but it does sting a little. Wish it were more moist as the color is perfect.
Blush: Toss up between NARS Dolce Vita and Taos
Eye Palette: I’d still have to say LORAC Pro

Megs Avatar

NW 25 now, will lighten to NW 20 as it cools off

Lips: MAC Desire or Darkside lipstick, lipglass in Pop Mode, NARS lipgloss in Dolce Vita
Blush: MAC Fever, NARS Dolce Vita and Sin
Eyes: self made MAC quad: Seedy Pearl highlight or lid, Haux in crease, Sketch to define or outer v, Cranberry as an accent, I also like Vex on the lid, Club on outer V over black liner

Quinn Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Yellow undertones/nc15
Favorite fall lip color? vampy reds and purple, black of course
Favorite fall blush color? I don’t really wear blush.
Favorite fall eye palette? cool toned taupes, matte blacks.

Melissa Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:
pale with blue/yellow undertones

Favorite fall lip color?
mac rebel paired with sephora’s nano liner in pleasant plum
kat von d homegirl (usually overtop a red lipliner or pleasant plum)
wet n wild vamp it up and cherry bomb
mac diva
nars fire down below

Favorite fall blush color?
nars dolce vita

Favorite fall eye palette?
naked2 and naked basics. since i do intense lipcolors, especially in fall, i like keeping my eyes neutral.

Sarah Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Sephora 2Y06, I think a MAC NC20 – light with yellow undertones

Is it bad that I don’t really differentiate between summer and fall makeup? Maybe it’s because I live in Southern California. I am going to be dyeing my hair chesnut brown, which I’m pretty excited about, so I’m going to be experimenting with different smoky eyes and trying out my new Sonia Kashuk Spiced Berry and Hourglass Icon lipsticks.

Mietta Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: NW10-15
Favorite fall lip color? Illamasqua’s Growl
Favorite fall blush color? NARS Sex Appeal (I’m quite red and don’t really like wearing a lot of blush)
Favorite fall eye palette? My own that I put into a z-palette.

Suzanne Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light pale neutral

Favorite fall lip color? revlons plum velvet

Favorite fall blush color? rose d oro blush by Milani

Favorite fall eye palette? Seduction by Chanel

Emmm Avatar

1. Light/pinkish NC20 in MAC
2. Urban Decay Revolution Lipstick in Venom
3. MAC Cubic or NARS Sin
4. My MAC palette or NARS And God Created The Woman palette

breyerchic04 Avatar

Light but not porcelain, pink toned
Plums, Berries, and Chocolate Reds. Currently loving UD Rapture and MAC Sweet Succulence.
MAC Breath of Plumb sheertone blush, but I pretty much use it and Benefit Coralista all year round
I don’t have a favorite fall palette yet, but I’m feeling some of the Bobbi Brown holiday ones.

tzwiggy Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Light-medium, peachy (NW20-25)

Favorite fall lip color? I love mauvey pinks for fall! UD Rush (the old formula!), MAC Syrup, Chanel Rouge Coco Shine in Boy

Favorite fall blush color? Muted mauve, burgundy, plum and berry pinks. MAC Plum Foolery, Chanel Fantasia, NARS Sin

Favorite fall eye palette? I don’t have a lot of eye palettes with what I consider typical fall colors. I think my favorite must be MAC Royal Assets in Warm Eyes (on old LE palette from the 2007 holiday collection, I believe) because two of my favorite fall eyeshadows, Club and Star Violet (both permanent), are in that palette. I honestly believe Star Violet is one of MAC’s most underrated eyeshadows. It’s really wearable (no punched-in-the-eye or cried-all-night look!) and so creamy and smooth. It really is the perfect burgundy eyeshadow for fall!

Laura Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair, cool-toned (MAC NW15ish), red hair, green eyes.

Favorite fall lip color? Vampy colours like MAC’s Rebel, Cyber, or Rocker, as well as plums/mauves like Plumful or Aristo-Cat.

Favorite fall blush color? Nars Sin, MAC Plum Foolery, MAC Gentle

Favorite fall eye palette? Hmm, Kat Von D Ludwig Palette (greens) and MAC Burmese Beauty quad are both nice, and you can’t go wrong with either of the Naked palettes!

A. Mar Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Fair/Neutral
Favorite fall lip color? NARS Terre De Feu. A favorite!
Favorite fall blush color? Illamasqua Zygomatic. Though it really is a blush I use most of the year.
Favorite fall eye palette? UD Naked. I’ll need to buy Vice 2.

Danielle Avatar

â– Your skin tone/coloring: NC15
â– Favorite fall lip color: Anything red!
â– Favorite fall blush color: NARS Sin, NYX Mauve, Laura Mercier Spiced Cider
â– Favorite fall eye palette: I have really been loving my MAC palettes. I made myself a little quad of autumn colors: Sumptuous Olive, Coppering, Cranberry, & Amber Lights.

Kelly Avatar

â—¾Your skin tone/coloring: MAC N3 – fair/medium
â—¾Favorite fall lip color? Sephora Rouge Shine in Make Me Famous (berry) with MAC Dazzleglass in Date Night
â—¾Favorite fall blush color? MAC mineralize blush in Gleeful
â—¾Favorite fall eye palette? Sephora Smokey Bergundy

Lauren Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Medium/NC30
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Brick-O-La, Bite Beauty Lip Pencil in Rhubarb, em Michelle Phan shade play palette in Mix it Up Roses (really!)
Favorite fall blush color? Smashbox Halo in Warm Glow, Tarte Exposed, Tarte Blushing Bride
Favorite fall eye palette? Tarte Amazonian Escape

Natasha Avatar

I love reading the comments on threads like this:)

Your skin tone/coloring: very pale, usually the lightest or 2nd lightest in the shade range
Favorite fall lip color? MAC Girl About Town (new fav)
Favorite fall blush color?I’ve been using Laguna in place of blush recently
Favorite fall eye palette?Not exclusive to fall, but theBalm’s Nude Tude. Shades Sexy and Sassy in particular.

Sarah Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Very fair, neutral
Favorite fall lip color? UD Rapture, Clinique Black Honey, Revlon Pink Truffle and Sugar Plum
Favorite fall blush color? UD Greedy
Favorite fall eye palette? UD Vice 2 and Stila In the Garden

Li Wen Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring:
Light/medium beige with yellow and olive undertones

Favourite fall lip color?
Chantecaille Heirloom, Clarins Passion Red, NARS Beautiful Liar

Favourite fall blush color?
NARS Douceur, NARS Zen

Favourite fall eye palette?
I build my own custom palettes with my Z/Yaby palettes, so I rarely buy eye palettes with more than 2 shades. For Fall/Winter, though, I like my Serge Lutens eyeshadow palette for the dark, elegant liners.

Joanna Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: Giorgio Armarni Maestro Fusion Makeup #4
Favorite fall lip color?: MAC Film Noir
Favorite fall blush color? Mac Hidden Treasure
Favorite fall eye palette? Tom Ford She Wolf

Georgie Avatar

Your skin tone/coloring: nw15 ish
Favorite fall lip color? chanel rivoli or armani lip maestro in #400
Favorite fall blush color? MAC gleeful… my only fall blush (I need to rectify that) though I may just continue wearing my fave, rouge bunny rouge blush wand in titian.
Favorite fall eye palette? I don’t really use eye palettes

We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!