Wednesday, January 29th, 2014

Temptalia Asks You

What type of lipstick finishes work best on you? Share!
Temptalia's AnswerI like something slightly glossy with a little shimmer. I always like the way the look best on me, and they’re the most comfortable for me to wear.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

74 thoughts on “What type of lipstick finishes work best on you?

  1. Cream! Or really anything that helps my lips not scream HEY I’M REALLY DRY
    Rikki Recently Posted: Liebster Award

  2. Satin and creamy mattes, think Russian Red by Mac..that’s my favorite finish of all time!

  3. I love cream & matte finishes the most .

    As far as cream finishes , I love Milani’s Color Statement & Covergirl’s Lip Perfection Lipsticks .

    For mattes , I love MAC & NYX .

  4. keG

    I am usually happiest with a matte finish-it looks the most professional. I love shiny lipgloss also,so I guess it is one extreme to the other-depending on the occasion.

  5. breyerchic04

    No shimmer! I’ve often gone for sheer to semi sheer colors like Clinique Black Honey almost lipstick, MAC hot tahiti and plumful, but now I’m liking more opaque shades, the UD revolution lipsticks, mac up the amp, and I did buy my first retro matte, all fired up, that I LOVE.

  6. Bee

    Satin or slightly glossy – I can’t work with mattes at all, they’re too drying! But incredibly frosty finishes don’t work for me either (though I’m tempted by metallic lipsticks every now and again…).

  7. I love most finishes but have a weakness for opaque glossy finishes! :-)
    Vineetha Recently Posted: Urban Decay Naked 3 Palette Review, Swatches

  8. Since i have extremely dry and prune like lips lipsticks with a satin finish work the best for me!
    Lisha Recently Posted: Maybelline Lip Polish Glam 13 Review: The Best Nude Lipgloss!

  9. Cream/creme and lightly glossy finishes. Mattes don’t look very good on me in general, I don’t think. And rare is the frost that doesn’t take me back to 1992.
    Christina Recently Posted: Sihaya Designs Earring Club 2014: Three Months in Mixed Metals- Earring Subscription Service by SihayaDesigns

  10. ShannonE

    I like slightly to moderately glossy, with a nice texture. Love me some shimmer, but do not want it to feel sandy on my lips! A matte is ok, provided it is a vibrant color. Pale colors make me appear ill.

  11. Lisa

    Sheer & glossy.

    I actually really really loved the MAC huggable lipstick formula. I have lips that are extremely prone to peeling so I can only handle lipsticks that feel like chapstick.

  12. xamyx

    For regular, everyday wear, I find a natural, MLBB shade with a cream or satin finish is most appropriate, so by default it’s what works best. That said, for special occasions, or certain events, anything goes! It really depends on the rest of my look. If I go shimmery on the eyes, lips are creamy; conversely, if I go matte on the eye, I like sparkly lips. It’s really all about balance for me.

    I do tend to buy matte/cream lipsticks most since I find them more versatile. I can always change it by adding gloss, or wear it as it is.

  13. Hah, SNAP! 😀 I’m pretty much the same. I like a little juiciness, cos my lips get dry, and who doesn’t love a little sparkle? I like the appearance of mattes and frosts sometimes (particularly for vampy colours) but they can be so drying…
    Sylirael Recently Posted: Give ‘em Lip – Dior Universal Lipliner and a Rogueworthy Purple Look

  14. I really like the look of matte lipstick, but not the feel…satin finishes feel the best on my lips. No frost, glitter, or shimmer…only vivid color.

  15. Hmm. Speaking purely in terms of comfort, suitability, and what’s most flattering, I’d say something satiny but on the hydrating side, I guess like MAC’s Amplified Creme. Not too matte, so as to not emphasize texture, but not too creamy and shiny, which I find uncomfortable and likely to fold over itself where my lips meet. My aesthetic preferences are always for the extreme, though–very matte, or super-glittery and glossy!

  16. Jellies/crellies are my favorite, shimmer or no shimmer.

  17. I love creamy, slight glossy lipsticks with a translucent finish. No shimmer preferably!
    Ankita Recently Posted: Rimmel London (002) Nude in the Box eye shadow palette : Review, Swatches

  18. megan zacc

    Hi I recently bought a blush compact that has three seperate color blocks in it. The package says that it is conturing blush. I assumed since it was in the same colkr family that one shade would be ths color one the darker shade to contour n the third the luminating highlighting color. I’m not sure how to use this compact becUse they are all colors do u have any advice

    • xamyx

      If all the colors are in the same family, that’s most likely what it’s designed for. Contouring shades & highlighers *don’t* have to be “fleshtones”, and sometimes it’s actually more foolproof to contour/highlight with color! HTH

  19. I like cream lipsticks. MAC’s amplified colors are amazing. I like mattes that aren’t drying and lustre type finishes are always nice. I haven’t found a perfect lipstick that looks glossy yet tho.

  20. C

    Shimmer or satin seem to work best. Matte often makes my cheeks look dry for some reason.

  21. zainab

    Mattes (provided they’re not horribly dry), anything opaque without too much shimmer and frost usually looks okay. I’m not a fan of sheerer lipsticks because on me it never seems to look intentional- it just looks like I haven’t bothered to reapply it.

  22. Kat

    Mattes, unfortunately. I think they’re the most comfortable and look the best on me, but no matter how much I moisturize, my lips dry out like crazy. I don’t like gloss; it’s too sticky, and I almost always wear my hair down.

  23. Rachael

    Matte..most definitely….even then the kind that go on liquid and actually dry. I have like 200 lippies and have bought some many that aren’t thinking I can add some silica powder over them and make them matte but when it comes down to it they really don’t get wore often because of the up keep through the day that comes with that.

  24. A Name

    Very creamy – like Urban Decay Revolution or Mac Amplified Creme – if my lips are more dry, so especially in the winter, but more matte/semi-matte/satin is preferable at other times.

    Less creamy lipsticks, especially if they have shimmer often look awful, grainy and dry on me – I unfortunetely had this problem with the Chanel Rouge Coco and Bobbi Brown Rich Lip Color.

  25. Cecilia

    I’m all about matte lipsticks! I love a long lasting lipstick, and for that matte formulas are the best. I have quite full lips, so sometimes it looks a little too much if I wear a glittery or glossy formula. I also love a matte lipstick because it’s such a statement!

    I’m pretty new to this amazing site, so I’m not really sure how these “Temptalia Asks”-answers should be :) Thanks for a fabulous blog!

  26. I prefer lipstains, lip creams and liquid lipsticks to the traditional lipsticks, because the latter always seem to sit too heavily on my lips, and looks like an additional layer masking the real texture of my lips.

    But I found my holy grail lipstick formula in Catrice’s lipsticks. I don’t know how or why, but they’re so lightweight and moisturising that it feels like there’s nothing on your lips when you wear them. They don’t need a balm underneath, and they are very pigmented, last a long time and never bleed or feather. They’re all quite glossy/creamy-looking (not too much), however, and I prefer the matte look. The matte lip creams I’ve tried from Essence have been amazing, but I still haven’t found my holy grail matte lipstick formula. Until then, I stick with satin lipsticks, which are more comfortable to wear.
    Plurabelle Recently Posted: Update + MAC lipstick dupes

  27. I like them either matte or very glossy, but I am not a big fan of too much shimmer.

  28. I like all types of finishes, but especially luster, cream, satin and matte. I even like frosty finishes which everyone seems to think is dated. The formula used to create the lipsticks has to superb so that my lips wont dry out.

  29. I think a cream finish looks best on me. Something with a little sheen or shine to it, but no shimmer or sparkle. Those are fun too, and I also love a good matte, but if I could only pick one finish to wear for the rest of my life, it would be a nice cream.

  30. Sarah M

    I have really uneven lip colouring so I like my lipsticks to be quite opaque and true to the colour they are in the tube. I kind of like all finishes – matte, shimmery, glossy, etc. I guess it just depends on how dry my lips are that day, my mood and what I think will look good with the rest of my makeup.

  31. Matte, for sure. Or, at most, a slight satin sheen… Frosted seems to emphasize how not-smooth my small lips are. If I want a plump glossy finish I’ll just add gloss on top.

  32. Kate

    A smooth satin finish, like Chanel Rouge Allure and Guerlain Rouge G. I don’t like anything too creamy or sticky.or with plenty of slip.

  33. Lily

    Cremes and glossy finish for me. A little shimmer is ok.

  34. Samantha

    A creamy, shiny lipstick such as a creamsheen works well. Matte colours last longest, though.

  35. I don’t know if I would say that certain finishes look better on me – but overall, I typically prefer matte lips. Although lately I have been getting a bit back into gloss.

  36. Clio

    I admit I look best in a satin or medium-shine finish, but I can’t keep myself away from mattes. They’re like the bad boys you know you shouldn’t date, but you just can’t help yourself; the heart wants what it wants.

  37. My ideal formula is creamy with a satin finish. Not too much sheen and no feathering. The closest I’ve found seems to be UD Revolution lipsticks
    fancie Recently Posted: Long Time, No Haul!

  38. Veronica

    I generally prefer my matte and semi-matte finishes, with satin being the one I like most on me. I figure a good gloss can give any shine to the finish if I want. I own a few glossy lispticks, but the big drawback is that I find that they tend to have higher maintenance wear.

  39. brenda

    I think I look best in a satin or velvet – not quite matte- finish, or I actually really like MAC’s Lustre finishes. Nothing too shimmery, frosty or glossy for me.

  40. I love velvety mattes because they seem to flatter me and the shape of my lips best. My skin tends to be oily so adding anything glossy can be overkill.

  41. Sarah

    I have to say the Satin formula by MAC Cosmetics is my most loved on myself and even on others! It gives that semi-matte look without being drying! I find them super creamy and easy to work with therefore I think its one of the best for my lips!

  42. Chris

    A matte or semi matte finish is my go-to choice.

  43. Something creamy and hydrating, preferably without shimmer or too much frost.

  44. I always like a nice cream finish. Occasionally I’ll opt for matte. I tend to stay away from glosses because I don’t like the texture. Even the ones that aren’t really sticky are usually a bit too sticky for my tastes.

  45. liz

    super-matte, a) because I LOVE how mattes look on me, b) I have fine lines around my mouth (at 21!! UGH) and anything glossy just goes freaking everywhere and c) because I’m so lazy and hate touching up through the day. MAC mattes stay put on me for HOURS.

    I’m gonna give the Retro Mattes a shot pretty soon I think. I have my eye on flat-out fabulous!

  46. Semi-sheer to semi-opaque, glossy, without any shimmer. The most important thing, though, is that they don’t look thick and heavy on the lips. I like that super thin, high-shine and smoothing look.

  47. My lips are so full that I feel like a clown when I draw too much attention to them with color. I like a sheer lipstick, and my go-to is Clinique almost lipstick in Black Honey.

  48. Jan

    Slight gloss and/or slight shimmer.
    Mattes that don’t look dry also suit me well.

  49. artemis

    I like creamy and moisturizing ones

    • artemis

      oh and shimmer-less….the opacity can vary but the only sheer ones i’d like would be bright and dark ones…and the lighter the color, the more opaque it should be :)

  50. Matte finishes because it means that I don’t have to worry about it for most of the day, also they’re much more pigmented than a lot of other finishes. I hate the way glossier textures feel on my lips plus I feel they make my lips look bigger and more out there!

  51. Quinctia

    Is “somewhat translucent” a type of finish? My lips are really pigmented, and most brands’ opaque lipsticks end up looking patchy and weird, especially the creams. Urban Decay’s new formula and Lip Tars work fine at high opacity.

    Overall, though, I like lipsticks that are a little bit translucent best, with either that wet sort of shininess, or some shimmer to them. My favorite formulas are Milani Advance HD (I own all of them) and UD’s old formula, actually. And I nabbed a LOT of UD when they were in the process of changing their lipsticks.

  52. I like a good cream or satin formula… though I do I an unhealthy obsession with MAC’s frost finish… it feels so good on.

  53. berryduchess

    Of all, i love matte the most. It is very complimenting for me especially for the bold colors. :)

  54. Geneva


  55. For everyday wear, I prefer something sheer and glossy. If I’m feeling bold, I like opaque and matte.
    Amanda Recently Posted: Review: Revlon Nearly Naked Foundation

  56. I love cream and satin finish. If I want a shinier look I’d prefer to top it with a gloss. I stay far far away from metallic and frosted finishes.

  57. joyce

    Sheer to semi-sheer, preferably with a glossy finish – my lips are always dry! Matte, satin and even cream lip color ends up sinking in and making my lips look chapped.

  58. kastehelmi

    I love a satiny creamy finish that doesn’t have too much slip. And shimmery lipsticks that have no grit.
    Favorites are MAC Satin, MAC Cremesheen, Bobbi Brown Rich Lip Color, Shiseido Lip Perfection and Revlon Super Lustrous…

  59. kitkat989

    same here! Amplified is what i have most still on the hunt for that Gold lipstick too, shiny not glossy. Btw do you have that new YSL GOLD GLOSS VOLUPTE?

  60. Matte or satin finishes look best on me. I love them because they are so opaque and pigmented. I am not a fan of sheer or shimmer finishes. They all look the same to me. :-( I need vibrant, popping colors! 😀

  61. It has to be matte for me. They last longer and tend to fade more evenly plus I think they look good on my lips.

  62. I prefer matte and creamy finishes. Revlon matte and NYX are the best for me!

  63. I love love LOVE mattes. My lips are a little bit on the bigger side, and I love the way matte looks on my lips!

  64. Rosie in Brooklyn

    I am with you on this one Chris I love Shimmer Lipsticks because I love sparkly things of course. Matte aint my style at all.sorry matte girls this is a shimmer fiend.

  65. Rosana Sayuri

    I have very dry lips so I love the mac luster finish “hug me” lipstick but it has lanolin in its ingredient list so I found the perfect “lanolin-free” dupe: Revlon ColorBurst “blush” lipstick. The colour is so beautiful but the Revlon lipstick isn’t as moisturizing as the mac one. To sum up, I love sheer, translucid and also slightly glossy.

  66. Rebecca R.

    I love anything that is nourishing to my lips…and I think my favorite is creamy with a hint of glossy or sparkly.

  67. I prefer creamy, matte but not drying lipsticks, and maybe a little bit of a glossy finish. I can’t stand shimmery\frosty lipsticks on myself, so basically anything but that. c:

  68. Definetely MATTES.
    I found true LOVE in Retro Matte finish by MAC. My absolute favorite of all times.

  69. Matte or semi-matte, then cream, then satin. Anything glossy looks awful on me because I have oily skin, and shimmers & frosts look bad because … I don’t know. They just do.

    It’s interesting how many people also said they like mattes or matte-ish. I have a theory that sparkly color cosmetics sell well because they look so pretty in the pan, but people don’t wear them.

  70. I like it all, except shimmers that leave little glitter pieces on my lips and I am distrustful of stains. What limits me is moisture. I have very dry lips and they can crisp within a few hours. Trying my first Burberry because of your recs, and a Rouge G is next. :) I would rather have a 5 lippies that I love as opposed to a drawer full.

  71. Creamy, Luminous and shimmer.

    Frost, glitter and mattes just does not look flattering on me.