Wednesday, November 26th, 2008

Temptalia Asks You

What was your favorite Fall collection? We’re fully in the swing of winter launches now, so I think it’s safe to pick a favorite from fall!

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

29 thoughts on “Temptalia Asks You – What was your favorite Fall collection?

  1. Laura

    MAC’s Cult of Cherry.

  2. paola

    yeah i like cult of cherry…i bought all of the palettes…that’s bad lol

  3. Valentina

    Dior and Bobbi Brown! I bought Dior’s quint earth tones, creme de gloss Creamy burgundy, Dior’s eyeshadow duo Silver look and Bobbi Brown’s Mauve palette

  4. Sandy

    Cult of Cherry without any doubt. I’m still rocking the lipsticks!

  5. GRACE


  6. yeah…one more vote for cult of cherry…every quad had one shade that was moneymaker….SMART MAC!!!

  7. DevilishDoll

    I didn’t get much from Cult of Cherry, I really liked Suite Array though, such pretty eyeliners and the Blue Zone duo is nice too. Everybody else said the duos were bad, but they show up great for me.

  8. kacie

    cult of cherry for sure… I fell in love with those mattenes.

  9. KyaLyn

    Cult of Cherry! I bought way too much of that collection, but I’m still loving all of it.

  10. cloudburst

    Cult of Cherry, I honestly almost bought everything from that collection!

  11. Carrie

    ha, I’m probably going with really unpopular choices, early and late in the season…Electroflash and Metal Urge. For some reason I am just having the most fun with the products from those two.

    • Anitacska

      I didn’t buy any of the Metal Urge collection, but bought all 9 of the Mineralize shadow duos. :) Still haven’t used them all yet though, some colours are not that wearable imo.

  12. ShugAvery

    My vote cult of cherry for sure..

  13. Bobbi Brown … Shimmering Nudes was perfect too !

  14. Opi’s fall France collection!

    • Lingping

      oh yes, I’m with you on that one! I still love You don’t know Jaques and Parlez vous Opi to bits, and wear them way more frequently than any other shade I own.

  15. B

    what? no red she said?

  16. Tekoa

    Cult of Cherry. The CoC lipgloss is killer. I also enjoyed the Red She Said eyeshadow pallets.

  17. Virginia

    Bobbi Brown Mauve and Shimmering Nudes. The palettes are so awesome, I use them almost every day. They’re simple and pretty and they just work!

  18. Chica

    I loved the eyeshadow quad I got from Cult of Cherry and the Warm palette from Red she Said but my favourite Autumn/Winter collection isn’t a MAC one – Urban Decay have released some killers this year :) The Book of Shadows and their gorgeously packaged lipsticks are my favourite!

  19. Macaddict

    CoC! Also, to a lesser extent, Red She Said (I love red).

  20. Dawn

    I can’t remember if this is summer or fall but I love the starflash collection-eyeshadows and the liners. I bought almost everything from that collection. SO BAD!
    UD Book of shadows is a close second :)

  21. Ruth

    Guerlain was my favorite fall collection.

  22. Rebecca

    MAC’s Cult of Cherry! Like nothing else in color-story and marketing. The rest of the recent MAC collections feel ‘pushed out’ without being thought about.

  23. Bianca

    Cult of Cherry for sure, I bought every quad. Also Starflash was quite nice. I also loved the eyeliner from the Sweet Array Collection.

  24. Kayte

    I’m going to join the masses in, to be honest, cult of Cherry, I was skeptical at first and didn’t think I’d find a lot of it wearable and while true for the matenes (i’m just a wimp who is scared to rock a dark lip) I LOVED The lipsticks I got (So Scarlet, and Lightly Ripe (love love love true love) and Blooming blush, and Shadowy Lady Quad, and Tempting Quad, (I purchased but could live without spiced chocolate, its … Okay but wasn’t PERFECT for me lol :) )

    I really didn’t check out other brands than MAC this year though, they kind of ate up my entire Makeup Budget (and then some…. luckily for me I decided to diet and therefor all my former dining out money went towards makeup this fall! )