Monday, January 24th, 2011

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil

NARS Spring 2011: Celebrate

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil ($24.00 for 0.14 oz.) is described as a “parrot green” by NARS. The Soft Touch Shadow Pencils are supposed to be “smooth, creamy, and long-wearing.” They are touted as the “ideal base for layering with powder eyeshadow to increase color intensity.” It’s a multi-tasking pencil that can be used to “Shade the lid, line, or highlight the eye.”

Celebrate is a bright, chartreuse green with a strong yellow base. It applied semi-opaque but glided on easily. The problem with this shade was its complete inability to not crease. I tried it alone, and it creased within minutes. I layered eyeshadow on top (Giorgio Armani Transluminence palette–the teal–I just used whatever I had nearest to me), and it still creased in less than an hour. It’s not even a little creasing–it’s painful to see. Not to be daunted, I also tried it over NARS’ Smudgeproof Eyeshadow Base with the same eyeshadow layered on top, and I still had the same results (a veritable creasing bonanza).

my thoughts on the formula: More often than not, the Soft Touch Shadow Pencils are a bust for me–they crease alone but also when layered with powder–and Celebrate continues to show that NARS’ Soft Touch Shadow Pencils really can be hit or miss.

The Glossover

P
product

Celebrate

I'm not even sure what you can really use this with or for, if it's going to crease with two additional helpers (a base and shadow to set). It migrates on the lower lash line, too, so it's not something one could line with, either. Five points for the glide and color pay off!
Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil

NARS CelebrateSoft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil, after 15 minutes

NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil
NARS Celebrate layered over NARS’ Smudgeproof Eyeshadow Base + teal eyeshadow on top, after 1 hour

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase Celebrate? How much is it?

NARS, $24.00.

Is it limited edition?

No.

Any dupes?

NYX's Lime is the closest pencil shadow I can think of, but a better color dupe is MAC True Chartreuse Pigment.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

148 thoughts on “NARS Celebrate Soft Touch Shadow Pencil Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. Jessi

    Wow… what a disappointment. I don’t understand how a brand known for such high quality products could put something like this out. Seriously… why would they do it?

  2. NEKTARIA

    oh dear, i think this is the worst eyeshadow I have ever seen!

  3. Naz

    Yikes.
    I’m feeling like these soft touch pencils are not worth the $. I won the Palladium pencil from the fall collection and felt the same way; it’s just not pro-long wearing and/or really wearable. You could put this is in your Halloween reserve…it would make for a lovely sugar skull look.

    • Rayna

      I had the same issue with Palladium. Even used as a liner and set with another shadow it ends up everywhere.

  4. Nicky

    Bummer, I was really looking forward to this one. Thanks for the review, Christine (and for saving me $$)!

  5. Wow, that’s pretty bad. The color isn’t something I’d pick up anyway, but I know to stay away from the product all together. That’s disappointing.

  6. Rebekah

    Oh my gosh, that’s terrible! I’m definitely passing on this (even though I do love me some chartreuse)

  7. Gina

    Wow, how horrible. At least the NYX pencils work out when you set them, and they’re less than $4!

  8. Such a shame, it’s an awesome color, too.

  9. Samantha

    I can’t help but think of someone using a yellow highlighter for eyeshadow when I see the swatch on your eyes.

  10. Aurkeed

    what a shame! They look good just to see as a pencil not the product :(

  11. kristy

    wow, a single digit product rating. the color reminds me of shrek anyway!

  12. Rebecca

    Fifteen minutes? And that? Wow! I can’t believe it.

  13. Becca

    NYX makes the same greasy pencil for $3.

  14. Lauren

    It kind of makes you wonder if he even bothers testing his products before they ship out? If I were Nars, I’d be embarassed, to say the least.

  15. Danielle

    lol, that creasing is HORRIBLE.

    wow, and i almost bought this!

  16. Alyssa

    When I saw the 5/30… I thought, “I know it sounds bad, but it can’t be that bad.” But, seeing the pics… it is even worse! Now, I know you were actually being kind.

    Sad, since it’s such an awesome color.

  17. I was really looking forward to this pencil… but now? :/

  18. Vanessa S

    This looks gross and for $24.00 they should be ashamed!

  19. Annika

    I don’t know why, but I get all excited when I see an F product… haha. I like to see the extreme of good and the extreme of bad I guess!

  20. Leea

    Hahahah the picture after 15 minutes made me laugh.

  21. Sarz

    OH snap. I’ve never seen an F rating before.

    stupid NARS. >:(

  22. Ashley

    That’s too bad since that shade of green is gorgeous! Sigh…

  23. divinem (Melissa)

    That is a hot mess! I’d be embarrassed to release such an ineffective product with the NARS name attached. What were they thinking?!

  24. Carrie Ann

    Oh, my goodness. That would be a total waste of money. You really expect more from a brand like NARS.

  25. Nora

    Oh, how awful! The color is incredible, too. :(

  26. Mec

    Creasing is bad :( Well, hopefully they will work in the formula; the color looks amazing in the pencil.

  27. Ayesha

    Thats a shame :( Although I am SOOO looking forward to your review on Calanque! The trio :D.

  28. Girl

    Thanks for that I was about to get it!

  29. Sass

    This is just horrible. Goes to show that even the higher end brands can make a mess sometimes too.

  30. kfm

    EW!! Thanks for the warning!! I’m sad, because I thought this would be a great, vibrant summer colour, but product tends to crease on my lids as a rule, so I can’t imagine what this would look like after a few hours’ wear, let alone an entire hot day’s!

  31. Kayla

    Bummer…the color is gorgeous. Shame shame, NARS! Do they make a similar shade in shadow formula?

  32. Natalie

    Wow! I was hoping so much for this to be fabulous too. So disappointed!!

  33. Kayla

    Sorrrry! Nevermind, just saw your dupe list. I’ll check out the MAC pigment. *facepalm* I’m so ditzy today.

  34. such a shame! cant believe Nars is producing this stuff for the make up world with that kind of quality..was looking forward to this bright green color for spring but sadly and gladly wont be buying this!

  35. AS

    I know how it can be used. Fake mucus/slime/snot drips under the nose for Halloween or Zombie walk. Or it could be melted into paraffin to create a chartreuse candle. Waste not want not…

  36. Verna

    Wow. That’s really bad! I’ve never seen anything like this.

  37. Marsha

    Wow, that is really bad. Makes be think of how awful the Covergirl Smoky Shadow Blast was on me. Of course the Covergirl is only like $5, I’d expect a lot more for $24, especially from Nars

  38. Maeve

    Wow! That crease is one of the worst I’ve ever seen! I’m disappointed in Nars.

  39. Ouch. An F rating? From a company like NARS? I hope the rest of their products don’t go downhill!

  40. That is aweful! Thanks for the heads up!

  41. I don’t know if you could possibly answer this but, what do you thin it is about the formula that makes this pencil so bad in application? It’s weird how the swatch looks so good but the actual application didn’t go well. And I’m also wondering if one of MAC’s Paints (from cream to powder) would do better as a base…

  42. Lauren

    I can not believe that a company like NARS would put out a product like this. NARS products are not cheap and when you buy NARS you expect a level of quality, and this is just unacceptable. Don’t they test their products before they put them out?

    Thank you temptalia for reviewing products and showing us all how some products aren’t winners, no matter what company it is. I don’t buy a makeup product without reading your review first. You’re honest, and I thank you for that.

  43. Wendy

    It’s too bad that it creases. That looks like an exact dupe for both Pharaoh paint pot and Colour Matters e/l.

  44. DonnaN

    wow, what a disappointment….guess that saves me $24.00!

    Thanks Christine!!

  45. Mamavalveeta03

    Sad to say, but this is just plain ugly. Francois Nars needs to realize that not EVERY color is meant to be a makeup color. What ever happened to using color to FLATTER and ENHANCE one’s features???

  46. Vijaya

    That little bit of shadow pencil under your lower lid: Did that migrate from your lower lashline? I ask because if it did, that’s impressively bad. Your lower lashline is totally clean.

  47. AnGeLwInGz

    Wow that sucks!

  48. ak

    Wow! I’ve never seen you give an F before Christine!

  49. Joan

    EWWWWWWWWW OH MY GOD.

  50. K7P*

    Awww what a disappointment this product wasn’t good! I saw the product and thought for sure it was something i must try, ughhh not anymore! LOL Thanks for saving me $24 Christine!! =)

  51. wow, that really is a disappointmen, because the colour looks really cool and original, plus you expect something from a brand like NARS.

  52. I think a lot of nars products are crappy. Love their complexion products but i’ve had some major issues with some of their eyeshadows and lipsticks. it used to be my favorite brand =(

    • Ria

      I completely agree. Their cream shadows are appalling (beautiful colours, but awful formulae). I get similar creasing with them as Christine did with this pencil.

  53. Gisele

    These NARS shadow pencils are just awful. I don’t understand how any brand, but especially NARS, can be so great with some products and so bad (F) with others. But this is why we count on you, Christine, to warn us. Thanks.

  54. WOW LOL This DOES indeed look terrible. As everyone knows, I am obsessed with NARS and have yet to try this product out. I will definitely have to check this out for myself, speak to some people and see what’s the deal with this one because I know sometimes NARS makes products that have to be used a certain but this one? I’m not so sure:( ~sP

    • Only one out of all the shades (probably 4 or 5 now) I’ve tried has been OK. Palladium is SO SO SO GORGEOUS OMG but it just doesn’t want to work.

    • Lucie

      Haha Brian I knew you’d piss yourself seeing an F rating for a NARS product…believe me I did too! But there seems to be a consensus among beauty bloggers that the soft pencils are crap. Sad because the colours are so purdy. :’(

  55. Jess A

    Christine that’s horrible!

    I hate to say it but that last picture made me think of the Creature From the Black Lagoon (and not by any fault of your own).

    What a disappointment!

  56. Katie

    Wow that is ridiculous. It looks like you just put some watercolor on your lid.

  57. Utter disappointment – I wonder how it would look on someone that has oily eyelids. Thanks Christine, once again you saved me some money that can now go to the D&G Spring line.

  58. Emily

    Too bad! Such a pretty color!

  59. Hannelore

    Thank you for posting those ‘fail’ pictures so we can see what the products does (or doesn’t lol) :) I would’ve thought Nars test their products extensively.. or they should include a manual ;)

  60. Laura

    Regardless the quality of the product, the color is fuggo! Who would want the color of jaundice next to their eyes??

  61. Ugh, that is some severe creasing!!
    What a disappoinment considering it’s a cool colour, and 24 dollars is quiet pricey!
    I feel bad for the ones who are gonna spend money on this and discover that it creases so badly >.<

  62. Marian

    Geez…NARS just can’t do creams, it seems.

  63. Christina

    you’re really the best shopping guide ever christine! thanks for your honest review <3

  64. Dawn

    Eek, that’s horrid!

    I thought cosmetic companies had people who tested stuff for ages before even considering putting it on sale? Obviously they missed this one!

  65. Ms. Jimmi

    I have been so disappointed by Nars in the past couple of years. Powdery shadow with weak pigment, Migrating eye pencils nad the Orgasm Blush seems to rub off after a while. Very disappointing.

  66. Melissa

    I was extremely disappointed in Palladium also. I will never buy another soft touch shadow from them.

  67. Heather

    Did they not test this?

  68. no tell me it’s not Nars! sadness!!! pretty color too :)

  69. Ashley D.

    Shame… it looked pretty too.

  70. lo

    Oh my gosh. The color is pretty (although it would look gross on me), but I literally gasped when I saw the photos on your lid. That much creasing is disgusting.

  71. Jay

    this actually worked really well for me, i have it in a light champagne kinda color and i loveee it!!! i wear it all the time!

  72. Claudia

    Lol omg don’t mean to laugh but the first picture just had me laughing. Man that really sucks that such great company like NARS has products like this. Thanks Christine for warning us ;)

  73. Rae

    AAHH! Now, that’s some truly frightening creasing. It’s too bad – the shade is actually really cute, at least in your skin swatch!

  74. I don’t understand how a company like Nars could put out a product like this. Don’t they do any kind of product testing at all?

  75. Erica

    Booo! Hiss! lol bummer that these suck so bad cuz the colors are so pretty! I guess you win some and you lose some.

  76. Tekoa

    *winces* No wonder it got an F. Thank you for protecting us from the horror that is Celebrate.

  77. Yikes! How disappointing! It’s a beautiful color, but that won’t cover up the fact that it’s the opposite of the name!

  78. anonymous

    Shame shame shame we NARS your name! OMG that is soo beyond bad. what exactly were they thinking?

    (umm 8/10 for VALUE??? Christine!) <:-O

  79. Nars makes some amazing colors but when they have formula mishaps they are HUGE, like their glitter shadows/blushes being a hot mess, and the shadow pencils. I’ve tested this with stay don’t stray and nars eye primer with the same results. :(

  80. Bernice

    oh wow > <

  81. Oh no! This looked so pretty, I’m so sorry to see that it’s such a fail!

  82. Yuck, what a creasing mess! Way to not deliver, NARS!

  83. Lorna

    as mush as i love NARS, i have never been impressed with his cream formulas or the soft touch shadow pencils.

  84. Vanessa

    Holy WOWZA…………….. What a fail of a product!!!!

  85. Jen

    Oh am I HAPPY to see this! I allllmost bought this and I couldn’t stop thinking about it and trying to decide whether or not to get it and I’m thrilled to just put it behind me now.

  86. Perri

    That is so disappointing :(

  87. Selenite

    Such bright, vivid color. Such a horrible, crease-prone and fadetastic formula. I have one of these in another color and am very dissapoint.

  88. Kristen

    Did you use an eye shadow primer with that? or just on bare skin?

  89. Yiiiikes. That’s too bad! The swatch was pretty, in any case! This exact thing happened to me with the Covergirl Shadow Blast! I still can’t figure that thing out!!

  90. Sylvia

    YIKES… NARS is better than that… They should fix these pencils!

  91. venice

    eeeek, that is bad!

  92. Boo!!! When I saw it I loved it, but wow, thank you for saving me money. :) That creasing sucks and is probably one of my biggest pet-pev.

  93. kiran

    Eww! I hate that. How can they ask for $24 for that stuff?

  94. anonymous

    liking awesome new collection preview banner!!!

  95. KRISTANNA

    wow they were really hyping this product in the beauty magazines too, thanks Christine for the straight story!