Thursday, May 16th, 2013

The Hit List

What’s the Most Consistently Good Drugstore Brand you’ve tried?

Share your pick!  And don’t forget to share why :)

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

82 thoughts on “Hit List: Most Consistently Good Drugstore Brand

  1. Avatar of Laurel Laurel

    I’m going to have to say Rimmel because every single product I’ve tried I’ve loved, and their new products lately have been the BOMB. They have a lot of my HG products (Lasting Finish foundation, Fix and Perfect pro primer, and the new scandal eyes eyeliners!!). Granted, I haven’t tried EVERY product they make, but of the ones I’ve tried (and I’ve tried a decent amount), there are none I’ve hated.

  2. Christina

    My experience has been that it depends on the product. For instance, I’ve found the most consistently good lip products from Revlon; the most consistently good eyeliner from Physicians Formula; the most consistently good cream eyeshadow from Maybelline (I’m looking at you, Color Tattoos!), the most consistently good blush from Milani.

  3. Avatar of Adena Adena

    does nyx count?

    If so, nyx :)

  4. Allison

    Easy – Revlon. Lipsticks and Lip Glosses that I keep going back to.

    • MakeupTray

      Yes, agreed. You never have to buy the high end glosses, lipsticks again.

    • Avatar of natalya natalya

      I probably have the most of out of this drugstore brand than any other… revlon

    • Revlon is the first brand that pop into my head too! Love all the lip products, they are all fantastic and I adore the packaging as well. Love the ColorBurst lip glosses, lipsticks, lip butter, and the super lustrous lipsticks and lip glosses, love them all! Never fail me! And their Just Bitten Lip Stain is like the best thing ever! Stays on like cray cray and hydrating!

  5. Avatar of Christine ChristineV

    Maybelline

  6. Georgie

    Revlon!

  7. zainab

    Rimmel. It’s the drugstore brand I’ve had the most experience with, and it’s the cheapest of the widel known drugstore brands. I love their mascaras, the Scandal-Eyes eyeliners are great (I think they’re basically Urban Decay 24/7s), they used to have a kohl liner I liked, so far I’m liking their matte liquid foundation and their lipsticks are okay for the price.
    I think that there are a lot of good products across a lot of drugstore brands, but eyeshadows are where they all fall a bit flat.

  8. Avatar of Christina Christina

    Maybelline is the most consistently good brand in my experience! Tons of formulas and options for all categories: foundations (FITme and Age Rewind are my top picks), mascaras (hello Mega Plush and Falsies), and lippies (from Vivid to Color Whisper to Baby Lips). They do trends but they have great mainstays and are on the lower price range compared to L’Oreal and Revlon. I am a fan!

    • Have you tried the Color Whispers vs. Revlon’s Lip Butters? I’ve been eyeing the two and trying to decide which would be best.

      • Gen

        I have about 3 lip butters and 1 color whisper but I do prefer the whispers. The formula is a little creamier but the rest is very comparable.

      • trishna

        i suggest go with color whispers. they’re lighter feeling and also more hydrating throughout the day… its almost a gel like formula lip butters on the other hand are slightly more pigmented and have a wider color range (whispers just look like a lighter or a dark shade of the same color at times) but they are a thicker consistency it would a personal preference as to what texture you prefer. I would recommend picking up one of each and trying it out (pink truffle in revlon and made it mauve in whispers both pink-y neutral everyday shades and are perfect firsts to try) :)

        • Avatar of Christina Christina

          I find Lip Butters are more pigmented and creamier and Color Whispers are more like intense tinted balms with more slip and shine. For me it’s just about the shade I want as I truly like both formulas equally. And I 2nd Trishna: Revlon Pink Truffle is a great MLBB color! And for me Rose of Attraction Color Whisper is its close sister (I am MAC C4/neutral light tan).

      • Strange, I would have said the opposite of the other comments. The Color Whispers have more of a traditional lipstick feel, and a cream finish, whereas the Lip Butters are more like a gloss in stick form–slippy, translucent though pigmented, and mostly high shine (though some of the shades do have a creamier consistency/finish). Lip Butters have a much better color selection, though. Color Whispers offer more coverage.

  9. I think NYX is pretty consistently good.

  10. L’oreal for eye products and Maybelline or Revlon for lip products. I’ve just found more success consistently when broken down in those categories.

  11. For me L’Oreal. I love the Infallible eyeshadows, the HIP eyeshadows are awesome. I also love covergirl mascaras and maybelline’s eyestudio eyeshadows.

  12. It’s a tie between Revlon and Maybelline for me, they’re both my favorites!

  13. Lenita

    Milani and CoverGirl

  14. Revlon, but I also really like Maybelline.

  15. Avatar of Cat Cat

    Hard to say, I don’t really equate drugstore brand with consistency! Maybe NYX?

  16. Basema

    Loreal: Superliner, Physicians formula: Eyeliner, Revlon: lipsticks (matt ones) and black pencil liner, Maybelline Mascaras are the best, NYX lipliners are as good as MAC :)

  17. Bourjois for me. And Maybelline is a favorite too.

  18. Erin

    Milani. From eyshadow, to primer, to nail polish. Everything I’ve tried, I’ve loved. They aren’t the easiest to find, but they are worth the trip!

    • Lark

      Ulta has all Milanis stuff. Their mascara was the best I’ve ever used! And the eye pencils are legend!

  19. Avatar of Lila Lila

    Milani. I adore everything of theirs. The lipstick is fantastic and the eyeshadow sticks are so creamy and pigmented. Hard to find but definitely worth it.

  20. Reesa

    i would definitely have to say maybelline, revlon, and loreal for mascaras/eye products.

  21. Avatar of Geneva Geneva

    Revlon and Cover Girl

  22. NYX. great pigments and long lasting! Especially their lip products! !

  23. Kristy

    L’Oreal for eye products, Revlon for lip products.

  24. Starfish

    Revlon has amazing face products, lip products, eye products, nail products. Everything is great. I really enjoy Rimmel’s products too.

  25. trishna

    i think for face, lips, and nails its Revlon also but for the eyes its a toss up between L’oreal and Covergirl I love the pigmentation on L’oreal shadows but Covergirl makes the best mascaras! the lashblast line is wonderful!

  26. Jen

    Revlon! I feel like I can find any Mac lipstick Dup in this brand. And I love their photoready foundation. Comes with the pump and all.

  27. Katie

    For lipsticks I gravitate towards Revlon, for nail polishes I go straight to Rimmel.

  28. Avatar of Amy xamyx

    L’Oreal; aside from the newly reconfigured eyeshadow quads, as well as some DC’d products (and a few new additions), their products have maintained the same integrity & quality for the past 25+ years I’ve been acquainted with the brand. It seems most of the “mainstream” DS brands have completely changed formulas, most of which were not for the better, in order to “keep up” with the gimmicks of HE brands.

    Revlon has also maintained that same integrity when it comes to most products, although the eye products are nowhere near the amazing formulas of 5-10 years ago. Again, I see this as the brand trying to “evolve”, although I’d much rather see them go back to what they were, before the gimmicky nonsense.

  29. Revlon, why… Great foundations. Cult lip products. And the unsung products such as their powders, mascaras and liners are better than some high end brands imo.

    Jules x

  30. NYX for me! I haven’t had an issue with a product I’ve bought and used! (My problems tend to be user-error though, haha) Admittedly, their Xtreme gloss smells funky but since they have Butter Gloss now, I don’t have to deal with a funky smell. :3

  31. Avatar of Xero Xero

    I’d have to say MIlani, and to some extent their sister company Jordana. I’m not aware of any products they have that are bad–even if Milani is on the pricier side of drugstore makeup. Jordana is nice and cheap, though.

  32. Yasmin

    SUPERDRUGS MUA

    Seriously one of the best cosmetic brands ive come across. the fact that every item is under ten pounds, means i can splurge without any guilt. My fave items from them have to be, the face powder, 3 in 1 counter liner, eyeshadows in 19 & 16, the eyeshadow primer, 2 brushes that are dupes for mac the mac brushes 188 and 224, Lipsticks, lipgloss.

  33. Elle

    NYX and/or Bourjois… I live in Japan, so those are considered drugstore products here. :)

  34. For me it’s a tie between Rimmel and Milani. Rimmel is all around great but they have some of the best lipstick and I’m loving the new Milani shadow sticks and primer!

    NYX is a runner up but I’ve been slightly disappointed in some of their new products and the new palettes I purchased/swatched weren’t as good as their old ones.

    • I think ALL the newer palettes by NYX are bad! Their Glam Eyeshadows are really dry and gritty too, the new palettes are dry as well and can lack in pigment. I haven’t bought a single one because of those issues; I had hopes for the Smokey palette being a close dupe for Urban Decay’s Smoked palette but was disappointed by the lack of pigment. It seems just their new eyeshadows and palettes are bad, because the setting sprays have been reviewed to be pretty good.

      • Stacey

        Thank goodnessssss….someone doesnt like NYX. I can nyx Nyx.

      • Karen

        I find NYX to be way overhyped. I bought two of their eyeshadow palettes recently and they were so bad I returned them. The colors weren’t pretty and had very little pigment. Blah.

  35. Avatar of Meiya Meiya

    Revlon for lipsticks and foundations. L’Oreal for mascaras and foundations.

  36. I would go with L’Oreal and Revlon.

  37. Krystina

    I really love Almay products, specifically their foundation (TLC and Clear Complexion). I haven’t strayed because I love that it’s full-coverage and matte.

    I wouldn’t say it’s my favorite, but I’ve been very pleasantly surprised by Wet n Wild’s eyeshadow. I have a couple trios and they’re really great – pigmented, nice colors, and they stay on all day with a little primer.

  38. Maybelline Tattoo cream eyeshadows and mascaras.
    Loreal HIP/Studio Secrets power eyeshadow duos.
    Olay and Neutrogena SPF face lotions.

  39. This is a tough one, especially since I don’t even find any high end brands “consistently good”. But I think Maybelline and L’Oreal have really stepped up their game in some ways. Here in Canada, we have a fortunate “out” because Lise Watier is sold in drugstores almost exclusively, so I guess I could say “Lise Watier” (or maybe NYX….or Physician’s Formula….see, this is really difficult!)

  40. Avatar of Susan Susan Nevling

    L oreal mascara- non waterproof. I like a lot of their brand too for eyes and lips. Used to use the colormatch (?) Foundations but not for years now.

  41. Avatar of Vanessa Vanessa

    Revlon (/and Nyx if that counts).

  42. Revlon has awesome lip products and Maybelline is my go-to for mascara, especially the Colossal. I’ve also been trying more products from Walmart’s Hard Candy and it’s really been great! Fun packaging and it’s really good quality product for the price.

    • Hard Candy isn’t *owned* by WalMart, just *exclusively sold* at WalMart. It was initially an underling of Urban Decay and may still be owned by them, not sure.

  43. Avatar of Marian Marian Humin

    I say Revlon. They’ve had good products for many years.

  44. Dianna

    I personally love Maybelline for mascara (love Falsies and megaplush), Revlon for lipsticks/lip butters (just tried color stay lip suede and am in love!), Nyx for their jumbo pencils–so versatile alone or as a primer (lip and eye) and their lipliners.

    I like Covergirl’s line architect retractable eyeliner a for a good on the go inexpensive liner. Though my personally fave eye pencils to use in general are Urban Decay’s 24/7 eye pencil and Rimmel’s eyeliners (love using the pencil for a quick and easy smokey eye–because they are so soft)

  45. Avatar of Phoebe Phoebe

    I have more favorites on my counter from Maybelline than anyone else!

  46. Hm. Maybe Milani or Prestige. FLOWER if that counts

  47. Avatar of Pamela Pamela

    L’Oreal and NYX.

  48. Drugstore brands have really stepped up their game in the past year or so. Aside from Asian drugstore brands like Majolica Majorca or Canmake, I’d have to say that Milani and Revlon has been my favorite for the products. For affordability, though, Essence is amazingly good for what you pay for.

  49. If it counts, NYX all the way.
    If we’re going for products that are actually sold in drugstores, I generally don’t find drugstore brands to be very consistent, but if I had to choose:
    L’Oreal
    They have many products that are outstanding (Infallible Eyeshadows, Colour Riche and Colour Caresse Lipsticks, Volumnious Mascara, Lineur Intense), and I’ve never gotten a really terrible product from them. Also, props to the only drugstore brand who decided we might like to know the undertone of our foundation BEFORE we buy it.

  50. Avatar of Gabi Gab

    Maybelline for eyes and Revlon for face and lips. :)

  51. None of them in my experience. There’s a few good products here and there, but none in my have a line that I think is top to bottom good quality. Where they fall short for me is foundation, concealer and eyeshadow, and blush.

  52. I haven’t tried enough of their stuff, but Sleek seems to constantly get it right for me.

  53. Avatar of Leticia Leticia

    I’d say Revlon – the quality and color range of their lipsticks and glosses is great and I also love their nail polishes. I liked their Custom Eyes eyeshadow palettes too. I’ve tried other products like eyebrow pencils and some foundations, but I think their stellar products are for lips and nails. I also like that every once in a while they throw in a “collection” product, like small lipglosses palettes or “nail stencils” that are simply fun!

  54. Rebecca

    Revlon, easy!

  55. Avatar of Amanda amanda

    Maybelline. I love their Color Whispers, 14 hour lipsticks, Vivids, Fit Me powder, etc. Several of their mascaras are also really good. Overall I think they consistently turn out great products.

  56. I feel like Maybelline has most often made me happy

  57. Avatar of Ajeng Ghina Ghina

    Maybelline & Revlon. I cannot choose between two of them. Maybelline has great mascaras & I love the gel eye liner. One thing that you cannot miss about Maybellie : The color tattoos.
    For revlon, I really like the lip products , foundations, & nail polish. The nail polish come in a huge bottle but just cost me about $3.

  58. kari

    definitely rimmel!

  59. Avatar of Haleemah Haleemah

    Revlon! I love their foundation, lipstick, everything!

  60. Isobel

    Revlon, Maybelline and L’oreal are all great brands

  61. I never thought of Nyx as a drugstore product since I can only ever find it in person at Ulta, but I would say that it is probably my favorite, especially their eye products! I have probably fifteen or more of their liners, a bunch of jumbo eye pencils, I think nine of the pigments in the little round canisters and five of the liquid crystal eyeliners.

    Still, I do like Maybelline for lipsticks!

  62. lilith

    Aveeno, L’oreal

  63. Definitely Wet n Wild for their eye shadows (has anyone mentioned them?)
    Revlon for their foundation and lipstick.

  64. I wasn’t able to narrow it down to one, but two: L’Oreal and Maybelline. Between the two, you could get everything you need, unless you’re a makeup addict like myself.