Written Reviews

Stila's black liner is absolutely perfect. So I regret to say that if you're looking for a brown one that performs the same.... this is not that product. It bears absolutely no resemblance to the black liner in performance, vibrancy, staying power, or product longevity. When I opened it, I was a little surprised at how "light" the brown is - it's not really brown black, it's really a medium-toned lighter brown color. The line isn't very opaque when you draw with it, which is a huge issue. It also quickly fades even more on my eyes through the day. I used this pen until it was totally gone and it just got more and more faded. Just not a very good product, which is a shame since the black one nails it.