Skip to content

Reviews

Reviews
All Products
Find a Review
Browse by Type
Browse by Brand
Popular Products

The Dupe List
Find Product Dupes
Compare Any Two Palettes
Submit a Dupe

Foundation
Matrix

Foundation Matching
Foundation Matrix
Use Existing Shade
Start from Scratch

Browse Swatches
The Swatch Gallery
By Product
By Color or Type
Compare Any Two

More Sections Below
Blog
Full Blog
Deals
Launches
Editorials
Makeup Tips
Makeup Storage
Sneak Peeks
Weekly Features
Posts by Brand
Recommendations
Best of Lists
Editor's Favorites
Round-ups
Inspiration & Looks
Editor's Color Stories
Editor's Looks
Look Ideas
Color Stories
All Looks
Create a Color Story

Sign Up
Login

Blog
- Deals & Sales
- Launches
- Reviews
- Sneak Peeks
- Weekly Features
- Looks
- Editorials
- More Posts
Deals & Sales

ColourPop — 10% off (a few exclusions apply) w/code TEMPTALIA
Cover FX — 15% off your first purchase

More Deals

Launches

Holiday 2023
Fall 2023
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007

Reviews

Browse By Type

Browse By Rating

Know what you're looking for?

Sneak Peeks

ColourPop Cloud 9 Palette Swatches

Holiday 2023 Palette Swatches (Guerlain, Tom Ford, Natasha Denona)

Pat McGrath Bijoux Brilliance Cheek Trios Swatches

Chanel Holiday 2023 Color Collection Swatches

View More

Weekly Features

Best of Product Lists

Community Favorites

Free For Haul Friday

Hit List

Makeup Look Ideas

Polls

Rant & Rave

Round-Ups

Survey Says

Temptalia Asks You

Week in Review

Most Recent Looks

Olivia Palermo Eyeshadow Look

A Pink & Plum Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia

Pat McGrath Colorful + Sparkly Eye Look

A Tropical Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia

View All Looks

View Looks from 2014 & Earlier

Editorials

ColourPop x Harry Potter Collection... Yer a Disappointment, ColourPop

$A look into Bite Beauty\'s rebrand - is anything going right?$
A look into Bite Beauty's rebrand - is anything going right?

Curate a Makeup Collection You Love with More Mindfulness (2022 Guide)

How-to Buy Less Makeup: Guide to Makeup No-Buys & Low-Buys (2022)

View More

More Posts

Makeup Tips

Contests

Looks

Makeup Storage

Tutorials

Brands
Swatches

The Swatch Gallery™
By Product By Color or Type Compare Any Two
Browse all swatches.

Featured Swatches

Divine Glow
Lightwork Eyeshadow
Illuminating Powder Duo
Eyephoria Cream Eyeshadow
Dupes

The Dupe List™

Find Product Dupes

Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice.

Compare any Two Palettes

Look to see if any shades between two palettes are known dupes.

Submit a Dupe

Popular Products
Foundation Matrix

Use Existing Shade

Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer!
Get Matched Now

Start From Scratch

Are you new to the world of foundation or have you never felt like you've found an ideal shade match? Not to worry -- we can still help!
Find your Shade
Favorites

Editor's Favorites

Readers often ask me what are my absolute, all-time favorites, and now you can find my current and long-time favorites all in one place!
View Favorites
Reviews

Makeup & Beauty Product Reviews Products
Find a Review Browse by Type Browse by Brand

Know what you're looking for?

Or view popular products
Color Stories

Makeup Looks & Inspiration
By Product or Formula By Color or Type Editor's Color Stories
Build your own palette, create a color combination, or discover look ideas to try.
Create a Color Story
Login — Register

Recent Color Story

Fairykin
Pixie Perf
Shapeshifter
Into the Forest

View Color Story
Looks

Makeup & Beauty Looks
Editor's Looks Recent Looks

Most Recent Looks

Love is in the Air

Baby’s First Pml Look

Spring Coral

Spring Has Sprung

Ulta Mesmerize Dupes

Here are our dupes for Ulta Mesmerize, which is an eyeshadow.

Product Details

= Verified

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Ulta Mesmerize Eyeshadow

-

%%COMMA%% Unknown

Review

Affiliate Links

Ulta

Ulta Mesmerize Eyeshadow

Mesmerize Ulta

Unknown

Affiliate Links

Ulta

MAC Club Eyeshadow

Club MAC

Permanent

Affiliate Links

Bloomingdale's Dillard's MAC Cosmetics Macy's Nordstrom

Saks Selfridges (US)Ulta

Int'l Retailers

Harrods John Lewis (UK)LookFantastic MAC (CA)MAC (UK)Selfridges Sephora (BR)

$17.00

95%

Similar

$17.00

More

Club is... less shimmery (1)

View Detailed Comparison

MAC Club Eyeshadow

95%

$17.00, Permanent

Less shimmery (1)

Full Comparison

-

Review

Affiliate Links

Bloomingdale's Dillard's MAC Cosmetics Macy's Nordstrom

Saks Selfridges (US)Ulta

Int'l Retailers

Harrods John Lewis (UK)LookFantastic MAC (CA)MAC (UK)Selfridges Sephora (BR)

Have Both Already? Rate This Dupe

Refine Results

Find a Dupe

Refine Results

Blush+

AllCreamGelLiquidLoosePressed PowderStain

Bronzer+

AllCreamLiquidLoosePowder

Contour+

AllCreamPowder

Eyeliner+

AllCreamDual-EndedFelt-TipGelGlitterLiquidPencilPowder

Eyeshadow+

AllBakedCreamGlitterLiquidLoosePencilPigmentPressed Powder

Glitter+

AllCreamLiquidLoosePressed

Highlighter+

AllCreamLiquidLoosePowder

Lip Balm+

AllExfoliatorTintedwith SPF

Lip Liner+

AllGelLiquidPencil

Lip PlumperLip Stain+

AllLipglossLipstickPencilPot

Lipgloss+

AllPencilPlumping

Lipstick+

AllLiquidPencil

Nail Color

Filter Brand

Permanent Permanent in Palette Discontinued Limited Edition

$ - $

Find Dupes By Product

Follow Us

View Temptalia's Facebook Account View Temptalia's Twitter Account View Temptalia's Pinterest Account View Temptalia's Instagram Account View Temptalia on Bloglovin'

Compare Any Two

Foundation Matrix™

Need help finding your perfect foundation shade? The Foundation Matrix is designed to help.

The Dupe List™

Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice. The Dupe List is here to help.

Swatch Gallery™

Looking for the perfect color?
Look no further than Temptalia's Swatch Gallery.

Get the latest reviews & beauty news!

Subscribe

View Temptalia's Facebook Account View Temptalia's Twitter Account View Temptalia's Pinterest Account View Temptalia's Instagram Account View Temptalia on Bloglovin'

About Contact Policies Review FAQ Privacy Policy Terms Accessibility

Temptalia Network: Try Hard Guides Video Gaming Goodest Pups

© 2006 - 2025 Temptalia®

(title)

(body)

This action cannot be undone.

Rate This Dupe

Original Product:

Dupe:

How similar is the DUPE to the Original Product?

80%85%90%95%100%

How does the DUPE differ from the Original Product?

More shimmeryLess shimmery

LighterDarker

BrighterMore muted

Less pigmentedMore pigmented

CoolerWarmer

Better qualityLower quality

GlossierLess glossy

Clear Selections