We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • BeautylishUp to 50% off select products (list here), like 20% off select Anastasia Palettes, 20% off most Natasha Denona, 30% off most Jouer, ends 8/19.
  • DermStoreUp to 25% off with code CELEBRATE (list of eligible brands/products here), ends 8/25.
  • SaksGet up to $200 off your beauty or fragrance purchase with code BEAUTY1SF, ends 8/19.
  • Sephora20% off for Rouges (early access on 8/19!) & 15% off for VIBs (starts 8/20) w/code SUMMERSAVE, starts 8/19 and ends 8/27.
  • Ulta$10 off $40 qualifying purchase (excluded brands here) with code 790210, ends 8/18.

MAC Which Witch vs. Makeup Geek Shady Comparison

Editor's Comparison

85%

Similar

$4.50

Savings

MAC Which Witch is a warm purple with a natural finish that is limited edition and retails for $19.50. In comparison, Makeup Geek Shady is a warm purple with a glossy finish that is permanent and retails for $15.00.

Makeup Geek Shady is 85% similar — it is darker, brighter, more pigmented.

How similar is Shady to Which Witch?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

More Dupes for Which Witch

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

Find Dupes of a Product