Makeup Geek Poppy vs. Make Up For Ever #5 Comparison

Editor's Comparison

Makeup Geek Poppy is a warm orange with a semi-matte finish that is discontinued and retails for $6.00. In comparison, Make Up For Ever #5 is a warm orange with a matte finish that is discontinued and retails for $20.00.

Make Up For Ever #5 is 90% similar — it is darker.

Community Comparison

Your Vote — 85%

• #5 is Darker (1)
• #5 is Brighter (1)
• #5 is More pigmented (1)
• #5 is Better quality (1)