MAC MamaStarrr vs. Too Faced Papa Don't Peach Comparison

Editor's Comparison

MAC MamaStarrr is a warm brown with a cream finish that is limited edition and retails for $21.00. In comparison, Too Faced Papa Don't Peach is a warm brown with a cream finish that is permanent and retails for $19.00.

Too Faced Papa Don't Peach is 95% similar — it is warmer.

Community Comparison

Your Vote — 85%

• Papa Don't Peach is Lighter (2)
• Papa Don't Peach is Warmer (1)
• Papa Don't Peach is Less glossy (1)