I tried to “dupe the vibes” using Anastasia singles and popular palettes (newish and/or permanent), as I felt like this is a brand that a decent number of readers have products from.  ColourPop was next, and I primarily went for singles as much as possible (though goodness knows what is available at this second and what will be available in five minutes!).  I pulled from Sydney Grace, which has more affordable singles in a plethora of shades, but their Autumn’s Reign palette is one of the closer “all in one” offerings (richer, but deeper, jewel-tones).

I also thought pulling from Natasha Denona’s eyeshadow catalog would work given the brand’s have a similar price point that I feel like there must be a decent overlap of buyers between the two brands.

For fun, I also pulled together closest shades within Pat McGrath’s own past releases along with pulling in exact shade matches where available (e.g. available as a single or in a still-available palette). This is for those who already have some of the brand’s past releases, so it might give you an idea of where there’s overlap within your stash already and then you can augment shades you need using other products you own!

What shades are MOST dupable?  Gold Standard (very warm, medium gold), Blue Blood (pearly, darker plum), Sterling (bright silver), Hedonistic (warm red, subtle duochrome).

What shades were least dupable?  Inferno (rosy brown), Sinful (deeper, pewter gold), Lapis Luxury (bright, deeper bluish-teal).

Pat McGrath Decadence Palette

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Gold Standard

Inferno

Blue Blood

Sinful

Underworld

Sterling

Lapis Luxury

Divine Mink

Hedonistic

Enigma

View Larger Photos

Decadence Vibes 1.0

Anastasia Eyeshadows

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Bronze

Cinder

Rosette

Tiger's Eye

Star Cobalt

Mermaid

Cyborg

Denim Smokey

Wiggalese

Brownie

8

Save

Click on the links below to view more possibilities as well as to compare the Pat McGrath Decadence shade to all possibilities (including the one listed in the actual color story).

• Gold Standard -> Compare All
• Inferno -> B2 (Norvina Vol. 1), Streak (Sunset quad) (Compare All)
• Blue Blood -> Drama (Norvina) (Compare All)
• Sinful -> Dwollahs (Jackie Aina), Metallic (single), Ember (Sultry) (Compare All)
• Underworld -> Compare All
• Sterling -> Compare All
• Lapis Luxury -> Compare All
• Divine Mink -> Jode (Carli Bybel) (Compare All)
• Hedonistic -> C3 (Norvina Vol. 1), Aura (Carli Bybel) (Compare All)
• Enigma -> Topaz (single), Teak (Sultry) (Compare All)

Decadence Vibes 2.0

ColourPop Eyeshadows

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Rascal

West Star

Hung Up

The Gemini

Quantum Sleep

On a Whimsy

Backseat

Goody Two-Shoes

Thank U, Next

Boxer

11

Save

Click on the links below to view more possibilities as well as to compare the Pat McGrath Decadence shade to all possibilities (including the one listed in the actual color story).

• Gold Standard -> ColourPop Comparisons (12)
• Inferno -> ColourPop Comparisons (9)
• Blue Blood -> ColourPop Comparisons (6)
• Sinful -> ColourPop Comparisons (7)
• Underworld -> ColourPop Comparisons (4)
• Sterling -> ColourPop Comparisons (8)
• Lapis Luxury -> ColourPop Comparisons (6)
• Divine Mink -> ColourPop Comparisons (4)
• Hedonistic -> ColourPop Comparisons (11)
• Enigma -> ColourPop Comparisons (11)

Decadence Vibes 3.0

Sydney Grace Eyeshadows

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Deep Desire

Peace

Awakening

Vanilla Bean

Moonlit Kingdom

Jingle Bells

Splendor

Black Ice

Blaze

Midnight Gold

13

Save

Click on the links below to view more possibilities as well as to compare the Pat McGrath Decadence shade to all possibilities (including the one listed in the actual color story).

• Gold Standard -> Hercules (discontinued), Golden Scepter (Autumn’s Reign), Fool’s Gold, Aztec Ruins (Compare All)
• Blue Blood -> Go For It, Dream Big (Raspberry Kiss), Be Kind (Raspberry Kiss) (Compare All)
• Sinful -> Be the Sunshine (Mountain Trail), Light My World (Mountain Trail), Recruit, Commission (Compare All)
• Underworld -> Abyss, Deep Water, Rendezvous (Compare All)
• Sterling -> Compare All
• Lapis Luxury -> Abyss (Compare All)
• Divine Mink -> Slayed (Compare All)
• Hedonistic -> Ladylike, Delightful Spark, Princess Pay Pay, Amber Jewels (Autumn’s Reign) (Compare All)
• Enigma -> Sydney Grace Options (8) (Compare All)

Decadence Vibes 4.0

Natasha Denona Eyeshadows

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Gold (137CP)

Lavender Gray (40M)

Maroon (22M)

True Gold (20M) (2019)

Blue Spruce (02M)

Chromatic (04M)

Aqueous (261M)

Anthrazit (06P)

Purpure (147M)

Ochre (61P)

9

Save

Click on the links below to view more possibilities as well as to compare the Pat McGrath Decadence shade to all possibilities (including the one listed in the actual color story).

• Gold Standard -> Compare All
• Inferno -> Compare All
• Blue Blood -> Compare All
• Sinful -> Compare All
• Underworld -> Compare All
• Sterling -> Compare All
• Lapis Luxury -> Compare All
• Divine Mink -> Compare All
• Hedonistic -> Compare All
• Enigma -> Compare All

Mirrored Decadence

Pat McGrath Eyeshadows

Gallery Options

Products

Swatches

Gold Standard

Le Sin

Amnesia

Sinful

Blitz Blue

Astral Luna Gold

Lapis Luxury

Divine Mink

Crimson Fire

Sable Bronze

8

Save

Click on the links below to view more possibilities as well as to compare the Pat McGrath Decadence shade to all possibilities (including the one listed in the actual color story).  Obviously, when the exact shade from the palette is available as a single or in a currently-available palette, I pulled the exact shade but below you’ll find a larger grouping of similar shades!

When you seen an asterisk (*), it means that there were no truly similar shades.

• Gold Standard Comparisons
• Inferno Comparisons
• Blue Blood Comparisons
• Sinful Comparisons
• Underworld Comparisons*
• Sterling Comparisons*
• Lapis Luxury Comparisons*
• Divine Mink Comparisons*
• Hedonistic Comparisons
• Enigma Comparisons