NYX Intense Butter Glosses ($5.99 for 0.27 fl. oz.) are a richer, more opaque gloss with a cream finish and a glossy shine. When NYX nails the formula, it’s really good, but there are some misses. My favorites were Spice Cake (A), Chocolate Crepe (A-), Apple Crisp (A-), and Toasted Marshmallow (A-). They wore around four hours on average and weren’t drying (nor hydrating) with a light vanilla scent but no taste. They’re heavier than the original Butter Gloss formula, and they’re lightly tacky.

>> SEE ALL SWATCHES HERE <<

Report Card

• Orangesicle (A)
• Spice Cake (A)
• Chocolate Crepe (A-)
• Apple Crisp (A-)
• Funnel Delight (A-)
• Toasted Marshmallow (A-)
• Napoleon (B+)
• Tres Leches (B)
• Sorbet (B)
• Black Cherry Tart (B-)
• Banana Split (C+)
• Berry Strudel (C)