MAC x The Simpsons Collection will pop up online on August 28th and head to stores and counters on September 4th. It’s a smaller collection, and it wasn’t particularly impressive. A lot of the shades were dupable, and the quality wasn’t always there. I wish MAC had included lipsticks with this launch, and since this is such an iconic collaboration, I was surprised not to see more merchandise (mirrors, makeup bags/totes, brushes, and so on).

• BEST PERFORMING: Red Blazer Lipglass (A), Itchy & Scratchy & Sexy Lipglass (A-)
• WORST PERFORMING: Pink Sprinkles (B-), Sideshow You Blush (B-), Nacho Cheese Explosion Lipglass (C-)
• MOST UNIQUE: Grand Pumpkin Lipglass (B+), Nacho Cheese Explosion Lipglass (C-)
• PERSONAL FAVORITES: Marge Simpson’s Cutie-cles (N/A)

Report Card

• Red Blazer Lipglass (A)
• Itchy & Scratchy & Sexy Lipglass (A-)
• Grand Pumpkin Lipglass (B+)
• That Trillion Dollar Look Eyeshadow Quad (B)
• Marge’s Extra Ingredients Eyeshadow Quad (B)
• Pink Sprinkles Blush (B-)
• Sideshow You Blush (B-)
• Nacho Cheese Explosion Lipglass (C-)
• Marge Simpson’s Cutie-cles (N/A)