Too Faced La Creme Lip Balm ($22.00 for TBA oz.) is supposed to hydrate lips so they appear plumper and smoother with a “delicious sweet citrus scent.” It comes in six shades (a second review is coming for the other three shades) and five of the six are “juicy tints of color,” while one is clear. The formula has some slip, but it seems less slippery/emollient–less “melty”–than the La Creme Lipstick formula, pehraps because this has a thinner feel overall. All of them give a light natural sheen to lips, and though they’re supposed to be tinted, just about all of them look nearly the same on lips. I have somewhat pigmented lips, but they’re not super pigmented–warmer shades make my lips look a wee bit warmer, cooler shades make them look a bit pinker/darker. I wouldn’t recommend purchasing them for their tinting abilities. On me, the formula is somewhat moisturizing; less so than my favorite lip balms, but the formula is thin enough that it doesn’t stay on for long. I get about an hour to two hours of wear, and then I feel like I have to reapply. The colored ones seemed to accentuate the texture of my lips–it seemed to catch on imperfections I didn’t even know I had. These seemed comparable to Bite Beauty’s BB for Lips. Since these three all look virtually colorless applied, I would rather opt for an ultra-hydrating lip balm than a so-so lip balm with no color or pick up one of their La Creme Lipsticks for greater hydrating and actual color.

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm ($22.00 for TBA oz.) is the clear, colorless shade (as in, intentionally left clear!). It is less glossy than a more liquid-like lip balm, but it is also thinner. The consistency is lightly creamy, lightweight, and applies easily over the lips. It lasts an hour and a half on me.

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm ($22.00 for TBA oz.) is a sheer, peachy-beige. On my lips, it adds warmth and darkens my natural lip color just slightly with a smidgen of shine. It lasts an hour and a half on me.
Bite Beauty Flush (P, $24.00) is slightly more pigmented. MAC Taste of Paradise (LE) is glossier. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm ($22.00 for TBA oz.) is a sheer peach. The major difference between this and Hunny Bunny is the undertone; this doesn’t have any beige in it, so it looks peachier–like a mix of orange and pink. It lasts an hour and a half on me.
Bite Beauty Flush (P, $24.00) is similar. MAC Taste of Paradise (LE) is glossier. See comparison swatches / view dupes.

See more photos & swatches!

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Like Buttah La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Hunny Bunny La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm

Too Faced Peachykeen La Creme Lip Balm