We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • HautelookUp to 59% off MAC Cosmetics, includes eyeshadows, palettes, blushes, eyeliners, lipsticks, and more, ends 8/20.
  • Muse BeautyBuy any 2 Viseart eyeshadow palettes for $128 (plus get three Esum eyeshadow brushes), ends 8/21.
  • Sephora4X points for Rouges (early access 8/11), 3X points for VIBs, and 2X points for BIs on all purchases, starts 8/11 and ends 8/19.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

Get Updates by Email

How often?
We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

93 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

Any of those red by Dolce n Gabanna or YSL lipsticks. All those reds with blue undertones. They should rename that Dragon lacquer “Temptalia” and emblem it after you…you made it an icon lipstick in my opinion. If they can have a “Birkin” bag, they need to have a “Christine” lipstick.

Sadly, I don’t have one yet! Unless I can count Guerlain Gigolo, which is like plum, berry, and red all rolled into one!

Gigolo is a magnificent, spectacular colour! One of my 2 HG lipsticks — NARS Scarlet Empress — is an exact dupe and I wear it whenever I want to feel ultra sexy.

Hourglass Femme Rouge in Raven. Never found a prettier red for my skintone, or one that out performs a non-long wearing formula lipstick. Dead.

Medium/light tan, NC30-NC35, slight warm undertone

Bare Escentuals Amazing Lipcolor in “Strength”.

Lady Bug by Mac, I have a medium complexion and although this red is not as opaque as other reds, it definitely brightens up my face whenever I wear it. Sadly, it doesn’t have much staying power. Still love it though πŸ™‚

So far, I’ve only found 2 reds that I like on me, MAC Fire Sign and MAC Baby’s on Fire…I’m very pale and cool toned.

I’m fair, with neutral undertones – gotta love being able to pull off cool and warm colours! Mine is MAC Throw Me A Line Pro Longwear Lip Pencil (from Hey, Sailor!) teamed with MAC Ladybug. Sometimes I wear MAC Glimmerglass in Blackware over the top, which turns it a deep vampy red – Blackware is an amaaaaaazing layering gloss.

I love “MAC Red” lipstick. It’s vibrant, bold, and a cool red. I’m an NC35, warm undertone. Everyone says I should wear a warm tone red, but I don’t care =)

I think MAC Red is really pretty and an under-appreciated red. It’s as pretty as Russian Red which gets all the attention, if not more so.

It’s a toss up between Kat Von D’s Adora or Make Up Forever Rouge Artist Intense 21. I’m a huge fan of the metallic but matte finish. I’m light with neutral-warm undertones.

L’oreal color Riche in flaming fuscia. It’s like a bright red with sparkle and a tiny hint of pink in it. Medium skin tone, yellow undertones, I’m nc30.

Estee Lauder ” Spanish Red” I’m medium with warm undertones. This is the creamiest lipstick, v opaque and long lasting.

Guerlain Rouge G in Greta is definitely my power red! I am not to be messed with when I put that stuff on my lips!

I’m a dirty blonde, blue eyes, and NW25, fairly neutral undertones.

Not really a power red, but my favorite red is MAC Barcelona Red. For really formal event MAC Ramblas Red is my personal pick.

I’m always surprised that i rarely see Lipstick Queen mentioned. My favourite is Rouge Sinner. Stays on forever. A little lip balm before application and it’s perfection.

I *love* Lipstick Queen and think it’s a massively under-appreciated line. It makes me pretty sad, actually.

I’ve yet to find that one red that stands above all others yet, but the favorite of my current collection is the blue-based Ruby Red I own from the Sephora brand. It’s the red I own that feels the most bold and feminine and sensual. Too bad It’s discontinued now. πŸ™ I think the closest in the new line is Rouge Cream #04 – The Red.

I’m fair with cool, pink undertones.

Dolce and Gabbana – Italian Monica from their Monica Bellucci collection. The most gorgeous red. It rivals and maybe even surpasses MUFE’s Moulin Rouge for me. Incredible texture, completely opaque, lasts for hours and makes your teeth whiter. Perfection.

i’m guessing this pertains to ANY type of red so i break it down based on products. blush-NARS exhibit a, lipstick-MAC red, nail polish-SALLY HANSEN-cherry red
=)

Light-medium (NC25-30) warm yellow/pink skin, about the only red that truly works on me is Chanel’s Lune Rousse.

MAC Relay Race lip gloss. Really wish they’d repromote this, it strikes just the right balance between vampy and classic.

NARS Vesuvio Pure Matte lipstick. It’s a true red and one of my 2 HG lipsticks. If they ever discontinued it, I’d sit down and weep. Actually *weep.* My colouring: light to medium Olive, so either cool, warm or neutral undertones depending on your definition of olive. (I see so many conflicting things!)

NC15 in the summer/NC5 in the winter. I always wear red/fuchsia/orange lipsticks, partially because I love my lips but also because I get lazy about putting on makeup in the morning. With a bright lip I just add mascara and BB cream and run out the door. The red shades I wear most often are Russian Red, Scarlet Ibis, Lady Danger, and Viva Glam I.

BeautΓ© Weightless Lip CrΓ¨me in the shade Masochist – the most beautiful red I’ve ever seen and wore! Suits both cool tones and warm tones in my opinion. I’m medium dark with warm undertones.

I love Beaute, but I have yet to try the lip creme’s.. I’m a huge fan of the voluminous gloss & stains

For stunning “Geisha” lips — Sephora lip stain in “Always Red”
For true “Retro” lips — Revlon’s “Love that Red”
For sexy “Bombshell” lips — Mac “Red” or MUFE “Moulin Rouge”

Mac Brick liner with Mac Russian Red lipstick. I then take Mufe#46 Satin lipstick and use it to contour my lip a little and then take Mufe 10C liner to trace around the contoured areas– this is if I feel creative

99% of the time I layer Mufe 46 over Mac Russian Red. It gives a depend vampy look

I’m fair-light, although not translucent, with completely neutral under/over-tones, and dark hair & eyes, so I find pretty much *any* red to be a good match.

My *favorite* red, ever, is L’Oreal Matte Maraschino, which has been long discontinued, but I found a brand new one in my stash recently, so I’m very happy. It’s almost an exact dupe for NARS Pure Matte in Mascate. Another red I find myself reaching for quite a bit is Maybelline Red Revival.

I’m very fair with neutral undertones and freckles, with red hair and blue eyes. My favorite reds are both Revlon – the Lip Butter in Candy Apple (a warm, coral red) or the Matte Lipstick in Really Red for a more formal/retro look.

Oh man, I have so many! I’m a red lipstick addict! I really love Tarte’s lip surgeon in Fiery! I also LOVE Dragon! I bought two πŸ˜€ Haha.

I’m very fair with cool undertones–less cool than I thought, but still definitely on the pink side of things. My absolute favorite red is Guerlain Garconne; it just makes me *feel* glamorous and beautiful. Second to that would be Shiseido’s Lacquer Rouge in RD607 Nocturne, which is a darker red and makes me look almost porcelain. I love them both to pieces, and both formulas are top- notch.

I am fair with pink undertones. I don’t actually own a red lipstick unless one counts two testers. I find it impossible to wear red. Unfortunately it seems like my whole complexion changes whenever I try a red lipstick and it is not a flattering change. Thankfully deep purple lipsticks work though in case I want a dramatic look.

My power red without a doubt is Adora by Kat Von D. Such a beautiful metallic red!! I tweet her frequently asking for a hot pink just like it. I’m going to keep doing it until she makes one!

I’m very fair with cool undertones and normally can’t pull off those orange based reds as well but mysteriously NARS’s Jungle Red looks killer on me. And the formula…is just my favorite ever.

I just bought it! It’s Eden Rouge from MAC’s new collection. I’m medium tan in color, warm in undertone.

Revlon Really Red is gorgeous, perfect for when I want a bright but not garish true red.
NARS Jungle Red is a summery coral-ish red.
I like to add a touch of NARS 413 Bleecker gloss on them, it really makes them come alive.

I am very pale, with neutral undertones. MUFE HD 117.

I am neutral-toned, around the skin color of Halle Berry or Frieda Pinto.

My power reds:

For summer: Milani Hot Flash Gloss Pencil
For spring: Covergirl Lip Perfection in Enthrall or Burn (for the corally tones)
For autumn: Shiseido RD514
For winter: Bobbi Brown Old Hollywood.

But I wear them all year-round! Still dreaming of a tube of Ellis Faas Milky Lips in L201, hopefully I can find one by the time I can afford to buy yet another red lipstick!

I have dark hair, NC25. I love NARS Moscow – maybe not a “power” red it’s more of an orange-red but I love that it is matte and the color doesn’t give me kidney failure when I catch my reflection.

Estee Lauder’s Pure Color Lipstick in Fig which is gorgeous brown-red color which EL just discontinued after over 20 years of having it in their permanent collection – and I am completely bummed!

My second favorite is Estee Lauder’s Pure Color Lipstick in Cranberry which is soft red (i.e. red-pink color).

I’m definitely late to this game, but I am here. Now, on to my power reds. πŸ™‚

I am medium dark complected with yellow undertones (MAC Studio Fix C8). I love love love red lipstick. Out of the 40 red lipsticks I own:

Nars Fire Down Below, NYX Eros (I love this!), MAC Charmed I’m Sure, MAC VGI, Revlon Ravish Me Red, and Revlon Really Red. I could go on as I love all of my reds, but I will stop here….for now. πŸ˜‰

NARS Mascate!! Not too bright, dark, cool or warm. Suits my tan Indian skin perfectly and I feel incredible wearing it! Highly recommend to everyone, regardless of skin tone.

If you don't see your comment yet, it's still in our moderation queue. We try our best to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind. Thank you for your patience!

On Instagram