We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Giorgio Armani Beauty15% off all orders, plus free shipping on $75+ orders and free Lip Balm on $150+ orders with code SPRING, ends 3/28.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!


Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.
Profile photo of Ryou

Aside from clear lip liner with everything, I wear MUFE Aqua Lip in 8C with most of my red lipsticks. However, I recently got Essence lip liner in Femme Fatale and I’ve been loving it with my Revlon Kissable Balm Stain in Romantique.

I really love MAC Viva Glam Nicki 2 lipglass over MAC Mineralize lipstick in Dreaminess. The lavendar really helps pull out the cool tones of the lipstick without completely overpowering the original color. 🙂

Fave pairing: NYX lip liner in Pumpkin with any clear, gold, or orange gloss. Pumpkin is my fave and I get asked about it all the time, especially at MAC stores.

NYX lip liner in Sand Pink with Kat Von D lipstick in Lolita.

Urban Decay lip liner in Gash with NYX lipstick in Snow White. Mmm, just thinking of this pairing makes me want to wear it RIGHT NOW! It’s midnight here though. Haha!

That is exactly how I get when reading about cosmetics- sure its 2 am and I haven’t slept but I really want to play with my make up.

Estée Lauder lipgloss in violet rain (on which I went crazy after your review) looks stunning on any dark red listick. I don’t wear glosses and there own as I have pigmented lips and the discolouration is seen thru glosses which I don’t like. I also like to use chanel myriade on dark pink or red lipstick as the Multi shimmer looks awesome on a lipstick.

Oh, whoops, I just realized I completely misread the question. XD I generally wear Covergirl Passion lip liner under many of my reds, particularly the warmer and neutral ones. I also love wearing magenta or pink liner under Revlon Colorburst lipgloss in Hot Pink.

Profile photo of Mariella

I only own 2 lip liners and one of those is invisible (it’s by Lise Watier and it works great) so I guess my favourite would have to be MAC Dervish (which I like because it’s basically the colour of my lips so if my lipstick wears off and I don’t get the chance to reapply (as often happens), I’m not left with that strange look of just lip liner. So probably Dervish with MAC Plumful or Craving or Clarins Raspberry Gloss Prodige.

Dervish is the perfect match for my lip color too. I use it in the same way. I wish there was a Pro Longwear lip pencil in the same color, because those last like iron.

All by mac….Oak lipliner by to fill in my pigmented lips. Whirl liner to define edges. Siss or angel lipstick topped off with boy bait cremesheen gloss.

MAC nightmoth and portland black lipstick co’s black lipstick! Which reminds me, would you ever consider reviewing some of their lipsticks?!

I love NYX lipstick in Narcissus over MAC Embrace Me liner. It makes the perfect Barbie pink. I also like MAC Rebel over NIghtmoth liner in the autumn months.

Not many for me except one, which is Wet n Wild Cherry Bomb w/ MAC Love Peck Kissable Lipcolor. Both are pigmented and can be worn alone, but I prefer cherry bomb with a glossy finish and it changes the color a bit so it’s not too blackened on me.

My fav combinations at the moment are: mac lasting sensation lipliner + maybelline colorsensational lipstick in vibrant mandarin, NYX hot pink lipliner + max factor colour elixir lipstcik in shade magenta divine, pupa true lips lipliner in shade 28 + maybelline colorsensational lipstick in electric orange. I fill my lips with a lipliner first (use it all over, not only as a contour), then apply lip colour with a brush.

My favorite liner/lipstick combo hands down is Mac’s Vino liner with Candy Yum Yum. Nightmoth with Diva is also to die for.

My favorite combo at the moment is Too Faced lipliner in Perfect Nude, with Mac’s Altered Beige on top. Love it!!!!!

MAC Nightmoth pencil + MAC Runaway Red lipstick

I usually don’t wear lip liners except with deep reds and this is my favorite combo.

Profile photo of Melissa

mac dubonnet with nyx cabaret or deep red. got dubonnet, was kind of disappointed with the opacity and feathering, so i picked up these lipliners and it is now one of my favorite lipsticks.

also, mac rebel with sephora’s nano lip pencil in pleasant plum. similar situation to dubonnet, rebel isn’t totally opaque on me and it was a little slippery for my liking, but overtop pleasant plum it is perfect.

On Instagram