Thursday, February 20th, 2014

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans

There are forty-four shades of eyeshadows available in pan-form from theBalm, which launched at the beginning of this year. They can be purchased at their San Francisco store or by calling 415-817-1800. Each eyeshadow pan is available for $6.50 and comes in a cardboard sleeve. The 9-pan palette is $8.00, while the 16-pan palette is $10. If you fill either the 9- or 16-pan palette up at the time of purchase, they will run you $44.00 (normally, $66.50) and $64.00 (normally, $114.00) respectively. Each palette is made out of thick cardboard–same as theBalm’s eyeshadow palettes have been in the past–and come with full-sized mirrors on the top flap. For more information about sizes, the palettes, and a general overview of the custom palette/eyeshadow pan system, please read this post. You can view swatches of all of them in the Swatch Gallery here or view photos and swatches on theBalm’s Eyeshadow Single product page. .

#1 is a warm-toned, dark brown with gold micro-glitter and copper sparkle over a satin-matte finish. It had really good color payoff, and the texture was fairly soft and smooth, but you could feel some of the sparkle separate from the base color, so there was fall out during application. I noticed some minor fall out during wear, but only some of the sparkle translates onto the lid so there’s less that falls out over time. The color lasted for eight hours before gradually fading. Makeup Geek Bada-Bing (P, $5.99) is grayer. Chanel Seduction #4 (LE) is less sparkly, more frosted. MAC Constructivist (P, $18.50) is darker, cream product. NARS Surabaya #2 (P, $24.00) is lighter, warmer. NARS Mekong (P, $24.00) is darker, cooler-toned. MAC Carbonized (LE, $15.00) is darker. bareMinerals Pumped (LE) is warmer. See comparison swatches. This seemed really close to Silly, but #1 had a better texture and more pigmentation.

#2 is a silver-sparkled, cool-toned pinky-purple. The texture was dry, powdery, and almost gritty–I could really feel the powder and sparkle in it. It had semi-sheer color payoff, and it was difficult to apply. It’s a shade that really has to have a sticky, almost white-tinged base to work in any usable capacity. What color I managed to get onto the lid lasted for six hours before I saw noticeable fading. Laura Mercier African Violet (P, $23.00) is cooler-toned with a golden sheen. MAC Swelter (LE, $15.00) is cooler-toned, more muted. Buxom Schnauzer (P, $18.00) is a cream product. Inglot #445 (P, $6.00) is cooler-toned, frosted. See comparison swatches.

#3 is a muted, dark green with cool undertones and a fine, emerald green micro-shimmer and satin finish. It had good color payoff, and the texture was soft and fairly smooth. It wore well for eight hours before showing signs of fading. Tarina Tarantino Very Wicked (LE) is more frosted. Makeup Geek Envy (P, $5.99) is very similar. Urban Decay Damaged (LE, $18.00) is brighter. Make Up For Ever #80 (P, $20.00) is brighter. See comparison swatches.

#4 is a softened, pink-tinged peach with a frosted finish and warm undertones. It had excellent color payoff, and the texture was soft and smooth without being powdery. This shade lasted for eight hours before it started to fade. This seemed really similar to theBalm Stubborn, though it appeared slightly lighter in the pan but the swatches were nearly identical. Kat Von D Precious (LE) is similar. LORAC Champagne (P) is lighter. MAC A Natural Flirt (LE, $19.50) is warmer.Le Metier de Beaute Nouvelle (LE, $30.00) is pinker. See comparison swatches.

#5 is a deep, dark, muted cool-toned purple with a satin finish. It had fantastic pigmentation, and the texture was very soft and finely-milled but slightly powdery. The color wore well for eight and a half hours when I tested it. theBalm The Stroke (P, $16.00) is very similar, if not identical, but the color payoff was weaker. MAC Double Feature #8 #2 (LE, $15.00) is darker. See comparison swatches.

#6 is a muted, coppery brown with warm, orange undertones and a pearly finish. It had excellent pigmentation, and the texture was soft, buttery, and smooth. The color lasted for just over eight hours when I wore it. Kat Von D Dog Roses (LE) is brighter. Too Faced Jingle All the Way Eyeshadow #3 (LE, $16.00) is more frosted. Anastasia Rum Cake (LE) is slightly more frosted. NARS Isolde #2 (P, $24.00) is darker. See comparison swatches.

The Glossover

P
product

#1

B+

Product

8.5/10

Pigmentation

9/10

Texture

9/10

Longevity

8/10

Application

4.5/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!
P
product

#2

F

Product

4/10

Pigmentation

5/10

Texture

4/10

Longevity

6/10

Application

2.5/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
P
product

#3

B+

Product

9/10

Pigmentation

9/10

Texture

8.5/10

Longevity

8.5/10

Application

5/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Click to Reveal More Glossovers!

See more photos & swatches!

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans — #1-16

theBalm Eyeshadow Pans
theBalm Eyeshadow Pans — #1-16

theBalm #1 Eyeshadow
theBalm #1 Eyeshadow

theBalm #1 Eyeshadow
theBalm #1 Eyeshadow

theBalm #1 Eyeshadow
theBalm #1 Eyeshadow

theBalm #2 Eyeshadow
theBalm #2 Eyeshadow

theBalm #2 Eyeshadow
theBalm #2 Eyeshadow

theBalm #2 Eyeshadow
theBalm #2 Eyeshadow

theBalm #3 Eyeshadow
theBalm #3 Eyeshadow

theBalm #3 Eyeshadow
theBalm #3 Eyeshadow

theBalm #3 Eyeshadow
theBalm #3 Eyeshadow

theBalm #4 Eyeshadow
theBalm #4 Eyeshadow

theBalm #4 Eyeshadow
theBalm #4 Eyeshadow

theBalm #4 Eyeshadow
theBalm #4 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #5 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #5 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #5 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #6 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #6 Eyeshadow

theBalm #5 Eyeshadow
theBalm #6 Eyeshadow

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #12 (inner lid), #16 (middle of lid), #3 (outer lid), #18 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #12 (inner lid), #16 (middle of lid), #3 (outer lid), #18 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #40 (inner lid), #42 (middle of lid), #28 (outer lid), #38 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #40 (inner lid), #42 (middle of lid), #28 (outer lid), #38 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #7 (inner lid), #4 (middle of lid), #2 (outer lid), #15 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #7 (inner lid), #4 (middle of lid), #2 (outer lid), #15 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #21 (inner lid), #6 (middle of lid), #13 (outer lid), #1 (crease), #24 (brow bone)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #21 (inner lid), #6 (middle of lid), #13 (outer lid), #1 (crease), #24 (brow bone)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #11 (inner lid), #23 (middle of lid), #5 (outer lid), #9 (crease)

theBalm Eyeshadow
theBalm Eyeshadows: #11 (inner lid), #23 (middle of lid), #5 (outer lid), #9 (crease)

The Dupe List: #1

See More Dupes

The Dupe List: #2

See More Dupes

The Dupe List: #3

See More Dupes
Click to Reveal More Dupes!

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

39 thoughts on “theBalm #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Eyeshadow Reviews, Photos, Swatches

  1. Thank you so so much for this posting! I’ve always wanted to try eyeshadows from theBalm and the new option of purchasing singles is frankly awesome! x

  2. It’s too bad the purple one rates so low.. I love all the eye looks!

  3. Miss C

    Hey Christine! Quick question… if I depot the shady lady palettes, will the shadows fit this custom palette? I was thinking of buying some new singles and mixing it with shades I already love from the shady lady ones. Thanks!

  4. I was kind of hoping these would be their other shades they have put out with their palettes as well as some new ones for single purchase. #2 Eyeshadow is the the first time I’ve seen a shadow from them preform this badly.
    Ani_BEE Recently Posted: Illamasqua Pure Pigment in Static: Swatches & Review

  5. Wow! An F! That’s a tough one to overcome. Amazing at how much quality can vary within a brand! you did some lovely looks with these!
    meganlisa Recently Posted: Jeffrey Dame’s Amazing scents..a must have…

  6. Ha yikes what happened with #2?! Aside from that, these looks great. I’ve had good experiences with theBalm’s shadows and love custom palettes, so these definitely peak my interest. Love that deep gold, especially
    Catherine Recently Posted: MILANI HD Advanced Lip Color in Ignition (113)

  7. Hm, some I like, some I don’t really care for! I’ve owned theBalm shadows in the past and while I loved the formula, I just wasn’t really itching for them when I was doing my makeup? I don’t know why. Something about the colours, even though they were pretty colours.
    Rikki Recently Posted: SPRING MAKEUP: NEUTRAL EYES & DEWY SKIN | closed captioned

  8. Wow of all the shades to be duds. I was expecting one of the nude/beige colored ones to do that. And yet the random empty spot on my Z palettes scream to be filled. Ugh no I don’t need to be a completionist!

    Thank you for the thorough reviews for this and the shades to come! I’m going straight here when I build my theBalm custom palette.

    • I read that totally wrong the first time, because I read it as, “Wow, all of the shades are duds,” and I was like, “Wait, no! They’re not!” LOL!

      I wasn’t expecting #2 to be anywhere NEAR that level of sheer/dry/gritty at all. It’s purple, so if it had been a little weak in pigmentation, it wouldn’t have surprised me.

  9. The shade I really loved among the 6 was #2 and it turned out to be the worst!!! :-(
    Vineetha Recently Posted: Lorac Pro Palette Review, Swatches

  10. I really wanted #2 to be good. I guess this just confirms I need to have African Violet in my collection.
    Erin Recently Posted: Le Creuset Signature Marseille Round Wide French Oven Review

  11. How does #1 compare to Gilded Ganache from the Too Faced Chocolate Bar palette?

  12. I wish these had names besides #1, #2, #3, etc. Also I wonder why these aren’t offered on their website?

    • Just in-store for now – I’m not sure if it’s a shipping thing or not wanting to have to set it up in a way to discount with the filled palette? No idea really.

  13. #5 is pretty! I love the hazy indigo colour :-)

    Bit of a shame about the other purple though :-(

    (*twitches with effort of not starting rant about how blue and purple eyeshadows almost always seem to be at a disadvantage, quality wise*)
    Sylirael Recently Posted: Rainbow Milk? Etude House Play Nail Polish in #113

  14. zainab

    I’m so sad about #2, I thought it was rem from the Balm Jovi Palette, which I didn’t buy when I had the chance. Oh well.

  15. oooohhh! I am such a sucker for custom palettes now that i’ve discovered them. i already have bh cosmetics, coastal scents, and recently did a haul including my elf palette. This one looks so pretty as well!
    doris Recently Posted: Eyes Lips Face Cosmetics Haul

  16. I love numbers 5 and 6! :)

  17. Wow! Shades 4and 5 are beautiful!

  18. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Susan Susan Dowman Nevling

    Your application and color combinations are stunning!