Thursday, December 23rd, 2010

The Hit List

What’s the Worst Setting Powder…?

What brand/product wins this category? Any particular reason it wins?

Thanks to Jenny for today’s topic!

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

41 thoughts on “The Hit List: Worst Setting Powder

  1. Charlotte

    I hate Everyday Minerals’ Bamboo powder. Feels like grinded glass on my face

    • Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of T Violet Lee

      Years ago, I used Coty Airspun and thought I liked it. But now I look at old pics of myself and I look so powdery, it’s like I can see it just sitting on top on my make-up.

    • Ani_BEE

      Never tried it but I have not bought from them in over a year and I’m not planning too again.

      Rice setting powders in general. They never seem to be refined enough.

  2. Ester

    I actually find the NARS loose setting powder aweful!!! It makes my skin so oily after just a short while. I am really disappointed.

  3. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Lisa Vita

    I use MUFE powder daily and have religiously since the dawn of time it seems. Its been so long since I used anything else but I seem to remember a Pallido rice powder I used ages ago that made me ghostly white no matter how lightly I applied it. I think I still have it though somewhere in my tower of makeup… Perhaps I can find a use for it.

  4. Ani_BEE

    100% Talcum Powder (AKA baby powder) not a bad thing when you use it with clown makeup but it’s too white to set foundation.

  5. Elise

    Now, I know a lot of people will disagree…but I think MAC Mineralize Skinfinish Natural is the worst. It does nothing to mattify, which might be great for some, but not for me. It also has absolutely no coverage, just kind of blurs lines a little.

    It also will give you a ghostly glow because of the blurring effect it has. Also, it is the WORST for settling into pores. I didn’t even know powder could settle into pores with a primer and foundation, but this one does, no matter what.

    It smudges and migrates easily too. A huge waste of $29.

    • sam

      i know just how you feel! it’s disgusting :\

    • Dawn

      The skinfinish natural is not a setting powder though. Nor is it to mattify. It Leaves a natural finish, hence the Mineralize skinfinish NATURAL.

      • ali

        You don’t need to have an attitude about it, though. It can be used to set foundation. MAC Fluidlines are supposed to be eyeliners, but you can use them for eyeshadow bases too. Food for thought.

        • I think her point was that msfn isn’t a mattifying or setting powder, so it’s unfair to say it sucks at doing that. Likewise, it’d be unfair to say fluidlines are bad bases if they’re meant to be eyeliners.

      • Lindsey

        If it’s not a setting powder or a mattifier, and leaves a NATURAL finish, what exactly is the point and why is it worth $29? I did not like this product, I really liked Napoleon Perdis, and Clinique.

        • El

          It is “technically” a powder foundation (like studio fix, just lighter coverage) and is geared towards those with drier skin, which explains why it makes oily people oilier. I’m not defending it, cuz it’s not my powder of choice either, but just sayin…

          • I agree, but the site does say “Provides perfect low coverage. Use to set and fix foundation or as a touch-up throughout the day.” So a lot of people would think that it could be used as a setting powder.

  6. Nunuiviet

    MAC skin finish natural, the worst I have tried definitely not for gals with oily skin!

  7. courtney

    Lorac translucent setting powder It jsut didn’t do much for me I still have half of it I switched to mufe

  8. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Marian Marian

    Besame loose powder. It’s too white and the vanilla scent makes me feel as if I’m putting candy on my face.

  9. julie

    urban decay’s de-slick in powder from.
    they said it was transluscent but…well it made my face look sickly!

  10. Jennifer

    The worst setting powder I have ever used is the Revlon Photoready pressed translucent powder! While I LOVE the liquid foundation, the powder that goes with it is HORRIBLE, just terrible. It’s glittery and makes me look so cakey!

  11. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Erica Erica

    I hate the Coty Airspun translucent extra coverage. I have pink undertones and even this is WAY toooo pink on my skin. And like Lee, I find it to look too powdery. But I love the smell of it. I think I need to try to the plain old translucent version. I’ve heard that it does come in some tinted versions, but I think my Walgreens only carries the 2 translucent versions. boo.

  12. I have to agree about the Revlon Photo ready pressed powder. Awful stuff! And yes, the foundation is great. I don’t know how they could hit so well with one product and miss by such a mile with the next….

  13. El

    Mary Kay loose powder. Purchased it once and never again!

  14. MAC Prep + Prime ! Il dries ma skin terribly, I hate it !

  15. Lindsey

    Coastal Scents. It’s so gritty. I like to use the L’Oreal setting powder; it’s so soft.

  16. Julianna

    Revlon Photo Ready. I made the mistake of buying the “translucent” white color. I was quite surprised to find that it was FULL OF GLITTER. Moreover, it was the chalkiest powder I’ve ever used. One swipe with their cheap little brush and there would be a dust storm. Iiiick.

  17. Nicole

    I hat to say it, but it’s MAC Prep and Prime Transparent Finishing Powder. It gives my skin a really matte finish and sets my Face and Body foundation all day long, BUT it breakes me out! In the beginning I thought it’s the foundation, but it’s the powder. Giving me more red spots is the reason why it is the worst setting powder for my skin.

  18. Desiree

    Bobbi Brown Sheer Finish Loose Powder in Sunny Beige!
    If your looking for oil-control and setting make-up, it doesn’t do either! It cakes up in dry areas even if I properly moisturized. And it contains Bismuth Oxychloride which makes my skin itch when I sweat (the ingredient is also found in the original Bare Minerals, etc.) !!

  19. Iliana

    Max Factor translucent powder is absolutely horrid on my skin. :( I’ve heard great things about the brand though. Too bad the powder made my skin look ashy-orangey.

    Happy holidays Christine and readers! :)

  20. Profile wp-user-avatar wp-user-avatar-60 alignnone photo of Ana Meg

    MAC Select Sheer Pressed Powder!
    it just doesn’t work with my skin type.

  21. Miss Tayva

    Coty Airspun.
    The smell is terrible, and it just sits on the skin, making it look crepey and chalky. I know many people who use this and it ages them so badly.