Saturday, December 27th, 2008

The Hit List

Best Pencil Eyeliner? What product wins this category?

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

17 thoughts on “The Hit List: Best Pencil Eyeliner

  1. Anitacska

    Have we not done this quite recently? Seem to remember a lot of people going for the UD 24/7 liners. Which is also my choice btw. Fantastic product in great colours! :)

  2. cloudburst

    My fave is Fly-By-Blu pearlglide liner by MAC. I find the subtle blue sparkles really make my eyes look whiter. I liked it so much I bought a backup!

  3. Rio

    Of what I have tried, I like Urban Decay 24/7 in color Zero (black). I only use it on my lower lid though. On top, I use liquid liner.

  4. UD 24/7s and MAC pearlglides tied as my faves. Followed by stila kajals.

  5. Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes! They’re long-lasting and waterproof. I can use it on my waterline in the morning and have it last long after I’ve come home from work in the evening :)

  6. PAOLA

    i like mufe aqua eyes…i got a sample from sephora and i thought the color really stayed on all day…but for me to pay $16 for a pencil hurts lol…call me cheap…it is worth it though lol…i did buy my avon smooth over eye definer in blackest black and i love it…it stays on good…the only thing with any kind of liner with me it always builds up in the outer corner of my eye…accept my hip liner…but the avon is def my fave…i have it in white too

  7. lisa

    Urban decay without a doubt it is the absolute best liner i have ever tried.

  8. Liz

    Urban Decay 24/7 liners (I have all the colors).

  9. Huge fan of the powerpoint pencils by MAC! :) Any of them, really.

  10. Sara

    Love the MAC pearlglides – my two faves are Wolf and Spare Change. I did get Fly By Blu but find I don;t wear it so much as it’s quite ‘out there’ for my work place!

  11. Chica

    UD 24/7 without a doubt :)

  12. pia

    Feline, Indigo, Wolf and blacktrack

  13. carriespooner

    UD 24/7. I’m a new convert. My Goodness these are special. I got the Velvet Rope colleciton from Sephora. So worth it.

    I’d put Mac’s pearlglides second since they are also creamy but UD wins my vote!

  14. Sammie

    Urban Decay 24/7 no contest. The lot! =D

  15. Grace

    I’ve tried all the high-end pencil eyeliners out there, and I would have to say, Prestige Waterproof Pencil Liners would still have to be my favourite. It’s so creamy, glides smoothly on my skin, and it lasts FOREVER. It’s also easy to remove at night. I love it.