Sunday, October 21st, 2007

What’s your favorite eye makeup palette? Nearly every line has limited edition quads, duos, or palettes that come at various times of the year – what’s your favorite? Which one do you always use?

I’m awful with palettes; they often sit unused for me. I own an overwhelming majority of MAC quads/holiday palettes — most of which I depotted and put in with the rest of my regular palettes. I love the Liza AM (old, old, OLD quad) for the easiest neutral eye. They’re all matte shadows, very blah shades when you look at them, but they can add some va-voom for those occasions where you need to be professional or subtle with the eye makeup.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

29 thoughts on “Temptalia Asks You – What’s your favorite eye makeup palette?

  1. Carrie

    Cool Delights 2005 Holiday 6-shadow set. It includes my two main looks – grayish-olive and plum. Tabby is one of my favorite MAC shades.

  2. shin

    hmm, i love my bobbi brown shimmer brick, which i use as an eyeshadow because of my fair skin tone. i find myself reaching out for givenchy’s delice de chocolat palette quite often though, because browns are such foolproof shades which are natural enough for day, especially since im wearing it to school. but i find the givenchy eyeshadow not pigmented enough for my liking and it takes several coats to achieve the intensity i would like. :/

  3. Ashlee

    I dont have any premade pallettes but I adore the showflower quad & both the smokey eye ones.

  4. Lindsay

    Holiday ’06 Smoked Eyes, it makes the perfect fool proof smokey eye. It was one of the first MAC products I ever bought and I have been addicted ever since!

  5. right now the Smoking Eyes quad for a perfect smokey look, or a quad i made out of pressed pigments — i forget which ones are which, but they are nice shimmery neutrals.

  6. Kate

    I like Tarte’s A List palette – 8 beautiful shadows in the cutest purple case and it was only $40!

  7. Skyler

    I loooove both Smoke Signals quads, the Thunder Eyes quad, and the Tease Me quad. I am a huge quad fan in general but those are the four that I use the most thus far. :)

  8. Noel

    With being new to Mac, I have to say the Smoking Eyes or Gentle Fumes quads for sure! The colors are all just so pretty and they help make a great smokey eyed look. :)

  9. Janis

    The only palettes I have of MAC are the Smoke Signals quads and Pandamonium quad and I love all of them coz I can make different looks with them. But my ultimate favorite palettes are the quints of Dior– I love all their color combos.

  10. tanya

    Guess I am the odd one in the group but I hate palette combos. It always seems like there are two or three colors that are ok and then one or two hidious in the combo. I much prefer individual colors that I can mix and match with whatever colors I choose. Its one of the things I like about MAC, buying one color at a time is an option. When I started out playing with drugstore brand make-up it always seemed so weird that the requirement was to buy a combo of colors and it always seemed that only one or two of the colors got any use. Maybe one day I will see the light that everyone here seems to see :) until then I just don’t get the appeal of combo colors.

    • Hey Tanya! I don’t reach for quads very often myself – I tend to forget about them shortly after I acquire them, but I love to depot MAC quads to put them in my 15-pan palettes instead so I use them more often!

  11. mich

    Don’t worry Tanya, I feel the same way as you! In fact, I’ve always been suspicious of palettes – they must be made to cater to as wide an audience as possible, so of course a few colours will sit unused because they don’t suit your individual skintone. And sure enough, that’s always what happens to me. Maybe I’m just too perfectionistic about getting the exact shade I want? In any case, that’s why I tend to steer clear of palettes unless they’re a clear bargain (like that Sephora one!! sigh …)

  12. chuarmk

    I like and own 5 eyeshadow palettes(3 MAC & 2 Jill Stuart) but oddly I rarely use them.On daily basis,I use my mineralize eyeshadows esp.Flashtronic much more.For the palettes,I only use it more when I go travelling.My favourite is Jill Stuart “Glazed Garnet”,from this year authum collection (this brand is only available in Japan) but the one which I use “most” is however Jill Stuart “Jewel Violet” also authum collection *weird*.

  13. Xoch

    I would def have to say the summerwear palette.

  14. Zsofi

    my fav palette is the CHANEL Aqualumiéres Water Palette.
    it is an old palette,but gorgeous,really.
    it has 8 wonderful colors in it,the colors are creamy,and You can use them wet or dry. i never used them with water,they are creamy already.they look fantastic!!!!
    You can put them on Your eyes,lips,cheeks…
    a zillion variations!!!!
    4 colors are rather bronze and goldish,mainly for the eye area.
    2 lilac hues,also mainly for eyes, and 2 pinkish hues for lips and cheeks.
    for creamy shadows,they stay on the lids for a long time,even without a base.
    love love love this palette!!!

    i also love the Les 4 Ombres eyeshadow quads by CHANEL:
    the 2 faves are: Stage Lights,with this palette,i can make aq gorgeous purple eye makeup.
    and Fascination,the greatest smokey eye palette i tried yet.

    i also like an YSL palette called “Bayadére” Style,
    it has 6 colors,3 blues,a green,and an orange.

    one more fav: Manhattan Perfect Eyes in Samba Effects: 2 blues,one lemon hue. for it’s price it is just wonderful,long lasting,intense colors.