We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Lord & Taylor30% off almost everything + 10% off cosmetics & fragrances with code FRIENDS, ends 12/15.
  • Tarte30% off with code BESTIES, ends 12/11.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

34 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

Only mascara, but I don’t fallow 3 month rule, since I use 5 mascaras at the time. I keep them longer then 3 moths and throw them after they dry out.

Mascara if it goes clumpy lipgloss if it gets that sickly smell liquid foundation if it separates, i try and keep my makeup clean by wiping round lids and tops with antibacterial wipes and keeping away from radiators and warm rooms like the shower room ect

I’m about to chuck some really old cheapie eyeshadows. The only other things I throw away on a regular basis are mascara and liquid foundation (or any other item that’s cream/liquid).

I throw everything out (or Back to MAC it if it’s MAC) when it’s expired. Nothing grosses me out like the idea of old makeup. Mascara, though… I don’t get too ridiculous about. I wear it maybe once a week so I mainly hold onto it until I’m tired of it or it’s not performing at it’s best (which usually isn’t more than four months, because bacterial builds up either way).

Well, like everyone else has mentioned, I mostly discard mascaras when they dry out. I use mineral foundation so that lasts up to 3 years and I usually use it up within less than a year. Eyeshadows.. well, I probably should clear out some stuff since I still have some eyeshadows from waaaay back in high school eons and eons ago lol!

When it smells or feels bad its out the door!I try to take reay good care of things I know will last me forever though like eyeshadow(powder) and pigments! Use a clean brush ect.

only after a few years..lol! I sometimes keep a shoebox of my fav colors which are either smelly or have gone to rot, but I keep them for the color dupes which I need. Other than that, it hurts like hell to throw away favorites ~~

Mascaras usually….with MAC i can B2M…..few lipgloss/lipstick frm my very initial days…they smelled funny…i throw them.
oh yeah, lotions n creams…if they separate or smell rancid..they are out….

I have had about 5 things in my life that I had to throw away because they went off, mainly lip glosses. I chuck mascara out when it dries out or runs out, but not one mascara has gone off in my possession. I chucked out a few old eyeshadows (ie older than 5 years!) because I didn’t use them anymore, but they were still fine, in fact I gave the better ones to my sister and she was happy with them. 🙂

I don’t if they still look fine. And but that I mean it does not smell bad or the powder starts creasing or a layer of oil on the top etc….

I usually throw out my makeup mainly the liquids according to smell / texture. I just back 2 MAC’d 12 glosses 🙁

Mascara’s go out every 3-4 unless they dry out before that…

Absolutely not. Lol I’m gross. Like others, I really base it on changes in color and texture. If a mascara is drying out, it gets chucked and replaced. I’m not about to throw away my perfectly good powder shadows which show no issue, though. My biggest fear in the world is one day I will get pink eye and lose everything. Watch, I just cursed myself.

I am the same way hahaha I’m glad I’m not the only one hahaha Unless it’s dried up and cruddy or smells or got watery, I use it haha

I do the smell & texture test – about once or twice a year I also “sterilize” my lipsticks by dipping them in alcohol & wiping them off so they are cleaner while I’mnot using them. I also sometimes will wipe the surface of my shadows to give them a clean. I only throw mascara out when it gets dry or the tube feels empty.

I’m really struggling with this right now, trying to figure out WHEN to toss things. I haven’t run into too many bad smelling or texture issues, and with MAC lipglasses how can you tell? Some things I’ve had for 5 years and I keep thinking it has to be time to pitch them but they don’t seem bad! But as other say, it hurts to toss favorites.

I just cleaned out a bunch of old stuff that i didnt use….. the only thing i throw out on a regular basis is mascara. when it gets clumpy or dry…. i dont like to throw away make up it makes me sad haha

mascara gets tossed on time. I spray alcohol on powder shadows after each use. If it looks or smells bad out it goes. But when u spend 50 for aneyeshadow quad.. you try and keep it as long as possible…

I think I’ve had makeup long enough for it to expire. Most of my makeup collection has been purchased within the past month and a half lol… But I have a ton of lipglosses and none of them smell bad yet and it’s been quite a while.

Foundation – when the water starts to linger on top! definitely off to trashcan when it’s over a year from opening unless it’s a powder foundation

Mascara – every 2months (I love using fresh mascara! This is why I buy them when it’s buy one get one free plus upon availability of a coupon)

Powder, Blush, Eye shadows – I scrape the upper part with a disposable mascara wand. I toss them when color or texture start to change. It should last for about 2 years or longer. You are better off changing any liquid products more often.
One of my favorites, MAC Barbie Beauty powder will never be tossed!

Lipstick – I lay down a piece of paper towel and run over it to make it fresh. Toss when smell changes or liquid comes out of it.

Gloss – Toss when smells funky, color changes, or when the sponge tip wears off. I store glosses upside down (the cap portion is facing down) to limit the air from entering the product.
The separation of a gloss does not mean it’s old; it simply means that it has not been mixed well when it was made. Many of MAC glosses have this issue.

Eye liner, Lip liner – As long as sharpen after every use and keep the cap on it will last for years. Automatic pencils can be scraped off, yet they have shorter lifespan than regular pencils. Gel liner/fluid liner will dry out and harder to use when it’s time to go.

Nail Polish – 1 year from opening, when becomes chunky in texture or change in color. Store it in the fridge if your house is warm.

*For those who have owned any opened products for more than 5+ years: It’s time to let go of them! Do not give them to your little sister or friend! Take them for Back 2 MAC or go shopping!!!

Subscribe

Join our newsletter and never miss a post!