Tuesday, March 17th, 2009

Stila’s Summer Collection features a stunning quad, the Charmed palette ($28.00), which I am sure instantly created some temptation! The colors featured in the palette are a mid-tone copper, warm gold, intense teal, and deep burgundy.

The color themselves are quite lovely, as they swatch well with rich pigmentation. I’d describe the colors more of a coppery-pink, warm coppery-gold, teal with green undertones, and a brown-burgundy. The texture is smooth and silky, easily blending into the skin and no fall out problems.

The only issue I had with the palette was the packaging itself. The gold coloring and the detailing on the outside was beautiful, but it feels like it’s all cardboard. The clear part (where you can see the shadows) is super thin plastic–like what you might find on top of shadows. I’d have preferred something more durable. Otherwise, this palette is superb, and it is totally worth $28!

See close-ups and swatches

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

71 thoughts on “Stila’s Summer Collection: Charmed Palette Sneak Peek

  1. Natalia

    Wow you werent kidding about the pigmentation, its gorgeous. I wasnt planning on buying this pallete but now im convinced to get it and play around with the colors. It looks perfect for summer

    Thanks for the review =)

  2. Kayc

    Oh wow I’m definitely gonna get this palette. I was debating whether I should purchase it when I first saw the product photos but now I’m sure about it. Thanks for the swatches :)

  3. JennXOXO

    Ooh. The warm gold and teal are both pretty!

  4. Rena

    The purple shadow swatches much darker that it looks! But all the colors are so pretty, I may have to buy this as my first venture in to Stila.

  5. Brie

    I’m sure I’m not the only one who is hoping you might do a look with these shadows! They look gorgeous swatched at the very least!

  6. sprut

    I feel like we are seeing this cardboard-like packaging more and more. I really dislike it for convenience but especially considering the prices on some of these lines I think it is outrageous that they give us such shoddy packaging. I think it’s really a turnoff…at least for me.

    • Avatar of Carrie Carrie

      Personally, I like the cardboard-y packaging because I tend to break and chip my plastic ones. These have been more durable, even though it feels like they ought not to be…maybe it’s just my luck, though.

      Also, it’s nice that paper is a renewable resource and plastic isn’t.

      • I don’t really mind that it’s cardboard either, though I know some would want to know that upfront so definitely had to mention it!

        I didn’t like the thin sheet of plastic on the cover — that felt cheap and flimsy :(

    • The cardboard itself doesn’t really bother me one way or the other (plastic = cardboard in my book in terms of quality), but the thin plastic part bugged me!

  7. yarid

    Looks beautiful!!!!! Thanks!!!!

  8. grace

    sooo getting this! i am loving the stila spring palette so this looks amazing for some dramatic looks for summer !

  9. Sasha

    Mind-blowingly pretty! Can’t wait to get one of these!

  10. Shefali

    AMAZING PIGMENTATION!

  11. smugbear

    stila usually doesnt interest me but im definatly getting this quad!!!:)

  12. Oh man… that’s gorgeous! I wasn’t very impressed at first, but now I’m definitely gonna have to go take a look when it hits Sephora!

  13. Emily

    I’m wondering if these colors are similar to anything from their permanent line?

  14. pj

    Lovely palette. The designs on the bottom look a lot like

  15. Ohhh it’s pretty!

  16. RuBie

    Hi Christine, is the pink in this palette similar to French Cuff from the MAC BBR collection?

  17. Nicole15

    Wow! The pigmentation on these is just as rich as you said. They are gorgeous. I really see them being ideal for summer. i can already picture some looks in my mind i would love to try with them. can’t wait to purchase this palette. Christine – do you know when this item will become available for purchase?

  18. cloudburst

    I’m not fond of coppers but the other 3 colours are too gorgeous to pass up, especially that purple – they are on the list!

  19. Megan

    These colors are amazing. I didn’t plan on buying this palette but after seeing the swatches I’m very tempted!!!

  20. Myxa

    Christine, can you please let us know what are the MAC dupes for these? Roughly?

    Thanks so much!!!!

  21. Avatar of Faiza Faiza

    It just looked so-so before but after seeing the swatches it looks like a great buy! Only if it wasn’t so much.

  22. mac addict

    this colors are GORGEOUS! but they look a bit glittery like the urban decay wallpaper pallet and the bax i am personally not a fan or cardboard.

  23. Christina

    stila packaging is a huge turn-off.

  24. Jessie

    This is drool worthy, especially loving the teal and burgundy. Though I know I can’t wear teal as I tend towards warmer colours. Any tips to overcome this?

  25. SephoraMac

    Oh I love these, I am dying to get this palette. Thanks for
    sharing!!!!

  26. Tanya

    I hope this goes to beautycrunch eventually. I love the colors but wouldn’t use them often enough to justify purchasing it now.

  27. Mikki

    Oeh. That gold-ish color is so pretty

  28. kat

    this is just beautiful!!!! i wonder if it blends well…

  29. aeys1

    These colors have great pay offs.

  30. violette

    This looks stunning and the packaging very elegant.
    I’m definitely buying !

  31. Tina

    In the palette the colors didn’t look so appealing but now that you swatched it really does! Do you know if the $10 dollar deal is also in stores?

  32. Charisse

    Cool! I’ve always wanted to try this palette, & the $10.00 price is a very good steal. Thank you so much for the heads-up. : )

  33. Skyler

    GORGEOUS! I’ve wanted this ever since I first saw the summer previews. My CP gal snagged one of the $10 ones for me so I am super excited. :D Although, she said some of the Sephoras are telling her they’re not going to carry the rest of the collection (already on the Stila site)? That’s really weird if Sephora won’t sell the rest of it. Do you have any idea if that’s true or not?