Rant & Rave: Holiday Collections

Date: Tuesday, November 25th, 2008 Author:

Tell us why/what you love, hate, or are indifferent about… HOLIDAY COLLECTIONS!

23 thoughts on “Rant & Rave: Holiday Collections

  1. Vee says:

    I like how many holiday collections usually involve more glam looks for going out to parties – smokey eyes and red lips & so on. And usually the packaging is fun, which is always a lovely bonus when it’s a brand/product that you always like! Palettes, kits & etc can make great gifts for those on your list that love cosmetics and can sometimes offer deal, too.

  2. MAHALIA says:

    I HATE HOW THEY ALWAYS SELL OUT IT EATS ME ALIVE. LOL

  3. msjlh says:

    I love that you can get an entire palette at an affordable price. I hate that sometimes I end up liking only one color in the entire palette.

  4. KyaLyn says:

    I love all the colors you can get in one palette, but they’re also hard to find an place for them in my bathroom as they’re usually odd sizes. I also don’t like the fact that many end up being inferior products from the normal line.

    • Macaddict says:

      Same here KyaLyn! That’s why I don’t buy them anymore. I never use them because I find that the pigmentation is different (WAY INFERIOR TO THEIR REGULAR PRODUCTS). Also, I like to pick and choose individual colors that I like rather than ending up with a collection of colors I’ll never use but that I got stuck buying a quad/quint/etc just to get 1 or 2 other colors that weren’t sold separate.
      In my opinion, palettes are a rip off.

      • KyaLyn says:

        I try to avoid the ones where I only like/need 1 or 2 colors. Its just not worth it and there’s usually dupes out there somewhere as singles.
        I’m a little OCD so the fact that they are different sizes really frustrates me.

  5. Josie says:

    I hate that most come with a laughable sized eyeshadow brush…come on now…am I really going to use that pathetic brush?

  6. MACPixie55 says:

    Love and Hate. Love that they’re super cute and affordable. Hate that they’re reasonably priced at the time of year where I really CAN’T buy for myself.

  7. Nicole says:

    I hate holiday collections, because it’s nearly always the same. The packaging might be funkier or cooler, but thats not a purchase creteria. I like it simple, pure and clear.

  8. DevilishDoll says:

    I love that you can get 6 eyeshadows for a pretty good price. I usually go for the cool palettes, I have Royal Assets, and the cool pigments from this year. I love all of the colors. I have nothing bad to say about holiday collections.

  9. Vicki says:

    I hate that they come out when I’m poor. I usually spend my extra school money before then :(

  10. I like that they are usually glamorous with sparkle and very festive.

  11. emma says:

    i love that u get a lot of bang for ur buck. but i always end up wanting everything and i have to narrow it down!

  12. kaoru says:

    It depends on the brand whether I like the Holiday collections, or not. NARS, for instance, I like. You can pick and choose what you want from the collection. Palettes… well, in general, I don’t really like them. Maybe a quad, but even then that’s pushing it. There’s always a color that I don’t really like in them, and it feels like a waste. MAC’s mini collections, though, are great. If I don’t like the color (as long as it’s only 1), I buy the set anyway, and give that one away.

  13. Kristie says:

    I will not purchase any of MACS holiday palettes again after Royal Assets. The product they filled the 6 pans with were as poorly textured, as if I went to the drug store. I will not purchase the brush sets because they are also inferior. I like the pigments though! Its fun and more reasonable for me to get the smaller versions..

  14. samaya says:

    i like the collections, coz they are affordable and make good gfts..especially the value pack ones..
    i don’t like the palattes that have all lip color, blushes n e/s in tiny compartments…they just mess up later..many atimes one or two stuff is good, rest all is just not my taste….

  15. Dawn says:

    I usually love holiday collections because they are, for the most part, things that I havent seen or have. But this year I was a little disappointed in MAC because they put out the same brush sets as last year; the lip glasses were mostly permanent colors; the lipsticks werent really exciting in my opinion. But I do love my Warm Pigment set and my Warm Pallet. Still on the fence about getting the Cool Eyes pallet.

    The Dior Blue eye pallet is really beautiful but i cant afford it :(

  16. Vivian says:

    I hate the fact that they jack up palette’s price when economy is in a slump while the product itself remains the same or even less than before. I like the fact that palette is a good way of trying out colors from a brand I never thought about buying. Oh, I also hate how lots of high ends give out foam applicators again (and regular items too) – I’d rather have a mini hair brush.

  17. Ruth says:

    I’m fairly pleased with the Holiday Collections this year. I bought from Chanel, Guerlain, Lancome, MAC, Fusion Beauty, Calvin Klein, Bare Escentuals and Estee Lauder, so I did pretty good !

  18. Jenna says:

    I’m drawn to pretty packaging :D

  19. Erin says:

    I haven’t bought any holiday collections this year because of what so many other readers said — the quality is inferior. I thought about buying MAC Smokey Eyes, but I’d rather seek out similar permanent shadows even if the shades aren’t exactly the same.