Friday, June 5th, 2009

Project Revamp

If you could revamp MAC Fluidline Gel Eyeliner, what would you change? What would you keep the same? How would you make it an even better product?

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

34 thoughts on “Project Revamp: MAC Fluidline

  1. I would keep it the same but make it a kit with a mini eyeliner brush =]

  2. kat

    I would make it waterproof or smearproof…

  3. Roberta

    More colors would be amazing.

  4. Zoila


  5. DevilishDoll

    I agree with more colors and have it come with an eyeliner brush.

  6. Danitza Zarate

    More colors and with an eyeliner brush and a mirror also =)

  7. Danitza Zarate

    And also I would add something to make it longer stay in the eyes … for those who have no access to UDPP … or other primers .. like me 😛

  8. Mary

    I would make it more long-lasting.

  9. i don’t think i would change anything, it’s my hg eyeliner :)

  10. lina

    longer lasting, smear proof, more colors
    i don’t think it should come with a brush because i think a lot of people that use mac already have brushes and it would be a waste of money to pay for the cost of a brush every time you bought a fluidline

    • cmferrets

      yeah same here, theirs no need for a brush, i always hated products that come with brushes, they never are up to par.

  11. cloudburst

    I would make the container easier to open & close – I damn near sprained my wrist one time trying to open the thing. Also I would make the formula a bit creamier, so it glides on the brush more.

  12. Nicole15

    I would love if it was waterproof. I use a lid primer no matter what so i don’t have an issue with it smearing ever, but any tearing near the inner eye makes it disappear so H2O proof would be amazing!!!

  13. Andrea

    More colours and creamier for sure!!!

  14. Kay

    More colors!!! I’m always amazed that MAC has like 20 blushes, and come out with a new one almost with almost every special edition line, but has the same basic fluidlines all the time! Especially considering that most women are 20x more likely to be adventurous in trying new eyeliners than they are with trying new blush!!

  15. slick

    Another vote for more colors! Otherwise I’m pretty happy with Fluidlines 😉

  16. catherine

    Smear and water proof and that it would not dry out that fast !

  17. Taryn

    Put it in a hinged container like the old MAC cream liners. It’s a pain to unscrew the top each time.

    Someone to apply it for me would be nice too. I have small eyes to begin with and if I make the tiniest error, the line is way too wide and dwarfs my eyes.

  18. Samantha

    Waterproof, smudgeproof and change that deceiving container!!

  19. Yaya

    Yeah, it needs a perfect brush to make it easier to apply

  20. It dries out too quickly! I also think using the 266 uses up sooo much product!

  21. Faith

    I don’t like the glass container! I’m always afraid I’m going to drop it.

  22. cmferrets


  23. Wilcoa

    waterproof and in a less clunky container.

  24. More creamier so that it glides perfect on, but I do love them :-)

  25. elle

    It would come with a brush to apply it with, and there would be more colors. More colors that are flattering on dark skin tones.

  26. kristin

    I would halve both the size AND the price so I could use it up before it dried out, and so I could buy more colors :)

  27. muffingrl

    definitely more colors.
    i guess a waterproof version would be great for smudge-proof pool time!

  28. Yo

    a smaller size…mine dried out after a year and I’m not even half way through..

  29. Nunu

    Creamier, more colors! I forgot mine open for a day and it dried! Any way to fix this or is destined to be dumped? =[ stupid me

  30. Natalie

    More color rage like Bobbi Brown – a few different browns, etc

  31. Haley

    i would add a gold and bright blue shade!