I bought this for the color. I thought it would be great eyeliner for cool toned smoky eye, or even to pair with a red or pink, but I find this very difficult to use. It goes on very dry, which creates an uneven line. When I tried to compensate by smudging and going for a smokier line I found it is impossible to smudge out evenly, and goes entirely sheer. I love the idea of this pencil, but in practice it does not live up to expectations.
Looking for the perfect liner to complement the ever-popular UD smoky eye? This is it: an ultra-velvety, PLUSH version of our legendary 24/7 Eye Pencil. 24/7 Velvet Glide-On Eye Pencil is the ultimate tool for smudging. And it has the same long-lasting benefits as our 24/7 Eye Pencils. More powdery than our original 24/7 Eye Pencils, 24/7 Velvet blends easier to create soft, smoky edges. Use this pencil to get perfectly blended-out or rich, defined lines. 24/7 Velvet is the ultimate liner for doing a smoky, rimmed eye (or whenever you want a look that’s more matte and soft).