(I just wrote a review but as I'd rated it at the top right, I couldn't add my review; hopefully, I've removed my rating and can now review this). I am surprised by the F rating for this shadow because I love it and I guess part of the reason I love it is that it is on the sheer side, though I do find it is fairly buildable. The fact that it's on the sheer side makes this wearable for me in work situations (a more full-on purple might look a bit much in my work environment). I was so delighted that this pretty, "girlie" shade was included as a bit of a "counterpoint" to the otherwise neutral and flesh toned shadows in the Chocolate bar palette. I love everything about this shadow, including the "sheerness".