I snagged this palette off an Instagram seller for only $15, and boy am I glad! As much as I love the shades, the original review does reflect the formula: powdery. I know I’ll only be able to wear them with the Urban Decay primer (which will defiantly make it long wearing) to avoid any fading and creasing, which is my biggest problem and pet peeve with shadows. The one I received was highly pigmented, although some claimed to be sheer, none were a problem for me and were visible on my fingers at the first tap. However the pans are regular Too Faced size, and with being limited edition for the holidays you’d think they’d be just a bit wider. So that’s my only disappointment, too little of something so scarce!