This is probably my least favorite out of the 3 palettes but I still use it quite a bit! My favorite shades out of this palette are: Envious Erin (a creamy shimmer great for brow highlight), Safe Bet Annette (frosty pink, for the light part of a gradient to a dark pink or red), and the whole bottom row (the teal-y blue shade is super pigmented and bright, I love deep purples and I finally own a black shade!) Overall, this is a great deal, I'd stick with the first 2 volumes but if you score the 3 for 1 on theBalm's website, its worth it. All of them have a large mirror on the side opposite to the shadows and the pots seem to last forever! I haven't had a crumbling problem with these either despite all the traveling they've done.