Milk

NYX

Found an error? Let us know about it!

Milk Reviews

Leave a Review

You must be logged in to write a review, Sign Up or Login.

Filter Reviews By

Age Range

Eye Color

Hair Color

Hair Type

Hair Texture

Skin Tone

Skin Type

Undertone

Avatar of Sarah Sarah
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Neutral

Where do I begin? Before I purchased this I had previously been using the whole “white base” concept, but with another more expensive pencil that didn’t quite cut it. When I discovered this pencil, I swore I would never go back. There are so many amazing uses for this pencil that really do take your makeup to the next level. I use this over my UDPP when I use any bright shadows (specifically my Sugarpill eyeshadows) to add that extra oomph of vibrancy. You can blend it, or cake it on- either way this pencil just simply works.

PROS:
Beautiful Application
Can be used for a variety of things
Opaque
Can be blended out softly
Very well priced
Cruelty Free

CONS:
The lid can be cracked or broken easily
Make sure to leave the lid on or it will dry out!

1 out of 1 users found this review helpful
Was this review helpful? Yes No

Avatar of NoName NoName
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Yellow

Useful as both an eye shadow base and highlighter for under the brow bone.

PROS:
— Decent primer; eye shadows applied over it pop with color
— Has multiple uses
— Cheap

CONS:
— Creases
— Not the easiest to apply; you can’t just apply it straight from the pencil without doing some work to fix it up
— Difficult to sharpen and you lose product when you do.
— Gets very waxy in the heat.

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Avatar of Erin Erin
Milk
Skin Tone: Dark Tan, Skin Type: Normal-to-Dry, Undertone: Neutral

I love this base, it makes the colors that I wear pop so much more. The only, only, only issue I have is with ONE tube of the milk that I have that seems like it melted or something (which is weird as it was in a cool place) and applied on my eyes weird, and creased after. The other three or four tubes I have are fine, so I”m thinking it was just this one tube. May happen when the product is expired or maybe if it was in a warm place once, if it’s to warm.

Was this review helpful? Yes No

Avatar of Cristina Cristina
Milk
Skin Tone: Medium-Tan, Skin Type: Oily, Undertone: Neutral
Avatar of MC MC
Milk
Skin Tone: Light, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Yellow
Avatar of Lauren Lauren
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Very Dry, Undertone: Neutral
Avatar of adrianna adrianna
Milk
Skin Tone: Light-Medium, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Yellow
Avatar of Breanna Breanna
Milk
Skin Tone: Fairest, Skin Type: Normal-to-Dry, Undertone: Pink
Avatar of Kelsey Kelsey
Milk
Skin Tone: Light, Skin Type: Normal, Undertone: Neutral
Avatar of Kirsten Kirsten
Milk
Skin Tone: Fairest, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Neutral
Avatar of Emerald Emerald
Milk
Skin Tone: Light-Medium, Skin Type: Oily, Undertone: Olive
Avatar of Mariella Mariella
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Normal-to-Dry, Undertone: Pink
Avatar of Stacie Stacie
Milk
Skin Tone: Fairest, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Pink
Avatar of tzwiggy tzwiggy
Milk
Skin Tone: Light-Medium, Skin Type: Very Oily, Undertone: Neutral
Tags: Creases
Avatar of Barbie Barbie
Milk
Skin Tone: Medium, Skin Type: Very Dry, Undertone: Yellow
Avatar of Mai Mai
Milk
Skin Tone: Light-Medium, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Yellow
Avatar of anna anna
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Combination, Undertone: Pink
Avatar of Valene Valene
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Dry, Undertone: Pink
Avatar of Kenzie Kenzie
Milk
Skin Tone: Fair, Skin Type: Normal-to-Oily, Undertone: Neutral

The Glossover

Grade

A
(19)
Rate this product
Loading ... Loading ...

Product Information

  • Availability: Permanent
  • Finish: Matte
  • Color: White
  • Undertone: Cool

Temptalia Review

NYX Milk Jumbo Eye Pencil ($4.49 for 0.18 oz.) is a stark, cool-toned white with a matte finish. Maybelline Too Cool is shimmery. Buxom Sheep Dog is shimmery, less cool-toned. Make Up For Ever #32E is shimmery, warm-toned. Make Up For Ever #4 is shimmery. See comparison swatches.

Read the Full Review

The Dupe List

See More Dupes