My favorite dupe for upscale liners. Easy to blend when you put it on, but once it dries, it stays put all day and night.
-- Good quality
-- Blendable until it dries
-- Stays put all day
-- Terrible on the waterline; it makes my eyes irritated
I own four shades of this eyeliner, and plan to purchase more. While I love how creamy it is, and how pretty the colors are (the black shade is so nicely dark and glossy), it did fade and migrate on my eyelids -- Not to mention it stayed all of 30 seconds on my waterline. >:
Then again, NOTHING stays on my waterline short of gel eyeliner set with powder eyeshadow, so this eyeliner might be the perfect one for you if you don't have the annoying migration issue that I get with virtually every eyeliner on the market.
I love how creamy (it's REALLY creamy) and pigmented this eyeliner is--it's easy to smudge or use as a base for eyeshadow. The price point is very, very nice too. However, once I put this on my waterline my eyes started watering and getting red immediately. Ow ow ow. Apparently this has happened to a lot of other people too...not cool!