Make Up For Ever #16L Aqua Eyes Liner ($17.00) is a muted grass-green with yellow undertones and subtle darkened, grassy sheen. I find this shade of green to be particularly unique amongst eyeliner shades. Despite owning more eyeliner than eyes (ha, ha, not hard to do!), I don’t have a green quite like this. It’s green without being bright or dark. It’s almost muted but not exactly dull. This looks pretty with soft, warmer browns and plums as well as the more expected blues, greens, and teals.