I have been using this mascara since I was 15 years old and it is definitely one of my favorite L'Oreal products. It doesn't clump up my lashes or smudge under my eyes like other mascaras. It adds volume and length to my lashes and it's also VERY long lasting. Sometimes I have trouble getting it off. Overall I love this mascara!
A perfectly good mascara. The word 'voluminous' when attributed to a mascara seems like a synonym for 'clumpy' most of the time but not in this case! It's very defining which is an A+++ in my book. It doesn't give eyelashes that could be mistaken for falsies, the eyelashes still look natural, nothing particularly dramatic and if that's the look you're going for- this is perfect! I can't comment on smudging or flaking because I don't have that problem with any mascara.