I've been a fan of Benefit for many years, and this is currently still my favorite Benefit product ever. I have smallish, deeper set (?) eyelids, and I absolutely love using this 'chubby'-type pencil in various ways to open up my brown eyes and give them more 'pop'! I have used it to line my watermark and find the really light pink color softer in a very pretty way compared to lining them with a white eyeliner.
Other ways I use this:
-To blend in near the inner corners of my eyes (to highlight)
-To line just above my upper lashes
-Below outer brow line for contour
-Over whole eyelid (blended very well!)
It glides on smoothly for me and does not dry out quickly. One stick will last me at least 6 mos. with nearly daily use, so I the price is reasonable for me and a little goes a long way!
This a product you either love or hate--which one will depend on the climate of where you happen to live, or season of the year in temperate regions. Wax based formula is very temperature dependent in how well it performs: in summer time it glides on and melts into skin performing as it should--brightening and highlighting (with subtle shimmer). Come fall and Eye Bright turns into a hard milky-pink crayon that will not lay down the product, and you can forget about blending!
I personally use this as brow bone highlight, which means I could have bought Benefit "High Brow" w/ twice the product for same price. Sharpen when chilled, use warm for best results, blend w/ clean fingers to help melt the product. Nice to have but not life changing--pricey for what it does, i.e. try before you buy.