New & Shiny vs. Old & Done
With some of the recent launches from various brands, we have seen previously released shades (whether permanently or previously limited edition) launched again in the latest seasonal collection. This is not a new concept–brands often rotate in permanent products to promote alongside new seasonal shades or bring back a shade from the past that matches the latest theme. I’m curious to know what side you’re on, though, because there definitely seems to be a divide.
On one hand, when a brand brings back an old shade, it’s an opportunity for those who missed out on the shade originally to try it out. It also is one less product to worry about fitting into the budget or figuring out if it’s something you really want–it’s old news! But on the other hand, are repromotes a sign of a lapse in creativity?
Is the question whether a repromote is adored or loathed more about whether it was a big deal when it first came out? Would you rather the brand tweak the shade imperceptibly and give it a new name instead? With so many new products releasing each month, is it really a bad thing that we see a few shades come back?
This post was prompted by some of the comments on MAC’s “new” Mineralize Eyeshadow Duos being nearly identical to previously released Mineralize Eyeshadow Trios. I imagine with the level of duplicability that it is not mere coincidence but intentional, and with that in mind, it seems like they would do so to fill gaps in the existing line by bringing these in or because they did so well initially that it made sense to make them permanent.
In general, I don’t mind repromotes, even if the shades weren’t coveted the first time they released. I’d rather they re-release than take nearly the same color and give it a different name. I like that it gives others the opportunity to try an old favorite, too. I don’t like when a brand pretends like it’s new when it is from the past, though. I also don’t want to see the same shade brought back as “limited edition” over and over and over again (MAC Showstopper, I’m talking to you!).
I can also see where readers are coming from re: Urban Decay palettes, which often re-use the same shades year after year. I know I have more Half-Baked and Baked eyeshadows than I’ll ever need–for five lifetimes. I actually kind of enjoy when a brand highlights great permanent shades within a seasonal launch, because sometimes we get caught up in all things limited edition that we forget brands even have permanent ranges!
How do you feel about repromotes?
Givenchy Demesure Audacious Lashes for Fall 2011
Nicolas is overflowing with imagination and is always ready to venture beyond bounardies. Today he reveals his own professional secrets to interminable lashes with staggering volume. The new Givenchy mascara, the mascara that is superlative in all aspects, bears his signature: DEMESURE, Audacious Lashes. This High Tech accessory at the cutting edge of innovation combines an extensible brush and a finishing tool. An exnclusive hyaluronic acid-based formula adds volume to the base of lashes without weighing down thetips. A super-audacious product for extravagant, breathtaking volume.
Generously coat lashes, wrap them in the material like you would a luxurious black sheat. Shape lashes one by one with an ultra thin accessory for a singular definition. It took two years of intensive research to finally create this exceptional item: the first three dimensional telescopic brush.
To create density: the volumising shaft has 16 inlaid grooves which serve as reservoirs for material. Each time it is dipped in the vial, they are engorged with mascara so that the base of eyelashes is covered with a thick coating on application.
To define: enclosed in the shaft, a totally clean elastomer separating brush is released by activating the base of the cap. Its cone shape guarantees ease of use combined with ultra-precision. The finishing tool gives the ultimate touch of precision. Its finesse provides a customized, unequalled, lash-by-lash result.
Three shades: Audacious Black, Audacious Brown, Audacious Green (which is limited edition).
availability: Fall/Winter 2011
See more photos!
There are a few ingredients I watch for, but they tend to be in skincare or blushes. I wish I had the mental capacity to keep track of more ingredients, but it’s overwhelming!
Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.
- Sometimes, but never as well as they claim!
- No way!
- Yes, definitely!
- Other - I'll tell you in the comments!
Total Voters: 3,303
Feel free to elaborate on your answer in the comment section! 🙂
Thanks to Meme for today’s poll!
From top left: This & That, Sage & Wisdom, Heaven & Earth, Mix & Switch, Pretty & Prim, Thunder & Rain
MAC Mineralize Eyeshadow Duos (2011) vs. In the Groove Mineralize Eyeshadow Trios
As speculated in my review, the new duos (which I’m still waiting to get official word on re: release date for in-stores, how long they’ll be available for, etc.) are definitely reincarnations of the trios from In the Groove. Five of the six duos correspond with a trio, while one duo requires taking a shade from two different trios to match–but for the most part, they are all quite similar. All swatches are applied wet (using water to dampen).
- This & That is a duo that I had to take a shade from two different trios. The ivory side in This & That is warmer than the ivory in Cool, Calm, Collected. The beige side in This & That is indistinguishable from the beige (middle strip) in Making It Easy.
- Mix & Switch compares closely to Making It Easy. The lighter peach side looks about the same in both. The coppery shade in Mix & Switch is more orange-based than in Making It Easy, which is a little browner and redder.
- Sage & Wisdom is incredibly similar to Cool, Calm, Collected. I couldn’t tell the difference between the two in terms of color. The darker shade swatches slightly better in Sage & Wisdom than in Cool, Calm, Collected.
- Heaven & Earth is a near perfect match to Blue My Mind. The blue in Heaven & Earth is slightly more pigmented and looks a little deeper, but they are very much the same, as are the two black shades.
- Thunder & Rain matches Togetherness well–the purples are indistinguishable from each other, while the silver in Thunder & Rain applies smoother than the one in Togetherness, but the colors are about the same.
- Pretty & Prim is quite similar to Fresh & Easy. The lighter pink seems a little yellower in Pretty & Prim compared to Fresh & Easy, but the darker berry shade seems the same. I had several readers ask how Pretty & Prim compared to Band of Roses, but the two are from different planets – not at all similar.