MAC Lipsticks: Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, Victorian, Colour Me Coral
MAC Spring Colour Forecast: Lipsticks Reviews, Photos, Swatches (Part 2)
And I bring you part two… and the LAST of all of Spring Colour Forecast reviews. Now, I’m going to go pass out. Or something!
Spring Colour 2 Forecast — Lipsticks
- Rose Maiden is a brightened up red-berry with a frosty finish and sheen. It applies nearly opaque on lips.
- Fresh Salmon is a medium salmon pink with a golden shimmer and lustre finish. When applied, the golden sheen is really apparent.
- Victorian is a bright pop of cool-toned pink with a golden sheen. It kind of reminded me of my new favorite pink, Guerlain Giulette, but it’s much cooler. When applied, this goes on mostly opaque and almost looks and feels creamy.
- Colour Me Coral is a light coral with some beige in it and a frost finish. With its frost finish, it does have a tendency to look too frosty on lips, but with a creamy gloss–say Ember Glow–I think it’ll be just fine.
Spring Colour 4 Forecast — Lipsticks
- Beigeland is a semi-sheer, shimmery pink-beige with almost a metallic sheen. It’s a frost finish, and I think it applies a bit unevenly alone, so it’s something that needs to be used with a lip brush or else finished with a gloss.
- Bronzilla is a reddened bronze with a very metallic sheen. Like Beigeland, it’s also a frost finish lipstick, but it reads more metallic. I found it applied better than Beigeland for evenness, but I’d personally layer a gloss on top to make it really pop and work in a look.
See product photos and swatches!
Spring Colour 2 Forecast — Lipsticks
MAC Lipsticks: Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, Victorian, Colour Me Coral
MAC Lipsticks: Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, Victorian, Colour Me Coral
MAC Lipsticks: Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, Victorian, Colour Me Coral
MAC Lipsticks: Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, Victorian, Colour Me Coral
MAC Rose Maiden Lipstick
MAC Rose Maiden Lipstick
MAC Fresh Salmon Lipstick
MAC Fresh Salmon Lipstick
MAC Victorian Lipstick
MAC Victorian Lipstick
MAC Colour Me Coral Lipstick
MAC Colour Me Coral Lipstick
Spring Colour 4 Forecast — Lipsticks
MAC Beigeland Lipstick
MAC Bronzilla Lipstick
MAC Lipstick: Beigeland, Bronzilla
MAC Beigeland Lipstick
MAC Beigeland Lipstick
MAC Bronzilla Lipstick
MAC Bronzilla Lipstick
The colors are beautiful…the collection is sooo huge…I am overwhelmed…
Thanks for all the swatches and reviews.
Wow! Great job on the reviews!! Loving the Colour Me Coral lipstick!
I was really exited for Victorian, but I’m not so sure about how it would look on me now that I look at it on lips
I guess I’ll have to check it out in person.
O_O Usually I am not impressed with MAC’s LE lipstick launches but wow, I so want Rose Maiden and Fresh Salmon and I am actually totally serious. So, so gorgeous! I’ve kind of stopped wearing MAC lipsticks though since my Laura Mercier stickglosses just treat my lips so much better. But omg, so pretty!!
fresh salmon is adorable!
I love Rose Maiden and Fresh Salmon, and quite like Colour Me Coral and Bronzilla too.
Now I want Victorian too. Oh God.
Wants Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon, and Colour me Coral!
love the l/s.
Christine you put so much work and time into reviewing and swatching this collection! thank you so much for that. This collection is so unique it will be impossible to pass on
lol
Happy to help out
Hi Christine why does Victorian look like Bubblegum in these pics?
They look very, very different to me… one is pink with gold sheen, one is distinctly lilac/has pretty clear purple tones to it (rather than being pink).
I have never liked so many!!! fresh salmon and color me coral are beautifuL! but i liked them all.. this sucks, i can’t buy all these:-p
Rose Maiden, Fresh Salmon Lipstick, Bronzilla Lipstick so beautiful!!! think must have!!!
I’m glad that the frost lipsticks – Victorian and Rose Maiden, aren’t as frosty as they their finish would otherwise indicate! Such pretty shades…I was kinda hoping some wouldn’t be so great so I wouldnt try to buy all of them….fail!
Wow! In the photos, Fresh Salmon looks a lot like lollipop loving! Are they really anything similar? I’ve been hitting myself for not buying that one!
Fresh Salmon is brighter, a little more of a pink, and it doesn’t have the green duochrome that Lollipop Loving has!
I don’t know why, but Bronzilla is CALLING MY NAME! Must have! It’s making me dream of summer. And Rose Maiden swatches so lovely on your lips! I’m not sure how it would look on me though….hmm…I’ll add it to the “maybe” list. :p
Fresh Salmon and Victorian are my favourites in this bunch!
I was thinking the same!
Oh no I intended to get Victorian but your swatch is so different to the hand swatch on specktra. Love Fresh Salmon (& it’s lustre yay) and Bronzilla
Wow, you’re so fast! I like a lot of the pinks and I’ll skip Bronzilla and Beigeland
Fresh Salmon is miiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiine!
omg! maybe it’s because i’m sick of the gloomy winter weather, but i’m so excited about this collection! i will most definitely get fresh salmon! it’s gorgeous! and i just might get rose maiden.
I love bronzilla.
I want Colour Me Coral and Beigeland!!! I think Victorian is beautiful but it doesn’t work on my skin tone I would look cartoonish lol=)
It’s such a shame they put metallic sparkles in everything. I’d have loved Fresh Salmon if it was a cream. For such a huge collection I’m finding it very skippable. I like the colour Malibu Peach NP… but I know Essie do similar colours that are probably better quality.
Maybe I’ve just got makeup fatigue!
Makeup fatigue? SAY IT ISN’T SO!
Hey Christine, Do you think that Rose Maiden is anything like New York Apple? And do you think that Fresh Salmon is anything like CB96?
Brighter, more like a coral-red in a sense. And nah, nothing like CB96 on me!
Hi again Christine, is Bronzilla anything like Shag or that Spiced Tea from the Warm & Cozy collection?
Hmm, more bronzy, more metallic than Spiced Tea – more metallic and not so frosty, you know? I can’t remember what Shag looks like at all at the moment, lol!
I think your lip swatches are one of my favorite things you do – SO helpful and I really appreciate it! I mean, am I crazy, or does Fresh Salmon look like it could be a half-decent substitute for Gems when I run out of it? It’s very, very pretty at any rate and I want it either way, but if it satisfies my desire for gold-laced pinky coral I will be very happy
I also LOVE Rose Maiden, even though I don’t generally get excited about frosts. I’ll have to see about picking it up. Will have to do some depotting so I can B2M for some of these and save $$!
Aww, thank you, Daphne!!
I am so glad you like them! It’s not a bad substitute, though I don’t think it’s quite like Gems, LOL! But nothing really is… you know the magic of Gems!
Sigh! I know, right? Trying to focus on the fact that it is a lovely lipstick in and of itself and I want it for that reason. Because really, no more $30+ lipsticks for me after Gems and my two Rouge Allure Laques.
LOL! That’s what you say… but how long will you last?!
Shhh! Don’t taunt me! Anyway, I said $30+. That still allows me plenty of Glossimers, KissKiss glosses, Aqualumiere lipsticks…:P
How similar are bronzilla and beigeland to high tea?
Beigeland is beiger/fleshier than High Tea, and Bronzilla isn’t like it at all, IMO!
Beigeland looks so good on your lips.I am thinking about buying that one.
Thanks, Monika!
Do you think Made with love l/s from Colour craft collection is a good alternative to Fresh Salmon? Or any other possible lipsticks that are similar..I am on a budget and trying to cut my list down a bit.
Kind of. It’s much lighter and maybe not as salmon pink and more medium pink.
Fresh Salmon seems similar to “Lollipop Lovin” or is my LCD screen just throwing the color off?
It completely lacks the green duochrome shimmer that makes Lollipop Lovin’ so unique! I’d personally say Fresh Salmon is a brighter pink, too!
I love lollipop loving… so I guess that means I’m getting fresh salmon AND colour me coral. I’m loving everything coral and peach and gold lately… This collection is perfect for my mood lately
Corals = love!
Salmon looks like a safely beautiful bet, but victorian looks tasty for bold looks. Victorian seems like it could look amazing or be a total mess, but sometimes you have to go out on a limb and take a chance.
Victorian looks absolutely divine! I should have bought that one last night!
hmmm…aaahhh christine i thought i was over the lipsticks, and now i’m starting to consider victorian and fresh salmon…! though i’d have to swatch them to be sure about frost levels…sometimes the frosty shades just don’t work for me…they make me look like an aunty, if you know what i mean.
I was wondering does Beigeland look anything similar to 1N lipstick?
Thanks for all the review and swatches, it always helps me out with the colors.
Is Bronzilla close to the slimshine Cocoamour?
Cocoamour was pretty brown on me from what I remember, but it’s been awhile since I’ve really swatched it!
I’m probably asking the same question others have in a different way, but does Fresh Salmon end up looking coral-y on the lips or more of a true pink? I’m trying to decide between Color Me Coral (which looks maybe too light and frosty for me), Bronzilla (maybe too 80s on me?) and Fresh Salmon. I think I’ve decided on Kumquat lipglass, if it’s not too bright. I recently got Lush and Bright and it is gorgeous, but too glittery for my 40 year old self!
Fresh Salmon tends to look more pinky on me, though still not straight pink or anything. I like Fresh Salmon the most out of the three you mentioned.
I know for sure I want the lady gaga viva glam. The pink color seems pretty close to victorian or bubblegum. Would you think I’d be safe skipping since I’m getting the gaga one? Just from pics you have seen of the gaga viva glam–I know you haven’t swatched yet. Thanks so much
I think Bubblegum might have a different shimmer and more of a lilac-y shade. Really hard to tell without swatching (and see the pigmentation).
Do you have pictures of the actual Gaga and Cyndi VG lipsticks up now?
No, I don’t have them, sorry.
Hi Christine, how do you think fresh salmon compares to see sheer? Are they quite similar? Thanks!
Pinker, not so coral, shimmer!
I went into MAC Pro last Friday and I asked about the Colour Forecast items. They didn’t have them out yet (the MUA told me they were coming this coming Wednesday??) but anyways, she still took me to the back and let me swatch the items so I was super excited. I was looking foward to Bubblegum the most.. which looks kind of like a mix between a lighter version of Up The Amp and sort of like Lavender Whip.. But I’m definitely stocking up on them. I tried Victorian too because I really liked your swatches of it and I liked how it looked “non-frosty” even though it’s a frost.. but it looked like a salmon-y pink to me.. was it like that for you as well?? I was bummed that I couldn’t get any of the new items but I’ll come back this week.. I got some lipmixes and other pro lipsticks instead! So excited
Christine
What color to the permanent line would you say victorian is like?
Based on your lip swatches it sort of reminds me of how Angel looks on my lips.
What do you think?
None, to be honest. At best, it’s similar to See Sheer, but I think they’re pretty different!
Angel doesn’t look anything like Victorian on me, IMO!
My MACpro card was renewed in store and my new card hasn’t come yet. Does the pro discount apply to this collection? I can’t sign in to the website yet and it’s KILLING me. ALSO, how do you think the peach ombre will look on olive complections? CANNNOT WAIT TO BUY IT.
Ok, good! And thanks!
I just ordered it, Fresh Salmon, and Pink Burst.
Thanks for the great review Christine.
I tried on every lipstick. LOL. Came away with a nice every day one, Fresh Salmon, and a more colourful one, Rose Maiden.
I’m glad you found two to love, Ember
Do you think Fresh Salmon can look like Surprise Me?
They’re not the same on me, but if you have more red in your lips, maybe…
Thank you, I love how it looks on you, but I see some other swatches that they look so alike.
Now I know I have to get Victorian. It’s looked so great and versatile in the looks you’ve done with this collection!
Hey Christine just wondering do yo think color me coral is kind of the same as lolipop loving from the sugar sweet collection just in a different finish?
It doesn’t have the green cast of Lollipop Loving, IMO!
Can someone please tell me a dupe for Victorian or a similar colour by MAC?… it’s sold out:(
Try Speed Dial or Bombshell… it’s about as close as you’ll get, I think!
how about a dupe for Fresh Salmon (minus the glitter)? thanks christine!
There’s no dupe that I know of
Are there any dupes for Mac Fresh Salmon that you know of? Is Nars Niagra close?