MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad Review, Photos, Swatches (RiRi Hearts MAC)

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad ($44.00 for 0.19 oz.) is a new and limited edition palette from the upcoming RiRi Hearts MAC (Fall Edition) that launches at MAC stores on September 26th, online on September 30th, and counters and international locations on October 3rd.

Edited at 9/18 at 10:24AM PST: It features four eyeshadows, and the eyeshadows do not have names (only the actual quad has a name). Originally, the shades were listed with working names (so they are not finalized and often serve as placeholders). When I wrote the review, I swatched each shade to the corresponding working name (because they were permanent shades) to try to determine if, in fact, they were the same. I’ve kept that information below, but I wanted to update and clarify based on information I received this morning. I also received official shade descriptions and corresponding finishes, which I’ve added to the shades below.

To that end, I swatched each supposedly permanent shade against the individual, permanent eyeshadow I had previously (some of mine are quite old, so you may find quality differences even when colors are similar). I’ve included these swatches below for your reference. The only one that was wildly different was Smoked Cocoa #1, which was listed as Shroom–it is much, much cooler-toned and lighter. My Copperplate (which is from the original release of the Matte2 formula, so several years ago) is darker/more pigmented than Smoked Cocoa #2–the texture of my original definitely had a more buttery, silky feel, but they looked nearly identical when I compared the pans.

Smoked Cocoa #1 is described as a “dirty cool champagne [with a Veluxe Pearl finish].” It is a cool-toned, off white with a frosted finish. It had fairly good color payoff, and it applied smoothly and evenly. It lasted well for eight hours before showing signs of fading. MAC Winterscape is similar. MAC Star Crystal is a touch pinker. MAC Creamy Bisque is less frosted. See comparison swatches.

Smoked Cocoa #2 is described as a “muted mid-tone grey [with a Matte2 finish].” It’s a neutral-cool taupe with a matte finish. It had a soft, finely-milled texture but was noticeably less silky compared to my original Copperplate eyeshadow (which this was listed as in my information), and as a result, Smoked Cocoa #2 appeared lighter when swatched side-by-side, though in the pans they both looked the same. It applied easily and blended out well. This wore well without showing signs of fading until nine hours of wear. Maybelline Tough as Taupe is grayer and a cream product. bareMinerals Rowdy is cooler-toned. See comparison swatches.

Smoked Cocoa #3 is described as a “black with silver pearl [with a Lustre finish].” It is a darkened matte black base with fine silver sparkle and shimmer. This could be a number of eyeshadows, and it could very well be Black Tied as it was originally listed as, since Black Tied is essentially a matte black base with silver sparkle. If it’s any consolation, my permanent pan of Black Tied is even worse. The quality of this shade was horrendous; it was dry, patchy, and incredibly sheer. It was a total pain to apply and blend out on the lid. It seemed faded after seven hours. There are so many of these types of shades on the market, and the main way they differ is that some are more pigmented than others. See comparison swatches.

Smoked Cocoa #4 is described as a “dirty black charcoal [with a Satin finish].” It is a bluish black, so it looks almost gray at times, but it is still quite a dark shade. It looked really deep in the pan, but this did not translate in application as the pigmentation was very, very weak. The texture is dry, stiff, and a total pain in the behind to use. It didn’t want to apply smoothly, and blending this shade out took far more patience than I had. It looked noticeably faded after six hours of wear. There was a very fine hint of navy micro-shimmer in the shade that I didn’t really catch in my permanent pan of Nehru, so while I think they are certainly similar (especially when applied–those micro-shimmers never show up!), they may not be the same shade. MAC Fashion Legend is darker, less blue. LORAC Black is darker. MAC Typographic is grayer, matte. bareMinerals Amnesia is darker. See comparison swatches.

MAC Eyeshadow Quad Smoked Cocoa
F
Product
5
Pigmentation
5
Texture
5.5
Longevity
7.5
Application
3.5
Total
59%
MAC Eyeshadow Smoked Cocoa #1
A-
Product
9
Pigmentation
9
Texture
9
Longevity
8.5
Application
5
Total
90%
MAC Eyeshadow Smoked Cocoa #2
A-
Product
9
Pigmentation
8.5
Texture
9
Longevity
9
Application
5
Total
90%
MAC Eyeshadow Smoked Cocoa #3
F
Product
2
Pigmentation
2
Texture
2.5
Longevity
6.5
Application
2
Total
33%
MAC Eyeshadow Smoked Cocoa #4
F
Product
0
Pigmentation
1.5
Texture
2
Longevity
6
Application
2
Total
26%

See more photos & swatches!

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #1 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #1 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #2 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #2 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #3 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #3 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #4 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa #4 Eyeshadow

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
Shroom vs. Smoked Cocoa #1

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
Copperplate vs. Smoked Cocoa #2

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
Black Tied vs. Smoked Cocoa #3

MAC Smoked Cocoa Eyeshadow Quad
Nehru vs. Smoked Cocoa #4

Write a Review

Reader Reviews

4.1
5 Stars
11
4 Stars
9
3 Stars
7
2 Stars
1
1 Stars
1

Based on 2 Reviews, 27 Quick Reviews

Rate It:
The Good
  • Easy To Apply (8)
  • Long-wearing (6)
  • Easy To Use (6)
  • Travel-friendly (5)
  • Versatile (4)
  • Buttery (3)
  • Great Gift (2)
  • Creamy (2)
  • Great Value (2)
The In-Between
  • Buildable (6)
  • Highly Pigmented (6)
  • Sheer (2)
The Bad
  • Fall Out (5)
  • Dry (3)
  • Powdery (3)
  • Fades (2)
  • Hard To Blend (2)
  • Too Little Product (1)
  • Hard To Apply (1)