Wednesday, November 26th, 2008


Distinguished, Identity, Monodramatic, Posh Life

OVERALL, Monogram offers a nice selection of lipglosses and lipsticks, but you can probably skip the rest! This year’s lipgloss formula is very similar to Dazzleglasses–both the chunkier shimmer (dazzle!) and the nonsticky formula really make them similar. They do not feel like the formulas they used in Couture or Stylistics (unfortunately for me). I picked up one gloss (Identity), but I wasn’t sold on it, which just made me sad, because I look forward to the luxe lipglosses every year. I did like the lipsticks more this year, even though the packaging felt cheap and plasticky (despite looking like “gold”). The pigmentation was good, none of the colors were overly frosty, and the shades are suitable for most people. I ended up getting All Mine and Flourish–I admit, I do not need another red, but I picked up because I seem to get every luxe red, so why not? I passed on the Sheer Mystery Powder, as I already have one from last year that never gets used. The Sheerspark powders were like past years–so utterly disappointing for me. I really wish MAC would replace the Sheersparks with something else–they just never seem to be a huge hit with most addicts I’ve talked to (including me!). I find them not pigmented enough to use as blushes/shadows and the glitter is too chunky to be a highlighter. I’m so pleased to see the Air of Style perfume housed in a much more practical bottle this year. I purchased last year’s version, which has cool packaging, but the perfume cannot stand up at all, which means it stays in its box and out of reach.

You can find collection details and photos in past posts.

Read my detailed review…

Lipstick

  • Flourish is a deep holiday red that’s not too bright. It has some shimmer/frost to it, but not too much. I might even compare it to Queen’s Sin in some ways, though not as bright. I hope I remember to compare it later on.
  • All Mine is a medium blue-based pink that I imagine will look great with Identity or Posh Life lipgloss from the launch. Lots of pigmentation and the formula itself is very creamy.
  • Marque is a light pinky beige color. It is the sheerest of the four lipsticks, but it still has more pigmentation than the average nude lipstick.
  • Status Symbol is a rich, warm brown with low shimmer and good sheen.

Lipgloss

  • Posh Life is a bright medium pink, almost a deeper, brighter pink. It has pretty gold flecks in it.
  • Identity is a pastel pink with gold shimmer. Good pigmentation for a light pink gloss.
  • Distinguished is a milky nude-beige gloss with subtle gold shimmer. It’s a pretty sheer gloss.
  • Monodramatic is a warm, deep chocolate bronzy brown with gold glitter.

Sheerspark Powder

  • Commemorate is a gritty/chunky glittery product that doesn’t have much color other than some shimmer.
  • Keepsake has the same texture as Commemorate, and to be honest, the color showed up little to none at all. It looked almost the same as Commemorate.
  • Personal Touch [I didn't get to review this--my MAC store did not get this in.]
  • Old English [I didn't get to review this--my MAC store did not get this in.]

Sheer Mystery Powder is a silky, lightweight pressed powder housed in a heavy “gold” compact. I did find the compact bulky (the product itself looks so small housed within that huge compact!), but the weight was a turn off, too. Like last year’s, it weighs somewhere in the same realm, I would say. You do get a refill, for those cautious of the $50 price tag.

Air of Style is just like last year’s–only way better packaged. Makes me wish I had waited! You can read my full review of the scent here.

Limited Edition Brushes [I didn't get to review these--my MAC store did not get this in.]

Monogram Clutch is so small! I couldn’t believe how small it looked. I didn’t touch or feel it, but I saw it in the display dome. It can’t be more than six inches wide. I wasn’t drawn to it; looked a little cheap to me.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

31 thoughts on “MAC Cosmetics Monogram Collection Review

  1. Tekoa

    Can’t wait to check out the perfume! The bottle last year was so silly. Might also get the Mystery Powder even if the packaging is irksome.

  2. Vee

    I’ve got a Sheerspark from last year and I don’t think I’ve ever used it, though I adored the Stylistics packaging. I might try layering it overtop of liquid eyeliner to make it sparkly but not over-power the line with colour…

  3. victoria

    aww what a bummer, i was thinking i’d be convinced by the packaging but that’s okay. at least i can save my money for better things. thanks so much for the review, christine, this helps a lot. i don’t think i have the chance to check it out this weekend.

      • victoria

        you’re right christine, i finally checked it out today. the sheersparks were the same as last years. i think the mystery powders are smaller than last years, it says 5g only where as last year’s the pans were the same size as blot powders. i wasn’t too impressed with the packaging in person as well, i think it’s just me, i had higher expectations or maybe it was the size of the pans that turned me off. to me the size of the pans doesn’t justify the price even if there’s an extra refill. if anything i would say the lippies.

  4. Those lip glosses look gorgeous!!

  5. Lauren

    What do you think of Identity? you said you did not really like it. For what Reasons?

  6. are the Sheerspark Powder worth it? i can’t decide if i should get them.

  7. Hope you & yours have a beauty full Thanksgiving!

  8. Lauren

    I keep forgetting its thanksgiving. We celebrated a while back! Have a great Thanksgiving everyone:) Enjoy time with your friends and family!

  9. Tanya

    I bought one of the brushes last year. The big one that is like a blush brush. I cannot speak highly enough of this brush. Its sooooo soft and I use it every day! I love the beautiful handle and would buy this years version in a heartbeat if I wasnt trying to save money. I would pass on most of the make-up in this line but the perfume and the brushes are well worth the money.

    • The 129? The 129 is definitely lovely. I picked up the Stylistics version last year, too, and it’s my favorite brush for blush. This year’s is pretty, but I’m glad I got the Stylistics – the ornate handle is so nice.

  10. kleri

    Thanks so much for your review. Did you have a change to see charming
    garnet kit? I am thinking of getting it for the 181 brush and the belightful powder.

    • To be honest, I totally skipped past it. The 181 brush is nice, though I still prefer the 182 — but if you have the 182 and want something smaller, 181 works well. I know some LOVE Belightful, but it has never shown up on me as more than some shimmer so I keep passing it up.

  11. Susanne

    Posh Life looks gorgeous! That one and a Sheerspark Pressed Powder for me! :)

  12. Kate

    Are the compacts for the Sheerspark Pressed Powder metal or plastic? If plastic, I’m going to pass. Thanks, Christine!

  13. Sarah

    I got the sheerspark powder in keepsake and two lipglosses; distinguished and identity online soon as they came out.

    i need some help though!

    i read somewhere that the sheerspark powder compact is refillable with any mac blush shade! is that true, the compact’s pan seems a bit on the small side to fit a blusher (you can tell i’ve never owned a mac blush (beauty powders and msfs yes, but not blush).

    i hate keepsake, but the compact’s cute enough, if it could be filled with a pretty shade like ambering rose or something..

    question is;

    can i refill?

    or will an e/s fit better?

    help a girl out please!

  14. Sarah

    thanks for replying christine. :)
    what a shame! a complete waste of money if it’s non-refillable. i’m going to try hassling a MUA at a mac store and see if they can help me find something suitably sized anyway.

  15. Sarah

    hi, really old post i know and a long buried topic;
    BUT
    the monogram sheerspark powder compacts ARE refillable!

    yaaayy!

    mine now has fabulush ccb housed in it and i love it so much! wheee!
    (i need a life, i know.. but oh what joy!)