We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!
  • Lord & Taylor30% off almost everything + 10% off cosmetics & fragrances with code FRIENDS, ends 12/15.
  • Tarte30% off with code BESTIES, ends 12/11.

Do you have a question idea? Submit yours here.

We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. Thanks!

31 Comments

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the post above for information regarding pricing, availability, dupes, and availability, and keep discussion on-topic. If you have general feedback, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

Comments on this post are closed.

I don’t really have a preference when it comes to amount of shades, but I like there to be some sort of cohesion in the layout of the shades. I don’t usually “follow” the layout, but on days I’m in a rush, or just being lazy, I don’t always want to think about what to wear, or scan the entire palette to see what works together.

* Something like the Kat von D or WnW 8-pans are ideal, as they are actually set up as 2 “quads”, but all 8 can be used together in any combination. The same as the Tarte 10-pans, which are set up as 4 “quads”.

totally depends on the purpose of the palette. Does this refer to a palette we put together with our own shadows? Or does it refer to shadow collections and themed shadow palettes?

I don’t generally buy single eyeshadows because I think palettes are a better value, and most of my palettes have nine to twelve shadows in them. I think that’s a good number for a good mix of colors and finishes; you could probably do less than twelve, honestly, but I like the palettes I have. (Naked 2, Balm Jovi, Shady Lady vol 1-3, and an Inglot 10-pan)

Maybe just 4. Chanel ” 4 Ombres “, YSL Pure Chromatics, Kiko eyeshadow palettes, Cargo, M.A.C quads, etc.. Except for Urban Decay I prefer quads.

I prefer between 2-4, actually. I don’t like too many shades in one palette because there’s bound to be some colors that I don’t use up as much as the others.

I rather like using all the colors of a palette in a look, so I like palettes with 4-5 or 6 eye shadows. Ones with 5 are optimal if one of the colors is very dark and can also be used as eyeliner.

Hm, I would agree with that, actually. As long as the variety is there – especially in finishes! – so looks can vary. Nothing puts me off a palette over 4 colours more than nothing but frosty, shimmery finishes. The colours can be as drop-dead gorgeous as they want, but if I’m going to have to pick up another palette to create something other than a shimmerbomb… um. No.

This doesn’t apply to palettes that are SPECIFICALLY made with a finish in mind – Sleek’s Matte palettes come to mind – because they’re aiming for that and that’s fine. But if it’s not a specific part of the theme of the palette, it just freakin’ bugs me.

I agree that getting a few more colors or even well-chosen colors is nice. Palettes tend to be full of shimmery, frosty colors and for everyday wear sometimes you need a good matte highlight or crease shade and many are lacking.

At least 6. I like to have 2 crease colours, 2 highlight colours and 2 lid colours. More is fine and always nice to have. I try to gravitate to palettes that have a variety. For my brows I like browns.

I kinda feel like there are two different types of palettes: single look and multiple look.

In single look palettes, eye shadows are conveniently grouped to be used together for a particular look (like in most MAC quads and I’ve made my own quads of some of my favorite combos) and, for me, four to six would be the best number of eye shadows.

Multiple look palettes are things like the recent Urban Decay Vice palette that have a broad range of eye shadows to be used in different combinations. For a multi look palette, I’d want at least ten shadows but preferably more.

I like anywhere from 3-6. I’m terrible at coordinating shadows, so I like it when a palate does it for me. If you have too many colors, then I don’t know what to pair with what. Boo hoo! T_T

I don’t really like big palettes, I feel like 8 is a good number of shades per palette. That way you get variety but it still generally follows a theme. I feel like a palette with more than 12 shades can get a little bit too scattered, color wise.

I think I like around six, that’s enough to offer variety and express any theme. My Urban Decay Book of shadows arrived yesterday (yay!) and whilst I like all the colours, the size of it is absurd. But at the same time I don’t get the point of duos and trios, they’re giving you the risk you won’t like one of the colours whilst not offering a lot of variety.

Subscribe

Join our newsletter and never miss a post!