Choose or Lose: What color of mascara do you prefer?

Date: Wednesday, October 8th, 2008 Author:

What color of mascara do you prefer?

  • Black (89%, 648 Votes)
  • Brown (7%, 53 Votes)
  • Colored (4%, 31 Votes)

Total Voters: 732

Feel free to elaborate on your answer in the comment section!

11 thoughts on “Choose or Lose: What color of mascara do you prefer?

  1. Trisha says:

    I’m a slave to black mascara, I really am. It’s very hard for me to use anything else. I like my lashes to practically EXPLODE off of my face!

  2. Amanda says:

    My most common and default mascara is of course black. For a night out or an everyday look it’s perfect to open up my eyes and the options are endless! However, I have taken on a new obsession with colored mascara, in particular Benefit’s BADgal collection. It comes in blue and plum – blue is perfect for the summer; plum is great to compliment this Fall’s most popular and trendy color purple.

    Colored mascara is great to switch it up every so often!

  3. shangrila says:

    ive been the opposite for the past year. my main mascara color is burgandy , and black is my next fav. i have dark skin and dark brown eyes and the burgandy color really “tricks” my eye color to look sorta greenish brown when i wear it. its pretty cool!

  4. Stargirl says:

    While I like colored mascara, it’s so much fun!!! I just love black mascara. I just love for my lashes to look super full and miles long and I haven’t found a colored mascara that can do that as well as any black mascara.

  5. Hillary says:

    i like black. but if mascara is one of the few things im wearing for makeup that day-brown. it makes my blue eyes brighter.

  6. Kellie says:

    I really want to try navy blue mascara.

  7. betsy says:

    My hair is black and so are my eyelashes…so black it is.
    I’ve tried blue and it didn’t work out too well, but i really want to give plum a try too!

  8. Jennifer says:

    Black! I’ve tried brown, blue, purple, and turquoise over the years, but black has always, always been right for me!

  9. Shortiee31 says:

    Black. Other colours wouldn’t show up as well and emphasise my eyelashes! x

  10. I’m a redhead so *technically* I’m supposed to be using brown. But I’m a makeup artist and don’t care what I’m supposed to do. ;)

    I always use the blackest black mascara available. My favorite is by Maybelline. :)

  11. Hildebryn says:

    I have used brown and brown-black, but I tend to switch between blue or black. I swear, blue makes blue eyes pop just a little more. And plain-old black is a workhorse.