Though you might not think this of me, but I like a more medium coverage highlighter so something super pigmented/requiring a very light hand to apply tends to go unused as I’ll reach for something luminous and foolproof first.
Anything that’s SUPER tacky (like glue!) or settles into every single lip line/goes on terribly unevenly. I wear gloss over lipsticks more often than alone, but I want a gloss that can be worn alone as well!
Lip balms that FEEL great going on but wear away in an hour two are really frustrating, as are ones that feel hydrating as long as they last but don’t seem to improve lips for the long-term. I love when they are smooth, lightweight, and wear a good amount of time.