Sunday, December 29th, 2013

Here is a compilation of my favorite budget-friendly lipsticks and lipglosses that I’ve tested over the past year! I’m really excited to have found an affordable, high-quality lip scrub this year. Bonus points for being an indie brand to boot! It does seem like 2013 was the year of bright lipstick–fuchsia, red, and orange!

What were your favorite budget-friendly lipsticks and lipglosses from the past year?

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

60 thoughts on “Top 10 of 2013: Best Drugstore/Budget Lipsticks and Lipglosses

  1. Avatar of Jennifer Jen

    Great picks! The new Revlon Lacquer Balms and the Milani Colour Statement lipsticks were definitely among my faves this year as well! xo

  2. I have honestly never heard of or noticed that lip scrub anywhere…and now I will not stop till I have it in my possession! Also, I’m surprised to see so much Maybelline on this list. At the drugstore I’m usually devouring the Revlon lip products. I must’ve just had a few bad experiences with Maybelline because they look beautiful!

  3. My best for lipstick is Milani Color Statement and my best for gloss is NYX Butter Gloss!
    Rikki Recently Posted: Real Techniques Duo-Fiber Face Brush: The Best Brush For Pigmented Blush

  4. Liz

    I am so surprised that no Revlon Super Lustrous lipsticks made the list. Didn’t you review a few this year? Anyway, they are some of the best lipsticks period, in my opinion. My favorite colors include Fire and Ice (pretty much the only red that I wear), Kiss Me Coral, Rum Raisin, and Toast of New York.

    • I did review some – http://www.temptalia.com/product/revlon-super-lustrous-lipstick – but they’re not a favorite for me. Not bad necessarily, just nothing that I would personally reach for based on what I’ve tried! They have almost no staying power, which is a deal-breaker for me most of the time (if it was a really unique color or something really special, I would deal with it!).

      • Liz

        Interesting. I’ve never noticed a problem with longevity. L’oreal colour riche is the only one that I’ve tried that has had serious longevity problems. Those seem to fade pretty quickly, even without eating or drinking.

        • Good to know – if those are quick on you, they might be warp speed on me, lol!

        • Avatar of Clare Clare

          I think the Shine formula wears off more quickly than the Cream formula. I prefer the Cream myself – love Siren in the summer!

          • Avatar of Amy xamyx

            I like both Revlon & L’Oréal, and staying power is with both is probably the best of what I’ve tried over the years. I attribute this to the comfort of the formulas, as I tend to rub my lips together if a product feels weird, which cause fading. The older Maybelline formulas were great, too, but I’m not in love with the Color Sensationals…

      • Avatar of Veronica Veronica

        I tend to think Revlon’s lipsticks are at their best with the reds and fuschias, but otherwise it’s not my favorite. I tend to think the glosses are the star of the lip line, really.

  5. The Maybelline ColorSensational Lipsticks are my top pick. I really love them!

    • The regular line I wasn’t as enamored with, but I LOVE the Vivids!!

      Do you have any recs from the regular range?

    • Liz

      I had one and really liked the color. But the scent and taste were unbearable to me. It was like freshly purchased play dough.

      • Avatar of Amy xamyx

        As I commented above, I’m not a big fan of the “regular” line, but I’ve never tried the Vivids, since I don’t do bright lips. However, in reading there is an apparent difference in formulation, I’m more imclined to try the “nude” collection. Perhaps there will be a difference?

        • Avatar of Veronica Veronica

          Are you talking about the new Buff line? I picked up the lightest shade the other day. I’d say the formula is comparable to the Vivids, so if you were interested in trying it, I’d say feel free to give it a go. :)

  6. Avatar of Melisa Melisa

    My favorite this year for lipgloss would be NYX butter gloss in Creme Brulee and Maple Blondie. Favorite lipstick are the Maybelline Color Sensationals.

  7. Eeeeeh just seeing all those pictures lined up like that is like maaaajor make-up porn, lol :-) Again fantastic picks!

  8. My favorite lip product from this year was the Neutrogena Lip Crayons. They are some of my favorites on the market.
    Cassie Recently Posted: My Favorite Posts of 2013

  9. I’m loving the budget compilations this year! The nyx soft matte lip creams are my all time favorite plus they smell divine!
    Lisha Recently Posted: The Body Shop Vanilla Bliss Body Butter Review

    • One of my goals last year was to include more drugstore/budget-friendly reviews, and I definitely improved, as there were so many picks to choose from that I ended up with three posts! (Last year, there was just one!)

  10. Avatar of Clare Clare

    My absolute favorite drugstore lipgloss is Revlon Colorburst. I’ve probably got about a dozen by now, thank god for BOGO sales!

  11. Avatar of beka beka

    maybelline color sensational is definitely my favorite drugstore lip product. i have a bunch of the vivids and a few of the regular ones…actually, i think i have most of the reds! i haven’t tried any of the milani because i don’t go to any stores that carry them.

  12. Avatar of Jackie Jackie T

    Definitely the NYX butter glosses and Revlon lip butters

  13. Avatar of Erica Erica

    I fell in love with the Milani lipsticks this year. I bought too many to mention, but Teddy Bare is my fave. The Maybelline Color Sensational Vivids lipsticks are 1st runner up. My favorites are Orange Edge and Midnight Plum. I have a few of the glosses too.

  14. CeeBee

    Jordana Twist & Shine Moisturizing Balm Stains in Cranberry Crush, Honey Love and Tropical Frenzy – adore the formula on these and they last SO well, especially if you layer the colour on!

    Milani Colour Statement lipsticks in Uptown Mauve (cool, vivid magenta purple) and Plumrose (neutral berry cream).

    NYX Soft Matte Creams in Milan and Sao Paulo.

    MUA Power Pout in Crazy in Love, Broken Hearted and Justify. These are a little softer and glossier than the Jordana ones but I really do love both formulas.

  15. Avatar of Abigail abigailod

    I’ve had good experience with Maybelline, and now im very curious in Revlon! Thanks for the list!

  16. Avatar of Barbie Barbie

    maybelline <3333

    but nyx butter glosses <333333

  17. Miss J

    I don’t usually pick up many lip products from the drugstore, but I thought the Revlon Matte Balm was this year’s standout drugstore product for lips.

  18. Maybelline Hotplum! Loved the shade!
    Vineetha Recently Posted: Must-Have Eye Makeup Brushes

  19. I can’t wait til the Revlon Lacquer Balms actually turn up in this country (we only just got the new Super Lustrous Lipglosses!) – looks like exactly my sort of thing!!

    My best ‘drugstore’ lip product purchase this year would have to be the two Nyx Butter Glosses that I picked up in a Douglas in Germany. They’re so comfortable, they smell great, they look good and they don’t hurt your wallet!

  20. Avatar of Cat CatG

    Revlon Colorburst in Fire and NYX Cosmo both impressed me a lot. And I love the Milani Color Statements, Best Red is amazing.

  21. Avatar of Urfa StrangeOne

    I so blame you for all the Maybelline vivids in my cupboard :P