Saturday, December 3rd, 2011

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow ($18.00 for 0.11 oz.) is described as a “copper spice.” It’s a gorgeous shade of bronze-shimmered medium brown with copper-red undertones. The hue reminded me of Make Up For Ever #15 when it is sheered out (when it’s opaque, it’s much too bronze and deep). Bare Escentuals The Truth is also quite similar, perhaps a bit redder. Shades like MAC Make Your Mark and MAC Buckwheat are noticeably darker.

Brandy Dandy has strong warm undertones, but paired with cool grays, taupes, or blues, could work on cooler complexions. Dandy Brandy pairs well with Fawn Over Me or Bikini Line for a quick and easy look of light/dark contrast with a lot of underlying warmth. It’s a good staple shade for those who love warm browns, but it’s certainly a shade that many brands have, so check your stash first for similarities.

Benefit recommends sweeping it on over bare lids for sheer color and layered over their cream eyeshadow for richer color. The super soft texture of the finely-milled powder makes it effortless to blend to a soft wash, but it doesn’t require building to get opaque color (see the swatch!) either. The Velvet Eyeshadows have a dense quality to them, and combined with their softness, makes them feel buttery and almost creamy (but they’re powder, I promise!). I’ve been a fan of Benefit’s eyeshadows for years now, and for those seeking softer shades overall, I recommend checking out the range. ¬†As a bonus, each eyeshadow is double the size of your average eyeshadow!

The Glossover

P
product

Dandy Brandy

A+
There are only things to love and like about this product--I have no complaints! I could not think of any criticism for the formula; the only thing I could point out is that it may not be the most original shade, so whether it's a must-have merely depends on what you already own!

Product

10/10

Pigmentation

10/10

Texture

10/10

Longevity

10/10

Application

5/5

Results
Loading ... Loading ...
Dupes
Login or Register to be able to add this to your Vanity or Wishlist! Plus rate and review!

See more photos & swatches!

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow
Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow

Product & Review FAQ

Where can I purchase it? How much is it?

Benefit, $18.

Is it limited edition?

No.

Any dupes?

The hue reminded me of Make Up For Ever #15 when it is sheered out (when it's opaque, it's much too bronze and deep). Bare Escentuals The Truth is also quite similar, perhaps a bit redder. Shades like MAC Make Your Mark and MAC Buckwheat are noticeably darker.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

37 thoughts on “Benefit Dandy Brandy Eyeshadow Review, Photos, Swatches

  1. Lilian

    Is it just me or it looks like snakebit and smog put together from the Naked pallets?.. Love the color anyway!..:) thank you for the review as always its a pleasure seeing what you have to say!.. Lili <3

  2. Michelle

    how does it compare to UD toasted

  3. alison

    I love this one! Dandy Brandy and Bikini Line was my go to look over the summer. :) id love to get more when I have a little more money.

  4. This looks beautiful! I’m just not sure if it’s so unique.. I feel like I have other shadows very similar to it. But it may not be once they are right next to each other!

  5. Nix

    Great review even if the shade is not the most original–will there be any more individual reviews of Benefit Velvet shadows?
    The reason I am asking is because Fawn Over Me has been on my mind for the longest time. But the shade’s popularity leads a constant “out of stock” at my local beauty stores-I can’t even swatch the color to get a feel for the product!

    On another note, would Dandy Brandy be anything like MAC Mulch? It has red undertones and is very ‘bronze’ on me (supper pale, neutral undertones)

    • I have another one lined up, but nothing else – I know I’ve reviewed *most* of the range already in the past!

      I’d say Dandy Brandy is a little less bronze but similar.

      • Nix

        I know, there are lovely swatches of the spring 2010 lineup as well as the original review of the six eyeshadow colors. My bet is that the next review will be for Where There’s Smoke, which looks nothing like the color swatch on the Benefit’s website.

        The hunt (ha!) for Fawn Over Me continues…

  6. rachel

    i really don’t like anything by benefit. i know you gave it 10/10 for pigmentation, but I just don’t! lol

  7. Allie

    I love this shadow! I use it almost every day with Leggy :) Rich Beach is a nice brown shade as well too

  8. Gina

    That is a TON of eyeshadow! And for only $18, that’s not bad at all! I really ought to take a peek at some of Benefit’s shadows. I’ve never really paid attention to them, and I’m not sure why!

    • Yep! The best part is they’re pretty neutral – so they’re the kinds of shades you could use a lot and for years, no matter how your tastes change!

  9. Tabitha

    I really like Benefit products but I’ve never tried their eyeshadows. They sound great– and this one is beautiful!

  10. Jenny

    I used to use Benefit shadows all the time but then they discontinued the entire line. I suppose to revamp them but they dq’ed all my favorite shades.

  11. Marta

    Pity, because I love the colour and the brand, but in the Naked & Preen palettes there are already bronzes and I don’t need any more. This shade is so much warmer and brown tan UD’s bronzes though, really pretty. Only thing I dislike is that it’s a single; I really prefer palettes or at least duos because they make more sense space-wise… can it be depotted, like MAC singles, to put it in a Z-palette?

  12. Emily

    It looks amazingly true-to-pan! Benefit’s been swaying me lately – I’m almost a convert! If only their blushes were such great value (like they used to be)!

  13. Avia

    What a beautiful color!

    I thought the name of this eyeshadow sounded familiar; you reviewed/swatched this a couple years ago… Wow, there’s a huge difference between the product photo now and then! :o Funny how that happens. :)

  14. I only have 3 of Benefits eyeshadow (and this is one of them) and I love them all, I don’t think they’re talked about enough! I’ve got my sights set on Fawn Over Me next, what do you think of that one?

  15. I love this shade, it’s one of my essential’s for quite a long time now.

  16. This is a really pretty color, but I can’t help feeling like I probably already have a couple of shades that are very close to it… I’ve never tried Benefit’s powder shadows, though, I will have to keep my eyes open since you like the formula so much! Benefit as a brand has been hit-or-miss for me, and I had just written off the eye shadows without paying much attention to them.

  17. Ashley

    I agsped when I saw this review; I’ve been raving about the shadow to anyone and everyone since I got it months and months ago. It’s one of my HG shadows, I love it! I also have Rich Beach, which is pretty :)