Tuesday, December 6th, 2011

Temptalia Asks You


Are luxury skincare products worth it? Share your experiences!

Temptalia's AnswerI’m still fortunate enough that I don’t have very many signs of aging, so much of luxury skincare is all about anti-aging, which is difficult for me to assess efficacy on, so I haven’t found that they are or are not. I like the consistencies and absorption of a lot of higher end products, though.

Thanks to Senem for today’s question! Got a question idea? Submit yours here.

Discussion and debate are highly encouraged, and we expect community members to participate respectfully. When asking a question, please check the FAQ section (above) for information about purchasing, price, dupes, and the like. If you have general feedback or need technical support, please contact us.

Comments that include advertisements, self-promotion, insults, etc. may be in violation of our comment policy and subject to deletion. Please see our comment policy for more information.

37 thoughts on “Are luxury skincare products worth it?

  1. The only luxury skin care brand I’ve tried is Yon-Ka, as I’ve won it in giveaways. I honestly think I get better results from my Olay Beauty Fluid. Maybe the creams I’ve won are just not for me, but couldn’t imagine spending $50 for a product that gives me similar results to a $7 product.

  2. Kristine

    Definitely! Lower end skincare makes me breakout a lot but when I switched, it really made a big difference on how my skin felt and looked! I use Guerlain and I LOVE it!

  3. Anila

    I can’t say much about the anti aging benefits either. My concern has been dry skin, sensitivity,SPF , and moisturizers that double as makeup bases. Even thoughI have tried both drugstore and high end products , my three best r high end: guerlain aqua serum , Chanel antiwrinkle day fluid SPF 15, and shu uemera redjuvenus emulsion! Still no luck with a decent night cream. I am halfway thru bobbi brown Eye cream and I like it so far. So I guess i would say if you can afford it high end products do deliver but I cant completely rule out drugstore products either. But don’t fall for all the claims and do your research.

  4. Roo

    I’m willing to pay more for beautiful packaging with luxury cosmetics or fragrances but the only thing I’m willing to pay more for in skin care is ingredients and formulation. Some ingredients are very expensive to source or to formulate so they maintain effectiveness. I’m willing to pay for those if I know they work for me. In the case of anti-aging ingredients, I can’t really tell if they’re working so I need science to back them up.

  5. I dont know if the luxury skin care products are worth it, but I only buy them. La Mer, Sisley, Clarins, Santa Maria Novella….cant even fathom buying drug store brand skin care.

  6. Tuss

    Totally depends on the brand and all, but overall I think it’s better

  7. Yazmin

    Ive not tried much luxury skincare, i think the most expensive i tried was the Nars brightening serum which retails at aabout £50pounds in the uk for a tub. But it was just like any skin illuminator, and i didnt notice any difference, so for what ive tried i would say no.

    What i wanted to try i would say no as well, i was really wanting a creme de la mer, because i heard miracles about it, and then after reading reviews i clicked on an article by the daily mail beauty column (i think but it was a british tabloid) that made nearly the same formula with £19.30 or something like that, and the same amount was being retailed at £1550.00! If i hadnt had known the £19.30 i probably would have said its worth it, but not right now if one of the most expensive things on the market could be duped for twenty pounds worth of ingredients.

  8. Avatar of Katherine katherine

    I’ve tried a great many high end and luxury brand skincare for antiaging and I have always gone back to using Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair. I do have mature skin and I have found that it works the best for me. My only wish is that I had started using it in my 30′s rather than late 40′s. I don’t use any of their other serums, just night repair and I use it morning and evening. I am currently using their time zone moisturizer and it’s fine. Just fine though, I’m not particularily overjoyed with it but it works as advertised.

  9. Avatar of Mariella Mariella

    For me, it’s not about “luxury brands”, per se, but more about high quality products that deliver and do what they say they will do. I’ve recently started using 3 products from a Canadian company called Jouviance and I am amazed by how good they are and by the effects I’ve seen in just a few days. These aren’t cheap products but they’re also not up there with La Mer and some of the stuff from Guerlain and Clarins. So it’s not so much the hype of luxury or the hype of advertising or “exclusivity” and more about whether they are truly effective.

    • Stephanie thurston

      I wish I could use jouviance but it burns my skin and makes it peel :( even though it has no crap like perfumes or parabins etc. Something in it hates my skin! It’s still a great sell for my customers though, especially the anti aging cream.

  10. Avatar of kyra Chiara

    I do personally not care for fancy packaging, extravagant yet obscure ingredients and alluring advertisements. I want the best ingredients, backed up by independent research, in optimal concentrations and adequately formulated. Otherwise I am just wasting my money. So to me the whole concept of “luxury skincare” is pointless. No comparison with medical strength lines or in office dermatology treatments! For example, years ago I received a gift bag of Kanebo products (suited for my skin type) and it gave me an awful case of cosmetic acne in less than a week. I also had the chance to try several La Prairie, La Mer and Sisley products that didn’t produce any of the spectacular results that I have instead been experiencing with SkinMedica, Environ and Retin A in terms of preventing signs of aging and keeping breakouts at bay. Today at -almost- 34 I have beautiful clear skin with no lines. So my suggestion for everyone would be to educate yourself on skin biology and ingredients, in order to choose what’s really going to work for you, instead of being suckered into false promises.
    Happy holidays to everybody!

    • Laura

      Totally agree with this. In my opinion, most of the very high end products are absolutely no better than what you can find in the drugstore; certainly, you can’t tell from the price of an item how well it’s going to work at its stated purpose. I think skin care is definitely an area in which “you get what you pay for” is an inaccurate phrase.

  11. Avatar of Ana Ana G.

    Well, I do think you can see differences between high-end products and the others – more in smell, absorption rates and packaging. Are they more effective that others? I’m not sure. I’ve used Matis creams in the past and now I’m using La Roche Posay and, to be honest, can’t really tell the difference (except on my wallet). However, for specific cases such as pigmentation spots, stretch marks, eczema, I find that high end brands are better.

  12. NeenaJ

    I don’t think so. For me, it’s more important to look at the ingredients rather than the brand. The use of actives in the proper concentrations with the right packaging and delivery mechanism to preserve them is critical. Sure, I could pay $100 for a high end Vitamin C serum but if it’s in a jar instead of a airless pump, I might as well have flushed that money straight down the toilet.

    Lots of brands make great products for small price tags: Neutrogena, Paula’s Choice, Cereve, Olay, etc. And if you’re crafty and have a hankering for playing science project, there’s always the DIY route.

  13. Kathy S.

    Is Bobbi Brown considered luxury skin care? Her eye cream and moisturizer are both worth it. I had a period of seriously dry skin and the moisturizer fixed me right up. The eye cream is actually firming. Nice stuff. I’d prefer something that had more natural ingredients, but I can’t argue with the results.

  14. Shilpa

    For the most part YES, but I do have a limit to how much I will spend, and I’m not impressed with every luxury line. Always willing to dish it out for La Mer, Clarins, Sisley, Darphine, Erno Lazlo, Cle de Peau, Elemis and Fresh. I don’t think La Prairie or Guerlain or Shiesedo do anything for my skin. Like you, Christine, I love the consistencies and absorption of luxury lines. Anti- aging is just starting to be a concern, but also, I love luxury cleansers and toners!

  15. I think that some of them are, but I have found organic coconut oil to be the best skincare product ever. I don’t need anything else, yet. Plus products like ROC are continuously hailed as the best anti-agers with a great track record.

  16. Liz

    I am personally not a fan of drugstore skincare products. Using it in the past, I never had clear skin. I would always have acne, various old scars, etc. I would be drinking lots of water and a solid skincare routine but I never saw really awesome results. Switching to higher end really made a difference, and I can imagine that luxury skincare would be beneficial. I used to be for drugstore, but now I am rooting for higher end products. Even trying a sample of saloon shampoo has made overnight differences in my hair!

  17. Anne-Sophie

    When you buy a Olay (regular brand, not the ProX) or whatever, the percentage of active ingredients is ridiculously low compared to dermo-cosmetic brands like Avene, LaRochePosay, or ROC. And for high end brands, they often use very pricey anti-aging ingredients OR they use the same basic ingredient as the drugstore low price brand, but 10 times more concentrated and they sell a complete product which will hydrate your skin AND help with wrinkles.

    If I was rich, I would buy these La Mer skin cares or Guerlain… But I’ve tried Avene, LaRochePosay, ROC, Lise Watier, and they were fine, and then I tried Clarins and Lancôme and they are amazing. :) I’ve seen the difference from like Garnier to Avene, and then from Avene to Lancôme… I think that you often pay for what you get.

  18. I think when it comes to face washes, you can stick to drugstore. I’ve used very expensive foaming cleansers from NARS, Shiseido and Estee Lauder and they worked the exact same way as my St. Ives Green Tea Cleanser which is only $5. In my opinion Salicylic Acid is all the same, no point in spending $45 on a cleanser that works the same as Neutrogena! (just watch out for drying sulfates)

    In terms of treatments, I think high end is better, but not all high end brands are created equal. You have to look at the ingredients.

    For a long time I used a Retinol cream from DDF. I thought it was pretty potent since it cost $85. After I finished it I switched to Skinceuticals 0.5 Retinol. Since I was using the DDF everday for 6 months I jumped right into the Skinceuticals thinking my skin was already “used” to it. Big mistake! My skin peeled and burned, because it turns out the DDF product (though its cost $35 more than Skinceuticals) was formulated with a watered down, less potent form of Retinol, while Skinceuticals is pure Retinol.

    That difference is going to mean a lot in terms of effectiveness and wrinkle prevention. Just do your homework and remember the only two proven anti-agers are Vitamin C and Retinol. Everything else is just over hyped claims for the most part! :)

  19. shelley

    My skin is a priceless asset so I refuse to gamble on drugstore brands that are labeled as one size fits all kind of mindset. With combination skin that is aging and sensitive I have yet to find a drugstore brand that addresses my needs. I’ve dabbled with many brands, high and low, it wasn’t till recently that I found a brand that fit all my needs and then some. Almost $400 for a complete program I’ve been insanely happy with the results from my high end skincare line. As mom used to say;”You get what you pay for.”

  20. M.

    I’ve never been impressed with any of the luxury skincare products I’ve tried in comparison to Neutrogena and (sometimes) Garnier, so I don’t think they’re worth it for my sensitive-yet-oily skin.

  21. Gina

    Like any products, some are worth it and some aren’t. Skin is like a fingerprint and everyone is different and will respond differently to each product…hence there are hundreds of choices out there. It may not have worked for me, but hey, you may love it. For this reason, I’ve never really gone with other’s reviews on skincare and always like to try it for myself. I.e., everyone says use Aveeno, Cetaphil, Neutrogena…those products made my skin a broken out mess. One cream that I have to shout out (sadly for my bank account!) is Creme de la Mer. It has transformed my skin, and when I’m off of it, I can see a difference. Sure, the other creams aren’t bad, but they definately aren’t as good. But luxury creams are exactly that…a luxury, and its there for those who can afford it. You are paying for quality of ingredients, processes used to activate them, texture, etc. Now, if I could only afford this luxury habit year round…:P

  22. Caiti

    Depends on your skin…mine is very dry, sensitive and acne prone, which means I need to avoid a long list of common ingredients. Like a few previous posters, I rely on coconut oil, almond oil, and other very simple moisturizers.

    I’ve used higher end sunblock (physical blocks, not sunscreen)since I was in my early 20s and that has prevented the need for major anti-aging measures…so far! (I’m 42.)

  23. Sarah Karenina

    Sometimes, luxury products are just a joke. For instance, the new Lancôme serum (Visionnaire in French, don’t know if the name is the same in English). It contains a lot of silicone, and the star actif is in the last ingredients. The same for the cleansers, most of them contains sodium laureth sulfate which makes your skin dry. I’m really not convinced. I prefer organical products like Dr Hauscka products, which are more effective.

  24. Stephanie thurston

    YES! At least when your skin is lame like mine. I get lines that cut between my eyesockets and my cheek bone from dehydration , as well as dry skin under my eyes which was from an allergic reaction to jouviance. The only only thing that worked was lancomes absolue precious cells night cream. It makes my skins surface look perfect, I don’t cAre if it’s for aging skin it’s a wonderful cream and totally worth it. But I do get lancome discounts so maybe that’s why it doesn’t bust my bank/:

  25. Lauren

    A few months back I read article on the Daily Mail about this older woman who spent a good 30 years buying expensive high end skincare products. In the end her skin was saggy and deeply wrinkled. In fact she ended up spending big bucks having plastic surgery. That article really opened my eyes about skincare. Because in the end having firm and youthful skin all boils down to your genetics. IMO, aside from giving your skin hydration, the main purpose for moisturizers is to prevent/combat wrinkles. For that I use prescription retin A, sun screen, and my cheapish yet effective jar of ceravae moisturizer. I have been using this method since I was 14, now that I’m pushing my late 20′s I have yet to any wrinkles, even around my delicate eyes!

  26. lunohodik

    la prarie – rose illusion cellular treatment line filler, cellular balancing mask
    la mer toner and lip balm

    • lunohodik

      sk II illuminating serum, and eye cream
      natura bisse top ten cream, lip boost, toner, glycolic eye cream(I’m not sure if NB is a Luxe though:)

  27. Van

    After agonizing about the price for the longest time, I bought a 15 ml bottle of Caudalie eye cream. Well, I certanly didn’t expect miracles but it didn’t do absolutely anything for my skin or wrinkles – it did the opposite, it enhaced the wrinkles under my eyes, not by much but enough for my coworkers to tell me I look tired a lot lately.
    I had better results with Burt’s Bees radiance eye cream.

  28. Monica

    I’m in my 40′s and if anti-aging products worked, then all the 40+ women would look like 20 yr olds and (sadly) we don’t :-P

    Best anti-aging advice is to avoid high carb, sugar indulgences and wear sunscreen .. then you won’t have to waste money on ‘anti-aging’ product :-)

    M.

  29. LollipopSiouxsie

    I’d say that luxury skincare products are worth it if, and only if, you think you can see and feel a visible difference in your skin. I’ve tried numerous luxury products that make extravagant claims and command a hefty price tag but turn out to be no better than a cheap drugstore equivalent. The only luxury product I use is Estee Lauder DayWear moisturiser. I was given a sample pot last year and I was very impressed with the results after using it daily for six weeks, so I decided to buy it. I love it because it delivers just the right amount of hydration, it doesn’t aggravate my acne, the texture is lovely, and it smells nice too. The only reason I don’t use something cheaper is because nothing so far is as good on my skin as DayWear. For everything else besides moisturiser, I choose products that are natural (preferably organic), ethically sourced, and cruelty free. At the moment I’m using a face wash by a company called Naked, and a bottle only costs £4.49. I could probably buy a product that came in fancier packaging, cost three times as much, and did exactly the same thing, but why bother when everything I want is sold at Boots and costs less than a fiver?

    • TLC

      Unequivocal yes, the right luxury brand can make a marked difference in skin care. I use a combination of Dior and Kiehl’s, which, along with my Clarisonic Mia, have improved my skin immensely. I am 44-years-old and am questioned regularly about the health and radiance of my facial skin.

  30. Nicole

    Only spf actually prevents aging, and you can get that from a cheap product. I would just stick to lower-end products with a sunscreen every day if your skin doesn’t have any problems.